Yearly Archives: 2008

Dark Knight masterpiece

The Dark Knight
United States, 2008

Directed By: Christopher Nolan
Written By: Christopher Nolan and Jonathan Nolan
Starring: Christian Bale, Heath Ledger, Aaron Eckhart, Maggie Gyllenhaal, Michael Caine, Gary Oldman, Morgan Freeman
Running Time: 152 minutes
Rated PG-13 for intense sequences of violence and some menace
5 out of 5 stars

There is a clear distinction between the film reviewer and the film critic, although at first glance it appears to simply be semantics. The film reviewer writes for the person who has not yet seen the film in question and may not know anything about it. They avoid significant spoilers, spend a great deal of time synopsizing, keep things relatively brief, and cultivate a tone of recommendation: thumbs up or thumbs down, praise or pan, see it now, wait for the DVD, or avoid like the plague. The film critic, on the other hand, writes for the person who has already seen the film. They discuss the internal workings of the movie, wrestle with why it succeeds or fails, and attempt to bring about a deeper understanding of the film’s sociological implications and its place within the culture at large.

I attempt, with varying degrees of success, to combine both of these paradigms in my writing, but The Dark Knight necessitates a more critical approach. In my professional career as a critic so far, it has been the only film that I have required myself to see twice before writing about.

Although I am somewhat late to the party, you would have all seen the film whether I told you to or not, so I’m not concerned with the tardiness of this piece. I am also eschewing the guidelines for reviewing, embracing the role of critic instead, so if you’re in the 5% who have yet to see the box office record breaker (rectify that immediately), consider yourself forewarned.

As filmgoers we are often asked to choose between films that entertain and films that stimulate thought, but rarely are we given both in the same package. Few have accomplished this in recent memory (No Country For Old Men, The Lives Of Others, and The Mist all come to mind). The Dark Knight, however, is an epic achievement on both counts.

Even with 5 months left in 2008, I guarantee you will not find a film this magnificently entertaining all year. Allow me to retain my ‘reviewers’ cap for a moment and say that if you consider yourself a movie lover of any significant worth, this is the one film that must be seen theatrically. Must. And having seen it in both standard 35mm and in IMAX, I can happily regurgitate what hundreds of others have said over the past few weeks: you have not truly seen The Dark Knight until you’ve seen it in IMAX. The difference is night and day, due to Christopher Nolan’s brilliant decision (I can only hope other directors follow his lead) to film the action sequences entirely with specialized IMAX cameras. When Batman leaps off a building in Hong Kong and the camera gleefully follows his plummeting descent, it sucked the breath out of my lungs. Literally. The Dark Knight is one of the most exciting, adrenaline-fueled films I have ever seen.

But plenty of films manage to be exciting, even incredibly so. Wanted, Iron Man, and Hellboy 2: The Golden Army, each comic book adaptations debuting in the past 3 months, have all registered shockingly high on the fun-o-meter. And while Batman Begins, Nolan’s previous foray into the world of the caped crusader, was considered by many to be the cream of the superhero crop, it remained securely anchored to the ground by its comic book origins. What, then, makes The Dark Knight different?

Christopher Nolan, like (to a lesser extent) Jon Favreau (Iron Man) and Peter Berg (Hancock), has realized that superhero flicks need to evolve to remain viable, both critically and financially. While Tim Burton’s vision of Batman worked fine in 1989, his kitschy and conspicuously stylized aesthetic is no longer relevant, especially in the post-post-9/11 world in which we live. We are reaching superhero burnout, and it won’t be long before Spider-Man goes the way of Daredevil and Ghostrider.

So Nolan strips his film of all but the most essential comic book conventions. While characters and outfits remain, gothic-pop landscapes and goofy plots to destroy the city go. There are no wink-wink-nudge-nudge moments that announce that this is a Comic Book Movie, no traces of irony, no cheeseball asides. Christopher Nolan takes the central question behind Batman – what are the consequences of putting on the mask? – and completely legitimizes it. The entire film is a meditation on the answers to that one question.

Note: Do not read any further until you’ve seen the film.
 

Bruce Wayne is a man in conflict. Having created the Batman persona, he finds himself disappearing further and further inside of it. Not only is it like a drug, consuming his life to the point where he doesn’t even return home after a night of crime fighting, it is also fracturing his personality. He and others have begun to refer to Batman in the third person, as if he was another entity entirely and not simply Bruce with a mask over his face. Is Batman a part of Bruce Wayne or is Bruce Wayne a part of Batman? The balance is shifting away from the former and ever closer to the latter.

