Category Archives: Local

Public Pension Concerns Growing

Concern is increasing daily about Tulsa and Oklahoma’s liability in pensions for public employees.  Union officials have been remarkably silent on the subject, but one Tulsa firefighter claimed recently on local talk radio, “After we have our [retirement] cake the City does not give our pensions another dime.”  From Tulsa Today’s analysis, the firefighter is telling the truth, but without the whole story.

The City of Tulsa contributes 13% of the gross salary for each paid
firefighter during their employment, and the employee can contribute
more if they wish.  During that same time and after they retire, the
State of Oklahoma also contributes 34% of the taxes collected for
Insurance Premium Taxes, as they have each year since 2006.

What this means is that while the City of Tulsa, may not have a direct liability to fund the pension, Oklahomans will fund it, in part, through taxes forever.

According to the Actuarial Valuation Report for The Oklahoma Firefighters Pension and Retirement System, the firefighters statewide pension was carrying an unfunded liability of $1,407,100,000 ($1.4 billion) as of July 1,2009.  

Over $1.4 billion in unfunded pension liability – monies owed to enable the fund to pay out 100% of what is due by contract with participants.  This means that, as of 2009, the pension fund is only 54.2% funded.  But wait, there’s more.  In 2008, the state lost money from the investments that make up part of the pension fund.  In the report for fiscal year ending June 2008, the pension’s assets depreciated 26.8%, including a loss of $84,144,252 (over $84 million) in investments.

So, where does that leave us as citizens?  Can we fire someone?  Who?  Those who are getting the monies are the staunch working folks who safeguard our houses, personal safety and teach our kids.  The average firefighter does a job with honor and sacrifice.  The average teacher is there to mold young minds and prepare them for the real world.  Who then is to blame?  Who is to be held accountable?  Perhaps it is time to look at why we got into the public union business in the first place.  

Perhaps it is time to consider the words of Franklin Delano Roosevelt from The Constitution Prevails (pg. 325 Sec. 97), Strikes of Federal Employees:

“All Government employees should realize that the process of collective bargaining, as usually understood, cannot be transplanted into the public service.  It has its distinct and insurmountable limitations when applied to public personnel management.  The very nature and purposes of Government make it impossible for administrative officials to represent fully or to bind the employer in mutual discussions with Government employee organizations.  The employer is the whole people, who speak by means of laws enacted by their representatives in Congress.  Accordingly, administrative officials and employees alike are governed and guided and in many instances restricted, by laws which establish policies, procedure, or rules in personnel matters.”

Thus FDR, known for huge government expansions, objected to unions for public workers.  Unions cannot function properly in government because the “Management” is all of us, including the workers themselves.  

At current standing, a Pew Center report puts our state’s total unfunded liability at just over $13 Billion dollars, and growing at a unfunded percent between 54.3% and 68.8%.  Most of this is from government workers in unions with negotiated pensions and funding rates in place by laws.  It isn’t a question of if we will run out of money to pay these promised pensions, it is simply a matter of when.  

It is significantly relevant to also consider SQ744, an education spending question promoted by unions on the ballot this November which would mandate that Oklahoma spend as much in education as an average of states in the surrounding area.  According to a Pew Center study, Kansas is second worst in the nation in regard to pension funding problems, only surpassed by President Barack Obama’s home state of Illinois.

This study titled “The Trillion Dollar Gap” outlines the difference between what is owed in pensions, and health benefits, and what the states have in cash in the funds to pay the debts.  The study outlines the worst states and the best states and Oklahoma is in the bottom 21 with the funding being less than 80%.

Patrick McGuigan, editor of CapitolBeatOk.com has done several reports lately on the pensions for the teachers in Oklahoma.  In a brief telephone interview with Tulsa Today McGuigan reported that the 80% funding mark is the actuarial industry standard for when a fund is either healthy or in trouble.  

McGuigan said, Oklahoma’s pensions “are in a lot of trouble” if Oklahoma’s economy declines, some natural disaster or other financial emergency occurs that reduces tax revenues.


About the author:
Aaron Sheppard is a long time believer in small government and responsible use of tax dollars.  As a former City of Tulsa employee who worked in the Finance Department assisting in production of the Annual City Budget from 2001 to 2004, he experienced first hand the differences in what happens behind the scenes and what makes the news.  He has a Bachelor’s degree from the University of Phoenix and has worked in the private sector since 2004.  You can read more from him on his blog at www.theperegrinfalcon.com and on Tulsa Today.

