Attachment Disorders Part I

The enemy within
by Linda Ann Smith
The smell of singed hair filled the classroom. A young girl grasped her smoldering pigtail and ran screaming to the teacher. Scott walked quietly to the front of the room. He dropped a book of matches and a scorched piece of paper into the wastebasket. He seemed unaware of the hysterical girl who was clinging to her third grade teacher.

The other students, paralyzed with horror, watched silently as Scott brushed ashes from his sleeve. On the way back to his seat, Scott spit on one of his classmates and "accidentally" bumped into another. As if nothing unusual had happened, Scott settled himself at his desk. Scott is an unattached child.

Healthy attachments begin in early infancy. The infant experiences pain, hunger, or discomfort and expresses rage by crying. The infant's primary caregiver (usually the mother) responds to the infant's rage reaction with eye contact, touch, motion, or food. The infant learns to trust his caregiver for comfort and the bonding process begins. This bonding cycle is repeated countless times during the infant's first year of life. Uninterrupted repetition of the cycle results in a strong trust bond between infant and caregiver.

Attachment disorders result when the infant's needs are not gratified. Kathy Miller, founder and president of The Attachment Network in Oklahoma, explains, "When an infant expresses rage and feels no relief for his need, he learns that to survive this world, he must control it. These children actually believe that if they release control to anyone else that they will die."

Unattached children are difficult to recognize. They deceive their elders with superficial charm while they scrutinize the environment. In school, as a teacher begins to establish a closer relationship to an unattached child, the negative behavior begins. The closer the teacher tries to get, the more the child rebels.

Scott's behavioral problems and lack of socialization skills were apparent when he entered kindergarten. Other children complained about his aggressive behavior and he became known as the playground bully. Each year, a new teacher tried to give him the opportunity for a fresh start.

"At first Scott smiled and seemed anxious to please. I began to wonder if his previous teachers had unintentionally provoked his negative behavior," admitted his third grade teacher. "Six weeks later, Scott was disruptive, impulsive, destructive. His mother refused to come to conferences and his father accused me of picking on his son."

Parents of unattached children, whether biological or adoptive, are usually angry, frustrated, and hostile. Because the child believes he was born into an unsafe world, he often directs his anger toward his mother or mother-figure. Outsiders (and often fathers) are not with the child as much and do not experience the mother's stressful situation. They view only the child's charming behavior. The child deliberately creates tension between his parents to satisfy his desire to manipulate and control. "The frustrated mother is pulling her hair out and looks crazy, while the father blames the mother for provoking the child," Miller explains. This conflict increases tension and the parents appear unreasonably angry.

Paul and Debbie were social workers who worked with abused children when they adopted severely abused twins. Almost immediately they knew that something was seriously wrong with one of their children. Their training and experience had not prepared them to parent a six-year-old who went into rages, knocked holes in the wall, overturned furniture, set fires, and planned the details of their murder.

They sought help from therapists and doctors, who suggested that the child's behavioral problems were so serious that the parents should consider giving up the child. Paul and Debbie ignored this advice and finally found a doctor who remembered hearing something about attachment disorders. He referred them to the Attachment Center at Evergreen, Colorado. The child was placed in therapy and the parents trained to help. "Parenting skills which we thought were wise were totally wrong for this child," Paul explained.

Paul and Debbie have no idea why only one of their twins is unattached. They do know that the infancy of both twins was similar to that of many other unattached children. Debbie said, "By the time they were four years old, they had been shuffled back and forth between an abusive biological family and eight different foster homes."

Any child who experiences great trauma, especially during the first eighteen months of life, is at high risk of developing an attachment disorder. Attachment problems can surface if an infant is separated from his primary caregiver due to foster care, divorce, death, illness or hospitalization. Abuse, neglect, teenage mothers with poor parenting skills, or emotionally absent mothers with chronic maternal depression, contribute to development of the disorder. Symptoms of unattached children include the following: 

Superficially charming
Abnormal eye contact
Extreme self-control problems
Manipulative, controlling
Destructive to self and others
Cruel to animals
Hoarding and hiding food or toys
Inability to connect cause with effect
Lack of conscience
Preoccupied with fire, blood and gore
Poor peer relationships
Stiffens when touched
Persistent nonsense questions, incessant chatter
Crazy, chronic, obvious lying
Refusal to show affection to parents
Learning lags and disorders

Some symptoms may be seen in many children, but unattached children display all or most of them. Traditional therapy methods will not work for these children. Severely unattached children, like Scott, must be referred to professionals who are knowledgeable about correct treatment of attachment disorders. The earlier the child is referred, the better the prognosis. Professionals can help these children battle the enemy within themselves.
 


 

Attachment Disorders Part II

Teaching teachers
by Linda Ann Smith
Editor's Note: In Part I of Tulsa Today's three part series, Linda Ann Smith explained the causes and symptoms of attachment disorders.