The playboy billionaire, however, is the only one who doesn’t seem to realize this. Alfred recognizes the symbol that his employer’s alter ego has become (“Batman can make the choice that no one else can.”) and Rachel realizes the addictive toll it has taken on the man she loves (“When I told you that if Gotham no longer needed Batman we could be together, I meant it. But now, I’m sure, the day won’t come when you no longer need Batman.”). Wayne, in the meantime, obliviously continues to slip further into the dark abyss of the cowl.

Christian Bale’s guttural, almost ridiculously gruff growl as Batman has drawn a lot of criticism, and initially I was put-off and distracted by it as well. This choice, however, is a finely calculated decision, both directorially and in terms of the character. The difference in voice between Batman and Wayne is so extreme that it effectively separates the two in the audience’s mind. They feel like different characters, and the overlap that existed between them in the first film has almost entirely disappeared here. Gone are the suiting up sequences, and only one scene in the entire film shows us Bruce in the Batman outfit (fittingly enough, it is an emotionally pivotal moment wherein he wrestles with how his choices have led to Rachel’s death). The basement-crawling growl serves to accentuate this division, and it becomes a brilliant maneuver rather than a grating liability.

In addition, it serves to reason that as Bruce is further consumed by his dark half he will embrace, and even revel in, the theatricality of the Batman. The grand entrances, the stunning exits, the shock-and-awe gadgetry, and the rumbling bass are all part of the performance. In The Dark Knight, Bruce begins taking that to ever increasing extremes: escaping with captured criminals by being whipped out of skyscrapers by Skyhook, harnessing the power of thousands of cellphones to paint a sonar portrait of Gotham, and deepening his already-deep growl. As he builds up a tolerance to the Batman drug, Bruce accelerates the spectacle, becoming more and more of a theatrical junkie. And while this certainly serves to threaten his sense of personal identity, it also harbors a much nastier and much less psychological consequence.

Enter the Joker, the direct and tangible result of Batman’s existence. In pulling on the mask, Bruce has “changed things forever,” as the Joker opines while hanging upside down by one leg. He is the yang to Batman’s yin, the Laurel to his Hardy, the flipside of the coin, the unavoidable balance that the universe must bring about. In previous incarnations, both comic and cinematic, Batman was directly responsible for the Joker’s creation by accidentally knocking him into a vat of acid, but here he simply exists by virtue of Batman existing. “You crossed the line first,” Alfred remarks. Giving birth to a new class of crime fighter, Bruce Wayne inevitably birthed its dark twin, a “new class of criminal.”

Heath Ledger is a force of nature. Despite his tragic and untimely death, despite the media circus surrounding him and the film, his performance crushes whatever preconceived notions or extenuating expectations you might have brought into the theater. It is not Heath Ledger. It is not an actor. It is not a real person who once lived and is now dead. It is only the Joker. In all his chaotic charisma, he reaches out with his velvety gloves and erases everything from your mind but him and him alone. There is no hyperbole in saying this is an Oscar worthy performance. Given Ledger’s death and the political nature of the Academy, his posthumous win come February is absolutely guaranteed.

“Nothing. No name. No other alias. Clothing is custom. Nothing in his pockets but knives and lint.” Commissioner Gordon’s estimation of the Joker is a snapshot of who Nolan and Ledger have chosen to give us. Rather than delve into a tired origin story, they have stripped him of his past and loosed him, like a “mad dog,” upon Batman and audiences alike. There is no beginning to him, no back story that might grant him “motivation,” no before and after that has marked nearly every villain in Batman’s storied history. The multiple sob stories that the Joker tells only serve to highlight the fact that he no longer has a story. The Joker simply is.

But what he is not, however, is solely a metaphorical symbol for anarchy and chaos. The Joker did have a past life, and the fact that he was someone is important, even if who he was is not. The original man has been swallowed whole by the Joker, as whole as hell swallows the doomed. The person has become the persona, disappearing fully inside the theatrical – scars, makeup, and purple cloth are all that remain. It is the same fate that awaits Bruce Wayne – how long before he has been completely replaced by cowl, growl, and cape? They are the same at different stages, Bruce Wayne in transition, the Joker having completed his. The Crown Prince of Crime is the inevitable conclusion to the Caped Crusader.