Human Rights Dept. Defended

As part of an ongoing investigation into the question of why the City of Tulsa spends over $500,000 per year on a Department of Human Rights, Tulsa Today spoke with Paul Zachary Public Works Deputy Director and Councilor Jack Henderson to see why the City of Tulsa needs the department and continues to increase funding even as police and firefighters are being reduced.

Previous investigations have shown there are many different state, federal, and county entities that handle Human Rights complaints.  We have also learned that the current director Dr. Lana Turner-Addison also works for the Tulsa School Board and feels that the department is vital to the City.  Still there are questions.

Paul Zachary, Deputy Directory of Public Works, is in a unique position to see up-close how the bid process works and what kinds of discrimination could be apart of getting a contract for the City.  Likewise, Councilor Henderson, former president of the local chapter of the NAACP, is familiar with the complaint side of compliance with Title 5 (Tulsa’s local section of the charter dealing with various boards and commissions; including the Human Rights commission) and Title 6 (Federal Civil Rights law) discrimination cases.

After the regular Council meeting on Thursday August 12th this reporter sat down with both gentlemen to see if I could get some understanding as to why the City is in the Human Rights business, why we have to grow government to achieve these goals, and what benefits might the citizens expect.

Tulsa Today:  Why did the Council choose to fund two new Human Rights positions from a one-time land sale from the county without forethought of how to fund them in future?  Is there some emergency that requires these positions get monies that could be used elsewhere in the City?

Jack Henderson: That is how any position in the City is funded.  We have to get the money from somewhere, and in this case, there is only one new position.  One of the positions was previously funded, but during the Budget Approval cycle, it was de-funded.  Secondly, the Human Rights department needs these compliance monitors because of the increasing caseload that will be expected now that the Disparity Study has been completed.

Tulsa Today:  What purpose does the Human Rights department serve that is not already being served by the county, state, or federal governments?  Why do we need a Human Rights department?

Jack Henderson:  The Human Rights department is something that we need to be able to handle discrimination cases against the City and/or contractors who will bid or work for the City.  When I was President of the local NAACP we had many times when a company would hire a minority worker, just to be able to say they were in compliance with the law.  Then when the work was done and the records that show who did what, the minority worker was on leave, or moved to a different project or something like that.  I would come to the City and the City Attorney’s office would say that there had to be a disparity study before any action could be taken.  Now, we have spent a lot of money on this study and the state and federal offices that receive the majority of these complaints will hold us accountable for it.

Paul Zachary:  We would need personnel to handle the incoming complaints in any event.  How the system works is that a person or group generates a complaint; the complaint is then given to the state, the feds, and the City.  Then they (state or feds) hold us accountable to get the work done to fix the issue.  The state does not come up here to investigate complaints, neither do the feds; instead, they put the responsibility on the city/municipalities to solve the issue or face prosecution or legal liabilities.

Tulsa Today:  So, If a person or group has a complaint about a public sidewalk that is not handicapped accessible, you’re saying that without a City Human Rights department, the City would be at risk of being held liable or non-compliant with the law?

Paul Zachary:  Not exactly, the Human Rights department are the persons who make sure the complaint is addressed, and then taken care of in the proper manner.  The complaints will come in from Inhoffe’s office, or Sullivan’s or the D.O.J. and they have to be handled by somebody.  Without a Human Rights department, we would have to have workers in Public Works working the cases anyway.  The Human Rights department is the City’s way of handling this need, but is still needs handling.

Tulsa Today:  Why wouldn’t the state send down compliance monitors for a complaint they received?  Why is it the City’s job?

Paul Zachary:  The state will not send down a person to investigate a claim.  They will send it to us, and expect us to handle it.  Most of the time they handle the larger complaints, such as corporations who do have the proper handicapped access to facilities, etc.  Think of the Human Rights department as the clearing house for the complaint process.  As it is currently, the entire process is not something that has active ongoing investigations where compliance monitors are searching for violations.  Instead, it is a very complaint driven area.

Jack Henderson:  Also there is going to be an even more increasing need due to HB 1804.  Illegal immigration cases and the like are going create an larger case load to work through.

