Yearly Archives: 2008

Voter identification fight continues

House Republicans expressed disappointment over the death of legislation yesterday that would have required identification to vote.

Senate Bill 1150 provided for a long list of identification options, including a free, state-issued voter ID card, a copy of a utility bill or a driver’s license. It also included language that would have allowed Oklahomans to vote without identification if they signed an affidavit attesting to their identity.

The bill was killed by Senate Democrats in a party line vote Tuesday.

Last week, the Supreme Court ruled in favor of an Indiana voter ID law that requires photo identification at the polls, citing the need to reduce voter fraud.

“Apparently the Senate Democrats who worked to block this legislation don’t care about the opinion of the U.S. Supreme Court or eliminating voter fraud in our state,” said Rep. Sue Tibbs, R-Tulsa. “Oklahomans need to have confidence that their vote will count, and they will not trust a system where anyone can vote without having to prove they are eligible.”

This legislation would not have prevented anyone on the state voter rolls from voting, Tibbs said, but instead would have reinforced the notion that each and every vote counts in Oklahoma.

Tibbs vowed to continue the fight to require voter identification in Oklahoma.

“I will continue to push this common sense legislation until it becomes law,” said Tibbs.

TCC campaigns for expansion

Thursday, 08 May 2008
On Tuesday, Tulsans have an opportunity to vote on a growth proposal for Oklahoma’s most successful community college – Tulsa Community College asks that day for voter approval of a $76 million package to be funded by a permanent tax increase from 7 mills to 8.7 mills and a seven-year bond issue.

The proposal specifies improvements and additions at all campus locations throughout Tulsa County and adds a new facility in Owasso.

Voters approved a bond issue for TCC in 1999 that was paid in 2004.  Since 1999, student enrollment at TCC has increased more than 20 percent.  The last millage increase for TCC was approved in 1994.  The bond issue is for capital improvements and the millage increase is for operating expense.

In a morning campaign kick-off on April 29, TCC President Dr. Tom McKeon spoke of success and the need to continue growth of one of Oklahoma’s top institutions of higher education.

“Since 1970, TCC has served nearly 400,000 students.  That’s more than the official population of the City of Tulsa.  On May 13, the citizens of Tulsa County will have an opportunity to vote on a capital bond package that will provide $76 million in new facilities for the students of Tulsa Community College, located on all four existing campuses and the City of Owasso,” McKeon said.

“This proposal represents strong collaboration that will create both efficiencies and improvements in higher education.  In Owasso, we will build a new facility on land donated by the citizens of that community, and we will work with Tulsa Technology Center to combine key student resources as they bring their Owasso facility online next door to our site.

“With the City of Tulsa, we are also sharing land and construction costs.  This will occur at the Northeast Campus when we provide land to the City and share costs of construction of a top quality regional fire and emergency training facility and classroom building.  Together, Tulsa and TCC will be creating one of the finest fire training departments and emergency preparedness teams in the region, and we will be sharing those resources with area municipal, rural and volunteer departments,” McKeon said. “[In both cases], we are taking taxpayer dollars and stretching them further.”

“This bond issue and millage election will mean jobs; as we work with local hospitals and clinics to expand our nursing and allied healthcare programs.  As we increase the number of students that can take our education and business programs, we are creating a more skilled and job-ready work force.  Companies like Sinclair, EDS, and the Bank of Oklahoma have already pledged to TCC graduates that they have hiring opportunities through our specialized training in the computer area.  As more and more jobs in our economy demand education and customized skills, TCC will be there to meet the demand with resources provided by this election Tuesday, May 13th,” McKeon said.

“The investments our citizens made in 1970 changed the landscape of higher education in Tulsa.  Today TCC ranks as one of the premier community colleges in the country.  This tradition can continue May 13th.  I urge all citizens to go to the polls and exercise their right to vote for the future of higher education,“ McKeon added.