Other moments in the film bear this interrelatedness out. In front of one of the Joker’s deranged and schizophrenic henchmen, Batman remarks to Harvey Dent, “[He is] the kind of mind that the Joker attracts.” The irony is lost on him, as he himself attracts likeminded individuals, unstable copycats intent on vigilantism. “What gives you the right? What’s the difference between you and me?” one of them challenges Batman. His response, “I’m not wearing hockey brands,” is an indication of Bruce Wayne’s self-delusion. Whereas the Joker recognizes, and embraces, the attractive gravity of his persona, Batman denies it. “See, to them, you’re just a freak, like me.” The hero refuses to accept that he is identical to his wannabe batmen and his freakish opponent, just coated with a different shade of paint. His disillusionment is total.

Even the score and the method in which it was created illustrates both the dichotomy and the similarities between the Joker and the Batman. Hans Zimmer and James Newton Howard collaborated on the score, and when asked which one had composed which aspect of it, they said,

HZ: Nobody will ever know who wrote what tune and what piece.
JNH: Including us!
HZ: Including us. We were doing it on this one, listening to something from the first one, going is that your tune or is that my tune?
JNH: Really true, we just don’t know anymore.

Yet when composing for the Joker they split apart, and Hans Zimmer alone composed the twisted clown’s theme.

HZ: I think that the fearlessness within the character of The Joker and the recklessness, I felt the music had to reflect that – and the single-mindedness. So that in a funny way was where the team idea went out of the window because it really had to be written as one.

Together, yet separate. Alike, yet different. Opposite sides of the same coin.

The image of a coin carries the symbiotic relationship between Batman and the Joker even deeper. Like warring parents within a destructive marriage, others become pawns in their quest to triumph over one another. One of those pawns is Harvey Dent. Batman sees him as a way to escape from his addiction, from the self-inflicted prison he is unable to break out of: “Gotham needs a hero with a face…Harvey is that hero.” The Joker sees him in an entirely different, yet no more selfish, light: “You need an ace in the hole. Mine’s Harvey.” Between them both the White Knight of Gotham is torn apart. If Batman represents the second act and the Joker represents the tragic finale, then Harvey “Two-Face” represents the entire 3-act play.

Handsome, charismatic, idealistic, and with a flair for the dramatic, Harvey Dent is initially no different than Bruce Wayne. Where Wayne ‘kidnaps’ an entire Russian ballet company in order to fabricate an alibi, Dent disarms a witness in court, strips the gun apart, and then insists on continuing his cross-examination. Both of them are consummate showmen.

And then, just as it descended upon Bruce, tragedy strikes Harvey Dent. His loved ones taken from him by violence and his face boiled to char, he enters a dark, self-destructive place. The same anger and inner turmoil that took Bruce to a Chinese concentration camp in Batman Begins takes Harvey deep inside his own ruined psyche. As it happened to the Joker, and as it is happening to Wayne, Harvey fully embraces madness. He destroys the man he was, and Harvey Dent disappears forever. The arc is complete. In his place he leaves Two-Face, the twisted child of both Batman and the Joker. Batman gave him the coin, but the Joker taught him how to flip it. “I brought him down to our level. It wasn’t hard. You see madness, as you know, is like gravity. All it takes is a little push.”

The structural beauty and thematic symmetry of The Dark Knight is completely owed to both Christopher and Jonathan Nolan’s brilliant script and Lee Smith’s precise editing. Both are works of art in their own right. Like movements within a symphony, the Nolans weave Batman and the Joker and Harvey Two-Face in and through and around one another, each character reflecting the themes of choice and responsibility and madness. And each of these movements is juggled with expert skill by Smith, who manages, during key moments, three to four separate sequences, blending them all together to create a single, cohesive narrative vision. Notice the final scene, where Batman chooses to shoulder the blame for Harvey’s crimes. Smith moves from Batman and Gordon, to Harvey Dent’s funeral, to Gordon destroying the bat symbol, to Alfred, to Lucius, and then back to Batman, all within the space of mere minutes. Each characters’ story is resolved, and the themes that have been building and rising the entire film crest the top of the wave and crash down in a stunning crescendo, set to Newton and Zimmer’s epic score.

“I’ve seen what I would have to become to stop men like him.” The irony is that in order to stop the Joker from triumphing, Bruce has to embrace the very thing he desperately attempted to reject. He must become the criminal, the murderer, the hunted dog. He must be the man who has no rules, the one who defies laws. He must become the villain. He must become the freak. He must completely, and totally, become the Batman.