Tulsa Today:  So, even with the 30 plus agencies at the federal level all with Human Rights departments, local regional offices in Tulsa, Oklahoma City, and Missouri; and with the ability to find who to report to and how to file a report, the Human Rights department is the receptacle of all complaints for the City?  How did we function before 1995 when the Human Rights department was created?

Jack Henderson:  I was not here in 1995, and do not know what actions were taken before then.  However, yes, we as a City are left liable and held responsible by the other governments for violations of Title 5.

Paul Zachary:  I imagine that someone would have gone to the City Attorney, but I do not know for sure.  The Human Rights department handles the complaints, but also acts as an independent third party.  If someone has a complaint about discrimination in the bidding process, it looks better if the same department is not investigating the claims.  Human Rights is completely autonomous from any other department and has a director that reports directly to the Mayor.  This structure ensures that the complaints that we do receive can be treated fairly.

Continue to check back with Tulsa Today in the coming weeks, as we continue in our investigation.


About the author:
Aaron Sheppard is a long time believer in smaller government and responsible use of tax dollars.  As a former City of Tulsa employee who worked in the Finance Department assisting in production of the Annual City Budget from 2001 to 2004, he experienced first hand the differences in what happens behind the scenes and what makes the news. He has a Bachelor’s degree from the University of Phoenix and has worked in the private sector since 2004.  Sheppard may be reached at editor@tulsatoday.com This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it for news tips.  Comments on this report are welcome below.

Council Disputes Continue

Fireworks continue to fly at City Hall.  In Thursday’s City Council meeting a charge led by Councilor Turner unanimously approved sending a complaint of Mayor Bartlett’s perceived ethics violations to the City Auditor.

During the discussion both Councilors Bynum and Mautino asked for a two week “cool down period” before the vote on the ethics violation was taken.  Bynum asked the council repeatedly “to wait and take the opportunity to sit with the Mayor and discuss all the issues.”  Councilor Turner in obvious impatience and visible disgust continually moved to hold the vote despite pleas for patience.

Originally the item was to go directly to the Ethics Committee using the City Auditor’s office as a conduit, but in an apparent effort to cool tempers, Councilor Bynum asked that instead of sending the complaint directly to the committee; that it should be sent to the City Auditor and then he would determine if there was a violation qualified for the committee.  Councilor Turner was visually upset by the process.

After some discussion by Drew Reese, and Rick Wescott; Councilor Turner was persuaded to allow the City Auditor first review of the issue; but it was not without obvious disdain.  All of the councilors that spoke voiced the opinion that the events “needed looking into” and that it was the council’s job to investigate every possible ethics violation.

After the meeting Councilor Bill Christiansen said that this would not have been an issue if the attorney that the Mayor was accepting donated services from was not a current contractor for the City.


About the author:
Aaron Sheppard is a long time believer in smaller government and responsible use of tax dollars.  As a former City of Tulsa employee who worked in the Finance Department assisting in production of the Annual City Budget from 2001 to 2004, he experienced first hand the differences in what happens behind the scenes and what makes the news. He has a Bachelor’s degree from the University of Phoenix and has worked in the private sector since 2004.  Sheppard may be reached at editor@tulsatoday.com This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it for news tips.  Comments on this report are welcome below. 

Tulsa’s Expensive Duplication

Eddie Huff’s question is simple:  Why would the City of Tulsa duplicate services provided by Federal and State government to an amount fluctuating around $500,000 a year during a time city police and firefighter positions are cut because of budget shortages?

Huff, host of The Eddie Huff show on AM 1170 KFAQ recently posed this question about Tulsa’s Human Rights department on-air.  He believes that there is no need for a Human Rights department in the City of Tulsa because it is a duplication of effort.  Tulsa Today’s investigation shows Huff may well be right.

The City of Tulsa Monthly Financial Report Executive Summary published December 30, 2005 had appropriations of $396,000.00 and a staff of 7 for the department.  Over the years, this has grown substantially.  In Fiscal Year 2009-2010 the Human Rights Budget Summary from the Adopted City Budget lists the FY 08 actual budget at $641,000 and a staff of 8.  Fiscal Year 2009 actual budget was $769,000.00 with a staff of 9 and next year’s approved budget was restrained to $484,000.00 until City Council approved another $100,000.00 in last Thursday’s session.  Just a round sum of the monies spent in these years alone is over $2 million.