The comprehensive list of improvements follows, identified by location:

Metro Campus                                              $3,540,000
Construct and equip buildings for laboratories, classrooms, offices, and support facilities for the development and expansion of programs including, but not limited to: Distance Learning, Digital Media, Graphic Design, Video Production, Journalism, Web Design, and Broadcast Production.
                                                                        $4,080,000
Remodel and equip buildings for laboratories, classrooms, offices, and support facilities at the Metro Campus site for the development and expansion of programs including, but not limited to: Physical Therapy Assistant, Dental Hygiene, Radiography, Occupational Therapy Assistant, Sonography, and Medical Office Administration.

Northeast Campus                                       $13,514,000
Purchase and acquire land, construct and equip buildings for laboratories, classrooms, offices, lecture/conference areas and support facilities.  This includes utilities, paving and site development at the Northeast Campus for the development and expansion of programs including: Fire and Emergency Services, First Responder Training, Community Preparedness and Homeland Security.

West Campus                                                $5,950,000
Construct, remodel and equip buildings for laboratories, classrooms, offices, and support facilities.  This includes utilities, paving and site development at the West Campus site for the development and expansion of programs, including the expansion of the Child Development program and increased space for additional children and student instruction.

Southeast Campus                                      $10,146,000
Construct, remodel and equip large multi-user computer laboratory to support the program including, but not limited to: Biotechnology, Interior Design, Accounting, Information Technology, Management, and Marketing.  Construct, remodel and equip a student support center with facilities for student academic and career advisement and skill assessment.

Expansion of parking facilities                         $1,200,000

Owasso Learning Center                           $16,000,000
Land acquisition, construction and equipment of classrooms, laboratories, offices, lecture/conference areas and support facilities.  This includes utilities, paving and site development in Owasso for the development and expansion programs including: Business, Leadership, Management, and Health programs such as Health Information Technology.

Contingencies                                              $21,570,000
While all $76 million will be used on the projects identified, 30 percent of the total package is set aside for contingencies and changes in needs.

For a homeowner with property on the tax rolls valued at $100,000, passage of the two proposals will mean a property tax increase of $4.05 per month or $48.60 per year.  After seven years, the bond issue will expire and the tax is reduced to $1.42 per month or only $17.04 per year for that homeowner.

John Wiscaver, Oklahoma Public Affairs Director for State Farm Insurance, also spoke at the campaign kick-off, saying, “As business people, we understand the direct corollation between business and education.  The reality is that a better educated workforce is a tremendously positive and important element for us as a workforce partner in this community.  TCC is a great asset for this community.”

Tulsa Mayor Kathy Taylor said, “I encourage everyone to fully understand the investment that you have the opportunity to make on May 13th that expands our economy, keeps our city safe, and that gives the next generation a wonderful opportunity to further their education in their own hometown.“

Lisa Palmer, now an accounts manager for Microsoft Corporation, spoke for many former TCC students, saying, “I have many titles, but I am most proud to list TCC graduate among them.  As a working adult with a young family, TCC provided me with access to inexpensive high quality courses and excellent guidance counseling.  This academic foundation has served as the bedrock for my personal and professional success.

“Leveraging this time at TCC, I now hold a Masters of Technology in Engineering and a Master of Business Administration.  Every day, I am able to use this education to the benefit of Tulsa companies through my role as a corporate account representative for Microsoft.  In this capacity, I assist local companies with strategic planning and implementation of technology solutions that are designed to drive value to their businesses and to the community.

Working hand in hand with these Tulsa corporations, it’s obvious to me that there is an ongoing demand for the courses and varied opportunities that are offered by TCC,” Palmer continued.

"Building on TCC’s already strong foundation, we have an opportunity as a community to say ‘yes’ on Tuesday, May 13 – ‘yes’ to building a pool of educated workers whose time and talents will strengthen local companies and communities.  I hope from my experience, you will agree with me – YES, TCC works!" Palmer concluded.

Click here for more information.