With Dent lying broken before him and Rachel, dead, behind him, Bruce finally accepts what he is, what he has become, what Alfred saw from the beginning and what Rachel somehow knew all along. Batman is no longer a part of him, but an icon, a symbol, something beyond himself. The Bat has taken on a life of its own, and the man, at last, embraces the truth of the persona. His sacrifice in doing so is personal, psychological, and perhaps ultimate. One of the strongest ties to his former life, the woman he loved, has been severed, and his hope for a Batman-less Gotham has perished with Harvey Dent. So he willingly races into the future, into a world where Bruce Wayne has faded from memory, a world where only the Dark Knight remains.

He finally understands the consequences of putting on the mask.

BATMAN: You either die a hero, or you live long enough to see yourself become the villain. I can do those things, because I’m not a hero, not like Dent. I killed those people. That’s what I can be.

GORDON: No, no, you can’t, you’re…

BATMAN: I’m whatever Gotham needs me to be. Call it in.

GORDON: (to crowd at Dent’s funeral) A hero. Not the hero we deserved, but the hero we needed. Nothing less but a knight, shining.
(to Batman) They’ll hunt you.

BATMAN: You’ll hunt me. Condemn me. Set the dogs on me. I guess that’s what needs to happen, because sometimes, the truth isn’t good enough, sometimes people deserve more. Sometimes people deserve to have their faith rewarded.

Batman flees on foot.

GORDON’S SON: Why is he running, Dad?

GORDON: Because we have to chase him.

GORDON’S SON: He didn’t do anything wrong.

GORDON: He’s the hero that Gotham deserves, but not the one it needs right now. So we’ll hunt him, because he can take it, because he’s not a hero. He’s a silent guardian, a watchful protector.

The Dark Knight

About the Author:
Evan Derrick loves movies, loves talking about movies, and even makes them from time to time. In the rare moment when movies aren’t consuming his grey matter, he enjoys eating grilled cheese sandwiches, playing with his baby daughter, and pretending to be the senior editor for MovieZeal.com. Use the Tulsa Today search feature to read previous reviews by this author. 

Secret Service agents raid ASD

Early Tuesday morning Quincy, Florida was abuzz with U.S. Secret Service agents.

They were in town to serve search warrants at 11 South Calhoun Street and at the home of Andy and Faye Bowdoin, 8 Gilcrease Road, Lake Talquin, south of Quincy.  Andy Bowdoin is listed as the president, secretary and treasurer of the local internet ad company, ASD Cash Generator (Ad Surf Daily, Inc.).

Secret Service agent Robert Munson, resident agent in charge at the scene, stated that there was an ongoing investigation involving the web-based business.  He stated that at this time he was not at liberty to discuss the case.  However, there were a number of agents on hand going in and out of the ASD complex and all of the company’s employees apparently had been sent home.

According to the Secret Service website, the Secret Service can investigate crimes involving the internet.  The website states: Secret Service’s ECTF and Electronic Crimes Working Group initiatives prioritize investigative cases that involve electronic crimes. These initiatives provide necessary support and resources to field investigations that meet any one of the following criteria: 
• Significant economic or community impact; 
• Participation of organized criminal groups involving multiple districts or transnational organizations; 
• Use of schemes involving new technology.
The Gadsden County Sheriff’s Office assisted in  serving the warrants but GCSO Lt. Jim Corder stated the sheriff’s department had no comment about the ongoing investigation at this time.
There had been a number of complaints concerning ASD, according to news sources.  The web-based ad generating business, according to a July press release concerning the business, said it was started in 2006 by Andy Bowdoin and his wife Faye. At the time of the press release, Bowdoin stated the company had 60 employees, 75,000 members and sales of $40 million.  Sales were expected to reach $100 million by the end of the year. 
ASD’s website stated Friday afternoon that, under the direction of the U.S. Attorney’s Office of the District of Columbia, it could not move funds in or out of company accounts. The organization would resolve the problem and return to normal operations, the website stated.
According to Tulsa Today in Tulsa, Oklahoma, a web-based news service and the first news source to question ASD’s operations, a large meeting of ASD associates was planned for Tulsa on August 23.
Editor David Arnett said he had received a number of complaints about the organization and decided to investigate the company.  You can view his articles concerning ASD [click for "ASD Cash Generator considered fraud" published Tuesday July 15th or click for "Feds halt ASD Cash Generator" published Sunday August 3rd.
According to a U.S. Attorney’s press release, a complaint was filed that a massive Internet-based wire fraud scheme was being operated by Thomas A. Bowdoin, Jr. and others out of a former flower shop located in Quincy, Florida.  According to the complaint, Bowdoin, through his company, AdSurfDaily, Inc., which operates on the Internet as ASD, operated a Ponzi scheme that he masked as an advertising company.
Ponzi schemes operate on the "Rob-Peter-To-Pay-Paul" principle – money from new investors is used to pay off earlier investors until the whole scheme collapses.