Much of the amount spent by the department over the last few years has gone to a “Disparity Study” costing over $300,000, but the question remains of why the City funds 9 workers at an average total cost of $400,000 per year?

Huff said, “I am not in favor of a Human Rights Department, period.  Secondly, at a time, when we are watching a City under [financial] siege with this battle between the Mayor and Council over the Police Department, now the City Council has the gall to find $100,000.00 to hire two new compliance monitors that are supposed to find instances of this new Affirmative Action package that was passed.”

“I think it will cause a big problem.  I am in the insurance business and you have to get a certain type of insurance before you can get a job or bid on a job.  You have to have comprehensive liability, worker’s comp, and you have to be bonded.  Many minorities starting out are not going to have all that, and so it is going to be cost prohibitive.  Now let’s say you are a contractor or the City who wants to put out a bid, and you are now going to have to find minorities who can do the job and be qualified to do the job,” Huff said.

“Another problem is going to be in hiring engineers.  How many black or Latino or female engineers do we have to choose from?  If they come back and say to the engineering companies they have don’t have enough minorities then they will have to go looking outside the state to fill the requirements.”

Huff noted that in the same meeting where the Council rejected the Mayor’s request for more funding, they gave the Human Rights department another $50,000.00 to total nearly $800,000 for last fiscal year that ended May 31st.

“This year some departments were cut over 50% where the Human Rights department has only been cut about 10%.  Barely cut, now they come back and get another increase only two weeks into the new budget,” Huff said adding “I don’t think we need a Human Rights Department in the City of Tulsa.”

Director Dr. Lana Turner-Addison disagrees. “The Human Rights department is about promoting and protecting the rights of people who work for the City and for those who live in Tulsa. [It is] extremely important.”

Addison has been the Director of the Human Rights Department for the last three years.  She earned an Associate Degree at Oklahoma Junior College; a Bachelor’s Degree in Accounting and a Master’s Degree in Urban Education from Langston University.  She recently earned a Doctoral degree at Oklahoma State University.  She was formerly employed at OSU-Tulsa as the Community Relations Manager and also owns and operates a bookkeeping service.

“We are focused on education and making the public aware of the issues taking place and who to contact if an issue is taking place.  We keep a lot of incidents from happening that way.  There are also five commissions that we report to, and these groups report to the Mayor’s office, Addison said.

“The numbers of incidents are definitely not declining.  When I started we were tremendously understaffed.  For the most part, the issues do not trend up or down, but rather tend to fluctuate from type to type.  In one month we may have more ADA cases, in another month there will be more sexual orientation cases,” Addison said.

However, a few simple Google searches present a plethora of options for filing complaints on every subject within the City of Tulsa’s Department of Human Rights specific mission.  For housing discrimination, the Housing and Urban Development Department (HUD) provides an online form, a toll free number and a form that can be printed and mailed. Click here for more.

The federal government investigates ADA claims and provides a list of no less than ten different agencies for filing complaints including instructions and contact specifics.  Click here for more.

There is an Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) office for the state in Oklahoma City, where again, names, numbers, contact information and instructions are provided for filing complaints.  In fact, on the ADA website there is a 23 page instruction booklet on how to both recognize and file a complaint for items as specific as “Readily Achievable Barrier Removal : Van Accessible Parking Spaces.” Complete with diagrams and a list of rights.

Don’t want to talk with the Federal government?  The Oklahoma State Human Rights Department employs nine staffers and five of them work in Tulsa.  Addresses and office hours for personal one-on-one appointments are posted online.

The basic goals of the City of Tulsa Human Rights Department are similar if not an exact duplication of Federal and State agencies. The Tulsa Today investigation has yet to find an agency, service, commission, branch, or other designate of the Federal, or State governments that do not already have a body of persons that exist solely for the purpose of receiving, and investigating or forwarding complaints of discrimination that operate on both a large and small scale.  

So why does the City have a Human Rights Department?  Why have we spent millions to duplicate work, purpose, and time that others are carrying out quite nicely?  A brief review of the cases that the Department Of Justices posts on its site shows a prominent Tulsa company in the top ten.  In this instance and a recent court case for ADA; the very topic Dr. Turner-Addison mentions repeatedly; was brought to court and prosecuted, not by the City, not by the State, but by the Federal government.