Last Updated ( Thursday, 08 May 2008 )

Utility officials defend rate increases

Wednesday, 07 May 2008
Representatives of the Tulsa Metropolitan Utility Authority (TMUA) and Tulsa Utility Board stand behind their recommendation to increase FY 2008-09 utility rates, noting the crucial importance of investing in the maintenance of Tulsa’s water and wastewater plants and distribution system.  This will be the third such increase in as many years.

In a written statement, Jack Neely, chairman of the TMUA, said, “The TMUA members thoroughly weigh the needs required to manage the water and wastewater systems for the benefit of the citizens of Tulsa against the expense for our fellow citizens.

“Next year’s rate increases are vital to support the critical maintenance needs and capital improvements, without even addressing other high-priority issues. Without the rate adjustments, we will struggle to maintain the systems, and will find ourselves with water and sewer systems in the future that are in the same conditions as our streets are today.

“While unpleasant, we must reinvest in Tulsa’s aging infrastructure, and these rate adjustments are essential so we don’t fall further behind,” Neely concluded.

The lack of adequate investment in the water and sanitary sewer systems, as well as stormwater drainage, can lead to federal government fines and ultimately failure of the equipment needed to meet regulatory requirements and keep Tulsa’s water safe. Inadequate public funding now also translates to higher costs for water and sewer services in the future. Until 2005, the City was under federal orders to complete capital improvement projects to the sewer system to keep overflows from occurring. More than $500 million was invested in sewer lines across the city and now they must be cleaned and maintained to keep them free of debris and blockages from tree roots and grease. Maintaining an adequate public investment in sewer lines is essential to avoid overflows and regulatory violations.

With the proposed rate adjustment, the average bill for a single family of four for water and sewer services will remain below five of the seven peer cities. In the Tulsa metro area, Tulsa’s combined water and sewer bill for average usage is below six of seven surburban communities.

Tulsa’s utility bills include fees for water, wastewater, stormwater and refuse services provided by the city. There is no increase in refuse fees anticipated for Fiscal Year 2009.

The rate for water, wastewater and stormwater would increase the average monthly bill for a single family home by $2.44.

The City of Tulsa last adjusted rates for water in October 2006. Following 10 years of stationary rates, the water rate was increased 9.6 percent in 2006. There was no rate increase for water in 2007.

Wastewater fees increased in 1998, 2000, 2004, 2006 and 2007 by various amounts.

From 1985 until 2006, Tulsa was required to address deficiencies and to expand the City’s sewage collection and treatment systems after receiving multiple administrative orders and unfunded mandates from the EPA. They addressed chronic sanitary sewer overflows through rehabilitation of the collection system and increasing the collection and treatment capacity of the system. The resulting work (233 capital projects) required dedicated funds from 5-year and 15-year capital improvement plans, and cost over $500 million, leaving little money available for other needs.

The Consent Order Case and the mandated work were completed by the required date of January 1, 2006.

“Tulsa has been blessed with visionary leaders who foresaw the necessity of having high-quality water in order to meets the needs of a growing Tulsa and the metro area,” said Rick Hudson, vice-chair of the TMUA.  “The fact is that our system must be adequately maintained and future growth must be provided for. The same is true with our wastewater system. We are barely able to meet the maintenance needs now with our income based on existing rates.

“If we fail to be fiscally responsible to adequately fund the maintenance and future growth requirements we will find ourselves in the same situation very soon as we now are in with our streets. Once our systems deteriorate past a certain point, they can no longer economically be maintained and they must be completely rebuilt and expensive equipment must be replaced at a cost that is far greater than the small rate increases that are required now.

“It’s the classic case of Pay me now or pay me a LOT more later," Hudson concluded.

Public Works Director Charles Hardt cautioned that failure to address routine maintenance and necessary equipment upgrades will result in state and federal administrative and consent orders which would cost the city millions of dollars.
“It’s like an automobile,” Hardt said. “You can either take care of it, maintain it through the years so that it has a long life of service, or you can neglect the car, and deal with tire blow-outs, broken belts and engine failure. An increase in utility fees is crucial to seeing that our water and sewage treatment plants and miles of storm water drains do not fail our citizens in the future.”