At press time there had been no arrests made.

Click here for a PDF file of the official complaint (Note: This is a large file over 100 pages that may take time to load.)

Feds halt ASD Cash Generator

Google news briefly removed from its service our last story on ASD Cash Generator (ASD), likely under threat of legal action from the company.  Google should not have done so without contacting Tulsa Today, but we are glad to see it back.  We never publish all we know about anything and as of Friday the U.S. Attorney General’s Office has apparently frozen ASD’s accounts.  The company’s main web site was changed to a single static page with the following text, “Upon direction from the U.S. Attorney’s office in the District of Columbia, ASD will not be able to move funds into company accounts, or out of them.  We will work to resolve this problem, and return to normal operation, as soon as we are permitted to do so.”

Tulsa Today is the first journalism organization in the world to shed light on what many people believe is a Ponzi scheme and a complicated fraud.   ASD was scheduled to convene a large meeting in Tulsa August 23rd.  Tulsa Today’s particular complaint is that there seems to be no actual advertising in the so-called advertising packages sold by ASD; therefore there was no complete transaction – outside of ASD harvesting money from the unsuspecting.

 

Jack Arons spent time and money investigating and protesting ASD and has been vilified by company supporters or “cheerleaders” with threats of lawsuits.  In response, Arons posted his contact information publicly asking ASD to bring it on.  Tulsa Today also received threats by e-mail and on our office voice mail.  The latest voicemail harassment message was recorded after ASD funds were frozen; it claims a $13 million lawsuit against Tulsa Today and this writer.  An earlier e-mail threatened $30 million.

Tulsa Today believes that work on this topic is a matter of public interest for readers, specifically because ASD was recruiting in Tulsa and publicized plans to do so here in mass at convention.

ASD seems to play fast and loose with the names of major corporations including Google, at conventions, web presentations and during personal recruitment pitches. Such ASD claims have been recorded and archived by Arons and others.  Does Google’s management understand that ASD has unjustly profited at its expense? Or does a business relationship between Google and ASD exist?
 
Investigations have found no ASD relationship with major corporations as company officials and cheerleaders have touted.

Our first source, Robert, worked the numbers on ASD and is quoted liberally in our first story (click here for “ASD considered fraud”).  Counter to company claims, many people believe that member money was being used to fund member revenue which on its face is illegal and defined as a Ponzi scheme or a fraudulent investment operation that involves promising or paying abnormally high returns to investors out of the money paid in by subsequent investors, rather than from net revenues generated by any real business.  It was named after Charles Ponzi. 

Several threads are available online with significant dialogue and personal testimonies of experience with ASD.  One of the most detailed is Scam.com (click here to reach the ASD thread on Scam.com).  More Internet discussions may also be found by simply utilizing various search engines.

In one such posting, a recruit wrote, “I went to an ASD meeting last Thursday night. It was my first introduction to this company.  In the company presentation, it was said that 100,000 people are current members.  Membership fees are $100.00 per month per member. That equates to revenue to the company of $120 million per year.

“The purpose of joining for members is to purchase "ad packets" from $500 on up to many thousands. This creates an account for them that thru internal machinations (by visiting websites and bringing in new members and receiving commisions) the account builds.

“ASD adds $ 0.25 to every dollar invested, and pays back to the account 1% per day for a maximum of 125%. In other words, if you buy an ad packet for $1000, they add $250 to it, and your account receives $12.50 for 125 days (or about 4 months) for a total of $1562.50,” recruit continued.

“Not bad. This equates to 168.75% per year return on your investment. And this doesn’t count the credits added to your account daily by visiting websites or commissions added from new investors or the compounding of your investment.

“If the 100,000 members were in it for only $1,000, ASD would be paying out a cool $169 million per year. But, several people at this meeting got up and testified that their accounts were getting credited with $600, $700, or $800 per day. And they had only been in it a few weeks. THIS IS A FAR CRY FROM $12.50 a day.

“So– ASD has got to come up with multiple billions per year to pay these members!!