Of course minority rights should be protected, but they are covered, well covered from every possible angle.  Do we need a Human Rights department at the City of Tulsa?

Maybe the better question is:  Should the City of Tulsa spend $584,000 on other community needs this year?  Maybe rehiring police and firefighters or repairing a few more city street would be a more compelling need than duplicating state and federal agencies.


About the author:
Aaron Sheppard is a long time believer in smaller government and responsible use of tax dollars.  As a former City of Tulsa employee who worked in the Finance Department assisting in production of the Annual City Budget from 2001 to 2004, he experienced first hand the differences in what happens behind the scenes and what makes the news. He has a Bachelor’s degree from the University of Phoenix and has worked in the private sector since 2004.  Sheppard may be reached at editor@tulsatoday.com for news tips.  Comments on this report are welcome below.

Federal Probe Returns TPD Indictments

Little Rock – Jane W. Duke, United States Attorney for the Eastern District of Arkansas; James E. Finch, Special Agent in Charge, Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), Oklahoma City Division; and Wayne D. Beaman, Special Agent in Charge, Department of Justice – Office of Inspector General, Dallas Field Office, announced today the indictment and arrest of one retired and four current Tulsa Police Department officers. Those arrested include Jeff M. Henderson, age 37, of Collinsville, Oklahoma; William A. Yelton, age 49, of Bixby, Oklahoma; Harold R. Wells, age 59, of Owasso, Oklahoma; Nick DeBruin, age 37, of Tulsa, Oklahoma; and Earnest Bruce Bonham, age 52, of Claremore, Oklahoma. The arrests stem from two separate indictments in which the defendants are charged with a variety of drug trafficking, civil rights, and related offenses.

A sixty-one count indictment charges Henderson and Yelton with offenses dating back to May 2004. According to the indictment, which remained sealed until the defendants’ initial appearances today, Henderson and Yelton conspired with one another from May 2004 until the present to deprive Bobby Wayne Haley, Sr. of his civil rights. The indictment alleges that in May 2004, Henderson and Yelton persuaded Rochelle Martin to testify falsely in a federal court proceeding involving Haley.

The indictment further states that on April 6, 2007, Henderson contacted Martin and told her that he needed her to testify for him the following morning and Martin agreed. The next day, Henderson and Yelton picked up Martin and transported her to the U.S. Courthouse to provide testimony to United States Magistrate Judge Paul J. Cleary. While en route to the courthouse, Henderson and Yelton coached Martin as to the testimony she should give. The two officers instructed Martin to falsely testify that she had given Henderson information in May 2004 concerning drug trafficking activity by Haley at his home and business. Henderson then used this purported information to obtain a state search warrant for Haley’s property. That search warrant resulted in the discovery of drugs and Haley’s subsequent indictment and conviction. Martin has since admitted that she lied during the Haley hearing and that she did so at the request and instruction of Henderson and Yelton. Ultimately, Haley was convicted and sentenced to 264 months imprisonment. In May 2010, an affidavit of Martin was publicly filed in which she admitted to providing the false testimony against Haley. As a result, Haley was released from prison. In all, Haley served over 4 years in prison on this now-vacated sentence. Both Henderson and Yelton are also charged with conspiring to suborn the perjury of Martin.

Henderson is separately charged with 12 individual drug offenses, one of which is a conspiracy to distribute and to possess with intent to distribute marijuana, cocaine, and methamphetamine. The conspiracy alleges that Henderson and Brandon Jay McFadden, a former special agent with the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives, conspired with one another and with other persons known and unknown to the Grand Jury to distribute less than 50 kilograms of marijuana, less than 500 grams of cocaine, and in excess of 500 grams of methamphetamine from January 1, 2007 through October 2008.

Additional drug charges against Henderson include distribution and possession with intent to distribute various controlled substances during the time period of the conspiracy. Because Henderson took many of these actions while carrying his service firearm, he is charged with possessing a firearm during and in relation to a drug trafficking offense.