WATER

Tulsa has 2200 miles of water line crisscrossing Tulsa. Currently, the cost for replacing water lines is about $17 per inch of pipe diameter, e.g. a 10-inch pipe costs approximately $170 per foot to replace. On arterial and non-arterial streets, line replacement occurs at the same time as street repairs in non-emergency situations. On streets without accompanying street repair, only 1-2 miles of line are replaced each year due to funding constraints.
 
Currently there are approximately 180 miles of water line are two-inch pipes, which afford no ability to provide fire protection. It is the City’s goal to upgrade older 2-inch waterlines in neighborhoods to improve service.  Current funding levels allow the City to complete only a couple of projects per year, 1 to 2 miles.
Rehabilitation of these lines is driven by street work, so that excavation and repair of the lines can be done during pavement replacement. Currently within the City, 16-18 miles of waterline are replaced or added each year.  This is less than 1 percent of the total waterlines in the City’s distribution system.

In addition to line replacement, the two water treatment plants, Mohawk and A.B. Jewell, must be maintained. The A.B. Jewell plant is 40 years old. At ABJ, the high service pumps are over 30 years old and need replacement before they fail. The same is true of two clarifiers, original equipment in place since 1969. A major plant improvement will be required by 2015 in order to keep up with current and projected water demands. Mohawk WTP, originally built in the 1920s but completely rebuilt ten years ago, requires ongoing maintenance and replacement of smaller equipment to protect the City’s investment.

The Quality Assurance Lab that services our water system is also in need of critical upgrades in order to meet the safety standards required by the EPA. Much of the equipment and facility is obsolete, and inefficient in performing the daily regulatory analyses that the EPA requires the lab to perform.

WASTEWATER

Recent reviews of Tulsa’s North Side Sewer Treatment Plant have indicated that 81% of the equipment has either exceeded its useful life, or will do so within 5 years. Estimated cost for replacement or repair is $100 million.

At the Southside Sewage Treatment Plant, 29 % of the equipment is at or near the end of its useful life for an estimated cost of $37 million for replacement or repair.

The current budget for the treatment plants includes $3.3 million for capital equipment replacement. Last year, the city spent 1.1 million in unanticipated repairs at the treatment plants.

Tulsa operates four sewage treatment plants, approximately 1,933 miles of collection lines, 53 lift stations, 400 miles of force mains and collects and treats an average flow of 64.4 millions gallons of wastewater per day.
 
The proposed FY 09 CIP budget of$27.3 million is broken down between the plants as follows:
·     Northside $8.7 mil – Anaerobic Digester Rehabilitation ( two of the four digesters are out of service), Headworks (screening and grit removal);
·     Southside $6.0 mil – Aeration System Upgrades and Odor Control at the plant and in River Park (FY 09 $2.0 mil with a total of $9.5 mil through 2013 to improve the odors around the Southside Plant, River Parks and around the 71st Street Sludge Processing  Facility);
·     Haikey Creek $1.7 – Sludge Thickening Improvements;
·     Lower Bird Creek $1.9 – Sludge Handling and Disinfection improvements;
·     Areawide $9.0 mil – Collection System Rehabilitation and other collection system improvements.
 
STORMWATER
Tulsa Flooding 1984
Stormwater drainage across the city includes 439 miles of open channels 29 miles of improved channels, 988 miles of roadside ditches and 100 detention ponds. Removal of debris in those channels is critical to flood prevention. Those channels include privately owned sections that must be monitored and cleaned to prevent blockages from affecting public sections upstream of downstream . $24 million from the 2006 sales tax was allocated to $4 million for system rehab, $1 million to address street and backyard flooding issues and $19 million for major channel reconstruction and repairs. Currently there is more than a $10 million dollar backlog of small drainage projects needed to alleviate run-off type/residential flooding.