Unattached children display startling and bizarre behavior and seem to lack conscience for their actions. They are guided only by what they want at the moment. They have no regard for how their behavior impacts another human being.

Coping with the behavior of an unattached child in the classroom is one of the most demanding challenges teachers face. Unattached children are manipulative and self-centered. They have extreme self-control difficulties. However, they attempt to control everyone around them.

Discipline techniques may seem awkward to teachers who have never experienced the controlling behavior of a severely unattached child. Love and praise are simply not sufficient for these children. Unattached children learn trust only when they begin to give up control. 

The following tips for teachers are a collection of ideas from parents, teachers, and experienced professionals in the field:

1. Establish Eye Contact
Unattached children roll their eyes around in their sockets or look across the shoulder to avoid eye contact. insist that the child maintain normal eye contact during conversation. Be aware that unattached children will attempt to control the situation by initiating a "staring match." However, their eye contact is excellent when they are very angry or when they are manipulating someone. 

2. Establish Who Is Boss
When a child tries to manipulate, remind him in a calm, firm, controlled voice that you are the boss. Then ask the child, "Who is the Boss?" Reinforce the child's confirmation that the teacher is boss with a statement such as, "That's right. I'll be a good boss and a fair boss, but I am the boss."

3. Recognize The Child's Subtle Attempts To Control
Unattached children often deliberately omit parts of an assignment, letters, words, sentences, problem numbers, or their names. When instructed to sit down, they often choose an indirect path to their seats, meandering around the room before sitting. When assigned a certain number of repetitive exercises, they may choose to do a few more, or less, than requested. Acknowledge the number completed, and ask the child to begin again, until he produces the exact number of activities requested. This may require the child to repeat the activity several times.

4. Win All Control Battles
Structure all of the child's choices so that the teacher remains in control. For example, if you want the child to take his coat outside on a cold day, ask him/her, "Do you want to wear your coat or carry it?"

5. Recognize Good And Poor Decisions
Since these children have great difficulty with cause and effect relationships, everything they do should be related back to their ability to make decisions. Recognize good decisions as if you expected this behavior all along with a comment such as, "I see you made a good decision to finish your math." Recognize poor decisions with a similar suitable statement such as, "I see you chose to have incomplete work today. You may finish it at recess. Better luck next time."

6. Allow The Child To Accept Responsibility
Look for creative ways to allow the child to experience the natural consequences of his actions.

7. Be Consistent
Do not allow the child any slack. Confront each misbehavior and support each good behavior.

8. Remain Calm
A child who manages to upset the teacher is in control of the situation. Model and verbalize desired behavior.

9. Document Interactions And Observations Of The Child
It is not uncommon for unattached children to inflict injury upon themselves and claim abuse. They can easily assume the role of an abused child and manipulate outsiders to rescue them. Good documentation is necessary to help the educator remain objective if the child accuses parents or classmates of abuse. It may also prove helpful if the child accuses the teacher of abuse.

10. Request Help
Asking for help does not indicate that the teacher's skills are weak. Supportive administrators, and utilization of available resources, are invaluable especially for teachers of unattached children.

Educators must be willing to realize that some children should not remain in a regular classroom setting. In their book, High Risk: Children Without A Conscience, Dr. Ken Magi and Carole A. McKelvey say, "No teacher should be asked to work with severely unattached children who are so out of control that they are a danger to themselves and others. These children need to be referred for therapy."

"Many professionals who work with children are still not aware of attachment disorders," says Kathy Miller, former president of The Attachment Network. When Miller teaches educators about attachment disorders in staff development workshops, she stresses that children who are referred for therapy must be sent to professionals who are knowledgeable about correct treatment of the disorder. "Traditional therapy is not successful with these children," she says.

The Attachment Network, a nonprofit organization of concerned parents and professionals who assist families with unattached children, was incorporated in the State of Oklahoma in September, 1989. Miller explains, "One of the goals of The Attachment Network is to provide education about attachment disorders and unattached children to families, mental health professionals, and educators."

For additional information about attachment disorders, write or call: 

The Attachment Network 
P.O. Box 2401
Broken Arrow, Oklahoma 74013
(918) 455-3873 

Attachment Disorders Part III

Dear Mom
by Linda Ann Smith
I'm only a baby, and to become emotionally well-adjusted later I need your help!  Do you think it will hurt Dad's feelings that I asked you first?  I hope not.  His love and care are very important to me too! 

Mom, I already have a special relationship with you.  Before I was born, I knew the warmth of your body, the rhythm of your heartbeat and the sound of your voice.  Now a stronger bond with you will help me learn to trust others for physical and emotional comfort.