Henderson is also charged with violating the civil rights of individuals in 14 separate instances. These counts allege the deprivation of the individual victims’ rights to be free from unreasonable searches and seizures and to receive due process of law before being deprived of property or liberty. Similarly, Yelton is separately charged with violating the civil rights of individuals in 3 instances. Henderson is charged in 5 separate civil rights conspiracies. Three of those conspiracies involved the theft of money from criminal suspects. One civil rights  conspiracy alleges that Henderson and other officers broke into the home of Jose Angel Gonzalez and hid a sawed-off shotgun inside an air vent; later came back with a warrant for the residence and found the gun. Gonzalez was subsequently charged with being a felon in possession of that sawed-off shotgun. The final civil rights conspiracy against Henderson involves a fabricated controlled drug buy by Ryan Logsdon from Larry and Larita Barnes. The fabricated drug buy was the basis of a federal prosecution against the Barnes that went to trial in April 2008. During that trial, Henderson, McFadden, and Logsdon all testified falsely under oath that Logsdon conducted a controlled buy of methamphetamine from the Barneses on May 8, 2007. Both Logsdon and McFadden have since confirmed that they lied under oath and that the controlled drug buy never happened.

The Barneses were convicted and sentenced to terms of imprisonment. Their release from prison was effectuated last summer through filings made by Duke’s office. As a result of his false testimony in the Barnes case, Henderson is now charged with 10 separate counts of perjury and with conspiring with McFadden and Logsdon to commit perjury.

Henderson is also charged with 10 additional counts of perjury related to his false testimony in a federal prosecution of Ronald Crawford. In a suppression hearing conducted in that case, Henderson testified extensively as to surveillance of Ronald Crawford that Henderson allegedly conducted on January 5-6, 2009 in Tulsa, Oklahoma. This testimony was false in that Ronald Crawford was not in Tulsa, Oklahoma on those dates.

Two charges in the indictment allege that Henderson and Yelton conspired to commit witness intimidation. These counts relate to attempts by Henderson and Yelton to prevent Brandon McFadden and Rochelle Martin from providing authorities and/or the grand jury with information about Henderson’s illegal activities. In the matter concerning McFadden, it is alleged that Henderson and Yelton took McFadden to a secluded location and that Yelton brandished a gun and while racking it made comments to the effect that McFadden needed to go back to Lubbock, Texas and keep his mouth shut. Concerning the conspiracy to intimidate Rochelle Martin, it is alleged that Henderson and Yelton conspired to prevent Martin from providing truthful information to the grand jury investigating Henderson.

The final count alleges that Henderson, aided and abetted by others, attempted to bribe Brandon McFadden with free legal representation with the intent to prevent McFadden’s cooperation in the corruption investigation. While committing these acts, Henderson knew he was a target of the investigation and he knew that McFadden had already been indicted.

In a second indictment, former TPD officer Harold Wells and current TPD officers Nick DeBruin and Earnest Bruce Bonham are charged with a drug conspiracy and a civil rights conspiracy stemming from allegations that these officers and others planted drug evidence on suspects they arrested. Each is also charged with possessing a firearm during and in relation to a drug trafficking offense. These three officers are also charged in a conspiracy to steal government funds and theft of government funds. DeBruin is separately charged with depriving Cody Weavel of his civil rights by depriving Weavel of property without due process of law. Wells is charged in a civil rights conspiracy involving the theft of money from Hugo Gutierrez during the execution of a search warrant in January 2008. The indictment lists co-conspirators in the Gutierrez matter as James K. Gray, a former TPD officer; Callison Kaiser, a former TPD officer and United States Secret Service agent; and Eric Hill, a current TPD officer. Wells is also charged in a substantive civil rights deprivation count involving Gutierrez; with distribution of methamphetamine; use of a telephone in connection with a drug trafficking offense; and in a separate drug conspiracy alleging that Wells conspired with Gray to distribute methamphetamine.

“When any law enforcement officer betrays the oath to protect; serve; and uphold the law, he tarnishes the badge of all law enforcement, violates the trust of the people and therefore should be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the very laws he has broken,” said Finch.

This case was investigated by agents of the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the Department of Justice – Office of Inspector General. The United States Attorney’s Office for the Eastern District of Arkansas was appointed by the Department of Justice to handle this matter upon the recusal of the United States Attorney’s Office for the Northern District of Oklahoma.

The case is being prosecuted by United States Attorney Jane Duke, Assistant United States Attorney Patrick Harris, and Assistant United States Attorney Patricia Harris. An indictment is only an allegation of wrongdoing based on probable cause. A defendant is presumed innocent until such time as he or she is adjudged guilty either by plea or jury verdict.