The goal is to fund $2 million in projects on an annual basis for five years. Currently, the city has identified expenses of $168,000 per year to address debris blockage on public and private creeks. $500,000 has also been requested from the stormwater fund to mow uncurbed arterial rights of way and apply herbicide.

Edit Note:  Tulsa Today publisher David Arnett has written in detail on problems with Tulsa’s Southside Waste Treatment Plant related to Arkansas River Development.  Many Tulsans believe that plant should be closed or replaced rather than repaired because the facility is too old to successfully repair and because of its location on the River beside the I-44 entrance to the City of Tulsa.  Click here to read “River-Pooping Gorilla” published February 12, 2007.
Last Updated ( Wednesday, 07 May 2008 )

Voice for freedom

The Singing Revolution
United States, 2007
Directed By: James Tusty and Maureen Castle Tusty
Written By: Mike Majoros, James Tusty, Maureen Castle Tusty
Starring: Linda Hunt (narrator)
Running Time: 94 minutes
Not Rated
4 out of 5 stars

I take a lot of things for granted, although perhaps less than some. I spent my teenage years in a borderline third world country where I shared a small room with both my siblings. It’s the small things you tend to miss. At the store there were two choices of soda: coke or sprite; our electric water heater limited hot showers to 2 minutes; and English reading material was at a premium—I devoured my books in mere days. Living in the states within that context, I appreciate the things I’ve had to live without: the sheer number of choices the grocery store has to offer, the 15 minutes I spend on average in the shower now, and the library and local bookstores, which I can lose myself in for hours. However, watching The Singing Revolution last night, I realized I had taken one Big Thing for granted, in large part because I’ve never had to live without it: my freedom.

Estonia is one of the three Baltic States in Northern Europe, bordered to the south by Latvia and to the east by the Russian Federation. In 1918 they declared independence from the Russian Empire and tasted freedom for over 20 years. Then, in 1939, the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact was signed between Germany and Russia, effectively dividing Europe between the Nazis and the communists. The freedom Estonia had enjoyed for two decades evaporated as 90,000 Soviet troops marched across the border and into their tiny nation. When Hitler betrayed Stalin and marched on Russia, Estonia changed hands a second time, a mere pawn to be toyed with by its powerful neighbors.

When Roosevelt, Churchill, and Stalin met at Yalta in 1945, the two western leaders were assured that Estonia would receive its independence back after the war, but once the Nazis were ground into the dust, that promise was never kept. The Red Army quickly marched back into Estonia, subjugating it once and for all. World War II decimated the tiny country; a full 25% of its population was wiped out.

Told through extensive archival footage and intimate interviews with the people who lived through the events, The Singing Revolution chronicles how the Soviets attempted to eradicate every shred of Estonian culture and national identity through an intense process of Russification, and how they ultimately failed {mosimage}because of a song. Every 5 years the Estonians would come together for a massive choral celebration, with over 20,000 singers on stage at once. The Soviets milked the festival for every ounce of propaganda that they could, forcing songs about socialism and Stalin (and later Lenin) into the program. The Estonians reluctantly obliged, but would rebel at the end of the program, proudly belting out their unofficial national anthem. As one interviewee says, when 25,000 people get it into their heads to sing a song, there is nothing you can do to stop them.

Unfortunately, the middle section of the film drags considerably. As stirring as the initial images are, once you’ve seen your fourth archival montage of Estonian folk singing, you begin to check your watch. The problem seems to be that directors James and Maureen Castle Tusty feel an unnecessary responsibility to document every step of the Estonians fight for independence. As noble as that intention is, the film bogs down when we’re given the play-by-play of every significant singing demonstration and protest. The tedium is further compounded by the relative staleness of some of the interviews. For all the atrocities and triumphs that these people have endured, I do not think I saw one of them shed a tear. While I’ll chalk that up to cultural pragmatism, it makes for dull, matter-of-fact interviews. Even at a short 94 minutes, it is about 10 minutes too long.