When you see my sweet little face, can you imagine that later I could develop severe behavior problems or even commit serious crimes?  Probably not!  But if I fail to bond now I could develop an attachment disorder and have difficulty with human relationships when I become and adult.  Failure to bond with my parent(s) places me at high risk for growing into a manipulative, controlling, "unattached child" without a conscience and with extreme self-control problems.  We don't have any time to waste!  It's important that I develop strong emotional attachments with my primary caregiver within the first eighteen months of my life.

I could develop an attachment disorder if I experience abuse, neglect, or poor parenting skills.  I need to trust you for comfort and won't understand if you are not aware that I am in pain or why you cannot always stop my pain.  Attachment problems could arise if our bonding cycle is interrupted due to illness, hospitalization, divorce, or death.  It can be dangerous for me to experience numerous changes in childcare, or an "emotionally absent" mother due to chronic maternal depression, drug abuse, or a severe psychiatric disorder.  Gee, Mom, that's a lot of responsibility for you, but don't get disouraged.

Healthy bonding is simple.  My part is to cry when I'm hungry, uncomfortable, or in pain.  Every time I cry, I have a need.  It may be a physical or an emotional need, but it is a need.  Your part is to soothe me with eye-contact, touch, motion, or food so I'll learn to trust you.  If my parents want me to understand that I can trust them, they must respond each time I cry.  Some people will say that you are spoiling me.  Please don't listen! 

Experts agree that I cannot be spoiled during my first two years of life.  Every time you comfort me when I cry, I'll learn to trust you and our bond will grow stronger.  When you respond to my cries over and over without interruption, I will learn that my enviroment is safe.

How will you know if I am forming healthy attachments?  You'll recognize when I cry and you meet my needs, that I can be soothed.  dI'll gradually stop crying.  I will enjoy close contact, cuddling and playing.  I'll smile, chortle, giggle and seem happy.  My eyes will seek faces, especially yours, Mom, and I'll fixate on your eyes.  I'll have a strong sucking response and watch your face while nursing.  Though I may display a variety of emotions, including anger and sadness, I'll seem "normal" and glow with enthusiasm for life.

Do you hear a baby crying?  That's me!  I'm just telling you that I want to get started on our bonding cycle right now!

Love,
Baby

Symptoms of unattachment
Don't panic if you observe an occasional sign of unattachment.  Bonding and attachment require time.  However, you should be aware of these symptoms.  Babies with many of these symptoms might be a high-risk for developing an attachment disorder:

1.)  ABNORMAL CRYING PATTERNS -- very weak or very rageful crying, crying without tears, or constant whining.
2.)  EXTREMELY RESISTANT TO CUDDLING -- arches back or stiffens body in protest, doesn't conform to contours of parent's body when held, and fights to be set free from cuddling or physical touch.
3.)  RESISTS EYE CONTACT -- turns gaze away from parents, uncomfortable with close face-to-face encounters.
4.)  NO SMILING RESPONSE -- seems passive and ignores smiles of others, does not exchange smiles even with parents.
5.)  NO INTEREST IN PLAYING -- does not "coo" or gurgle in response to gentle tickling or playful gestures.
6.)  NURSING DIFFICULTIES -- does not adapt well to nursing, may fail to sevelop strong sucking responses.
7.)  NOT "NORMAL" -- displays no sign of strong attachment to any other human, lacks zest for living.

Helping Baby Bond
Babies learn about their environment through their five senses:  touch, sight, hearing, tast, and smell.  When parents provide the kind of nurturing and care the baby needs, the five senses are positively stimulated.  To promote healthy bonding, keep these tips from your baby in mind:

TOUCH -- Each time I am held, I experience the sense of touch.  When I cry, I learn that someone will respond by picking me up to investigate my need.  When my diaper is changed, my sense of touch is relieved from irritability.  My discomfort after feeding is relieved by patting to help me burp.  My need for emotional comfort is soothed by cuddling, patting, or rocking.  I sense my parents' feeling of tension or relaxation through my sense of touch.

SIGHT -- If I am held facing away from my parents, I am robbed of the eye contact I need.  Studies show that very young babies prefer faces (especially their mother's face) over other visual stimulation.  Hold me face-to-face to promote healthy bonding.

HEARING -- I need a balance of quiet time and auditory stimulation.  I need quite time for rest, but I also need my parents to talk to me.  I enjoy hearing my parents' voices when they read or sing.

TASTE -- Taste is stimulated when I am fed.  I begin to associate relief from hunger with my sense of taste.  Feeding time is an especially important time for me to be touched and nurtured.  If I am left alone to eat or with a bottle propped up on a pillow, I might not understand that my parents are involved in my relief from hunger.  Since I need food to live, holding me will help me understand that I can trust my parents to provide my needs.

SMELL -- The smell of dirty diapers and soured milk is just as offensive to me as it is to adults.  I use my sense of smill to help me identify people and places.  To learn that my environment is a safe and pleasant place, I need clean, fresh aromas.