Muskogee Daily Phoenix investigates Watts
Media Review
Donna Hales of the Muskogee Daily Phoenix and Times-Democrat crafted the best print piece to date on Watts, Oklahoma asking how a "tiny town of 303 residents" can generate 97 percent of their city revenue from traffic fines.  Actually, the number is 97.5, but it is close enough to shame Watts Mayor Phyllis Hagan.

Hagan said, "The money has not profited the town one iota -- it just supports the police.  We don't even have swings on the swing set at the park."  She said the town is going into the red.

The story also details fear of the Watts Police by the local residents.  Mayor Hagan said, "People are scared to death of this police force -- from school kids up and down the spectrum."  The Mayor said she gets many calls from citizens afraid to speak out publicly.  One elderly woman called to tell her: "I keep telling 'em we need to stand up -- they can't arrest us all."

One could suggest, however, that with only 303 residents, the Police Commissioner, Chief of Police, and four officers could in time arrest them all.  Of course, that is more similar to how the Serbs run things in Yugoslavia -- arrest the targets, drive them out, or kill them.

Commissioner Fain said his officers instill a sense of peace, not fear, by enforcing the law.  Fain said town trustees gave him authority more like that of a town manager than a police commissioner.  He is responsible for supervising the deputy city clerk and manages most of the town's business.

Fain's poor records
Hales writes that the Phoenix made two trips to review Watts records, which are public and by law should be available during office hours.  Apparently, following law is a very selective activity of the Police in Watts, Oklahoma.

"The day the Phoenix first sought records, year-end accounting reports were locked in Fain's office.  Employees said they couldn't release any records in Fain's office.  Fain met with the Phoenix on a second visit to the police station.  But some records still weren't available.  Fain produced only a summary of the number of tickets written from mid August to mid September, but the documents to back up those compilations and earlier speeding citations were not yet in order and filed, he said."

Reporter Hales compares Watts with 303 people and six police officers to the town of Warner, 20 miles south of Muskogee with a population of 1,479 and a police force of four officers.

Law breaking quota
Hales also found a January memo from Fain to all police officers that doesn't mention a ticket writing quota, but noted officers were writing "fewer and fewer" tickets.  "I must remind all of you this is what pays the bills, your bills," Fain wrote.  "So let's pick our feet up and get our activity up!"

Ticket writing quotas are against the law in Oklahoma.  A former Watts police officer called Tulsa Today and said that if they did not write five tickets per day or more in Watts that officers understood that they would be fired by Commissioner Fain.

Rep. Larry Adair, D-Stilwell helps Watts post signs
Oklahoma Department of Transportation spokesman Nico Gomex confirmed to the Phoenix that "No Tolerance" signs had been posted in the Watts area recently at the request of state Rep. Larry Adair, D-Stilwell.

Tulsa Today is pleased that Rep. Adair moved to help the Watts Police Commissioner cover his tail, but we wonder why the core issue some call police corruption has not yet gathered this esteemed lawmaker's attention.

Fixing tickets
Hales quotes Fain saying that despite recent allegations the town is operating a speed trap, he gets very few complaints personally.  Most of the people unhappy with him are people who have friends or relatives who have been given a speeding ticket he wouldn't "fix," Fain said.

Now stop here just a moment.  Tulsa Today respectfully suggests that if Fain would not fix some tickets then he is, in his own words, admitting that he will fix some.  Again, we ask are all men equal under the law or have we become soviets.

The commissioner
The Phoenix reports Watts Police Commissioner Gary Fain was an Oklahoma Highway Patrol trooper for 17 years before he took early retirement and accepted the police commissioner job at Watts.

He was hired August 4, 1997 on a four-year contract.

Fan is one of five people charged with promoting and conspiring to join an illegal pyramid scheme in a multi-county grand jury indictment unsealed last week. 

Tulsa Today will post with our next edition details of that indictment and specifics contained in the affidavit filed by Kelly Beach, Special Agent for the Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation.  Beach does report that Gary Fain was a leader of the "Friends Helping Friends" scheme, organized and attended such meetings while dressed in the uniform of the Oklahoma Highway Patrol.
 

Related Stories on speed traps
Watts amok by Dan Wofford (updated September 14, 1998)
As highwaymen of the Middle Ages robbed unwary travelers, the Watts Oklahoma Police Department fleeces money from unsuspecting modern travelers.  This village with sales tax collections of only $1,214 (April 1998) gathered $13,023.96 per month in speed trap revenue for the 10 month period reviewed by Tulsa Today. [MORE]

State Law (This page quotes state laws)
Arkansas, Missouri and Texas law clearly identify a speed trap as an abuse of police power.  They target the percentage of revenue (from 30 to 45 percent) as the way to identify such abuse.  Watts Police Commissioner Gary Fain has said his city earns 97.5 percent of their revenue from police activity.  [MORE]
 

Public Comments on Speed Traps
These are some of the funniest, saddest, shameless and strangest reader comments on any issue Tulsa Today has ever gathered.  One son of a former Watts Police Chief threatens to go to war with the current force.  Several residents requested their name be withheld, but their letters leave no doubt that they believe the current police administration is evil.  From around the nation, Oklahomans are outraged.  We did get one letter is support of the Watts Police Department, but it was unsigned.  The most common opinion is that the speed trap problem must be solved. [MORE]
 

Interview with Commissioner Bob Ricks
KJRH Anchor Chad Nye and Tulsa Today Publisher David Arnett conducted an interview with Commissioner Ricks.  The KJRH feature ran September 9 and this file contains additional detail from that interview.  Also in a KJRH/Tulsa Today interviesw, Watts Commissioner of Police Gary Fain admitted on camera that 97.5 percent of all municipal revenue is generated by the police department.  Ricks said that if that number is true, then certainly Watts Oklahoma is running a speed trap.

With a formal complaint, Ricks says he will investigate speed traps in Oklahoma.  However, the Oklahoma Legislature has not given the department the best tools to work with to fix the problem. 

Commissioner Ricks credits Tulsa Today for bringing Watts, Oklahoma to his attention and providing legal guidelines he will ask the Legislature to enact next session. [MORE]
 

The strange story of Mr. Roy Banks
"I have just heard about this story last night and I'm shocked that Roy Banks would sink so low.  I would prefer that my name is withheld because I'm a police officer who has to work with Roy Banks on occasion and my department wouldn't agree with me sending this message.

If David Arnett was not informed, I think he would like to know that Roy Banks is an Oklahoma Highway Patrol dispatcher.  He is stationed out of Troop C  (Muskogee) and used to be friends with Trooper Freeman prior to this incident."  [MORE]