In spite of this, the final act is emotionally stunning in the way that all great human drama is. Through patient and peaceful means, Estonia slowly asserted its independence one day at a time, and in 1991 they finally achieved it. That they did so without a single violent protest, without any loss of life, is simply mind-boggling. If someone were to have told me that a revolution could be achieved non-violently through singing, I would have laughed at their idealism, but the proof is right there on screen. Shame on my cynicism.

Given the present global climate, with China occupying Tibet in the exact same fashion as the Soviets occupied Estonia, The Singing Revolution is more relevant than ever. Not only is it a chilling reminder of the fragility and preciousness of freedom, it is also a call to action. Estonia is finally free, but Tibet and other nations like it are not. That something as simple as a song could bring about lasting change is a direct challenge to anyone who excuses themselves on the basis that they’re “too tiny to make a difference.”

I hope I don’t take my freedom for granted as often now. It is a luxury that other people do not possess.

The Singing Revolution is currently playing at the Circle Cinema. Call 592-FILM for showtimes and more information.


About the Author:
Evan Derrick loves movies, loves talking about movies, and even makes them from time to time. In the rare moment when movies aren’t consuming his grey matter, he enjoys eating grilled cheese sandwiches, playing with his baby daughter, and pretending to be the senior editor for MovieZeal.com. Use the Tulsa Today search feature to read previous reviews by this author.

Sen. Wilcoxson honored by State Senate

State Sen. Kathleen Wilcoxson’s efforts to promote education reform and innovation will long be remembered as her legacy in the Oklahoma Legislature.  Wilcoxson was honored by the State Senate on Monday.  She is completing her twelfth and final session in the Legislature due to term limits.
“At every step of the way, Senator Wilcoxson has fought for Oklahoma’s children with a vision of creating an education system that would help those children, and the generations to follow have the greatest opportunities possible,” said Senate Co-President Pro Tempore Glenn Coffee.  “She has served her district and our state with honor and dedication.”

The Oklahoma City Republican is a former Oklahoma City Teacher of the Year, and is a Doctor of Education in Curriculum and Instruction.  In 1982, she was appointed by President Ronald Reagan to the National Advisory Council on Adult Basic Education, and in 1996, she followed in the footsteps of State Sen. Helen Cole, winning the District 45 seat.

“Helen Cole was my friend and my mentor, and I consider myself truly blessed to have had her guidance and support,” Wilcoxson said.  “I do not know of a more intelligent, ethical and compassionate public servant.  I am tremendously grateful for the trust that Helen, my friends and family, and all the citizens of District 45 placed in me when I first began this journey.”

Wilcoxson urged her fellow members to continue her efforts to pass education reform—especially in promoting policy to improve student achievement in math, reading and science, and to help increase the numbers of students who complete high school.

“As a state, we should applaud our achievements, but we must always be honest about our shortcomings—otherwise we will never correct them and we will never move forward,” Wilcoxson said.  “We cannot be satisfied with the status quo—too many children are falling between the cracks.  When we acknowledge that fact and truly embrace bold reforms that will result in excellence in education, then we will see individual and collective success and achievement we had never before imagined.  It is a cause I have been proud to advocate in the Senate, and one I will continue to fight for in the years to come.”

Among the special guests attending Monday’s ceremony were Wilcoxson’s husband, Lynden, and her daughter and son-in-law, Stacy and Jeff Salem.  Also attending were Alma Johnson, Don and Sandy Johnson, David and Beth Johnson, Phyllis and Gene Williams, Margie Galt, David Cole, Alana VanOver, Bert Gowdy, Lynden Wilcoxson, Ralph and Janice Wilcoxson, Barbara Gowdy and many others.


About the Photo:
Senator Kathleen Wilcoxson stands on her soapbox to address her fellow members. The petite lawmaker from District 45 in Oklahoma City was honored in the Senate on Monday for her 12 years of service in the Legislature.  Wilcoxson is one of five senators who are term-limited this year.