"HOW DO THEY DO IT?  Well– When asked that question, ASD responded by saying that it sells advertising to corporations (plus member dues of $120 million per year).  I don’t think so. I find it highly unlikely that they are covering their costs this way,” the recruit added.

Many are befuddled as to how ASD generated money into the daily profit sharing pool aside from new ad packages being purchased by current and new members.  This was the question ASD failed to clearly answer and, from that failure, the charge that the business model lacks sustainability gained additional credence.

Returning to the advertising question, it is important to note that the advertising packages sold by ASD were not available for non-members to view.  Members were required log in and follow a viewing program for 15 seconds (a clock timer displays) then click on the next.  To buy the advertising packages from ASD, you were not required to have a business to advertise which begs the question of why people would purchase such packages other than for investment purposes which ASD repeatedly said they were not selling.

Watching a timer doesn’t equal an advertising impression in our media business.  We can teach a chicken to click a button every 15 seconds.  We can write a computer program to do the same.  There is no value, as we have written, in a paid view by a disinterested party.  Jack Arons reports that with his membership he followed the program and only saw promotions or listings of other multi-level-marketing (MLM) offers.

Was this advertising?  If so, what was being advertised?  Did major corporations look at ASD member web sites?  We doubt it?  Maybe this was the hope of ASD – to use a dynamic to offer a nonexistent product.  ASD reminds us of the 70s scheme, “Dare to Be Great” which required individuals to sell Adventures and Plans to others.  The court concluded that the scheme was “no less an investment contract merely because [the investor] contributes some effort as well as money to get into it” thus involving in substance, if not form, securities. (Click here for more from the book, “You can’t Cheat an Honest Man”.)

One cheerleader by e-mail referenced the Security and Exchange Commission (SEC) lawyers ASD has “on staff.”  The Tulsa Today response questioned why any company that so loudly declares it is not an investment opportunity nor subject to SEC regulations would employ multiple SEC lawyers?  That same writer declared as fact that ASD founder Andy Bowdoin “just has [sic] meetings in DC and met with the President and Vice-President and received some honors in relationship to what ASD is all about.”  Is it likely that the “honor” or “honors” received were distributed to a large number of Republican donors in one gathering?  Did Mr. Bowdoin disingenuously transpose this into an award?

Aside from the foregoing, Tulsa Today has found no proof that such a meeting ever took place.  Other investigators suggest that Bowdoin may have been in a room with political supporters that President Bush visited, but no award has been found in Bowdoin’s name.  Heck, I have met U.S. Presidents and other potentates, but that doesn’t mean they support any business of mine.  Bowdoin talks a lot about how great and honorable and successful he has been in business, but not about twenty companies associated with his name and later dissolved by the Florida Secretary of State.  A complete list of those companies follows this story.

Further, the recent announcement of ASD’s business relationship with William Levine the owner of www.Greenbackstreet.com which is still operating a web site, creates other questions.  Levine also has a long history of companies that have been dissolved due to no annual report.  A list of those fifty-five companies is found following Bowdoin’s also at end of this story.

MLMs have been around for decades and in dispute for much of that time.  The notable examples of properly run legal MLMs are Amway, Tupperware and Avon which all include tangible products.  Hundreds of want-to-be MLM schemes have been declared illegal.  Is ASD due for such declaration?  Only a court of law can determine the facts and declare such a ruling.

In a day of increased communication options within the historical existing group of dedicated MLM fans, new plans or schemes can be launched quickly and rise with the support of the greedy or merely hopeful to harvest millions before law enforcement and the courts can respond.  Could that be considered a conspiracy?  Again, only the courts can decide once the issue is before them and that process never works as fast as someone can hatch a new plan with new terminology or revised definitions of existing terms or complete business models.

For the public good, media has a responsibility to engage in considerations of fraud – to be suspicious – to raise concerns – prior to determinations by a court system that moves too slowly to prevent many from casting life savings to the wind.  With ASD, new communication allowed critics with concerns to link and multiple personal examples to be brought forward for public consideration.  If the pitch is public, then critics should have equal access to public publication of questionable issues within the pitch.

Tulsa Today stands proudly on our First Amendment Right to free speech and the Tenth Amendment, which reserves what rights that are not retained by Federal or state governments to the people.  We claim the right to consider issues publicly prior to their final legal determination by the court system – especially when issues reference Tulsa.  That may sound a little provincial to those readers who believe all things of importance only happen on the coasts, but expressions of appreciation for our ASD investigations have come from as far away as Canada and as close as a long-time reader, financial planner, and a former editor we have not heard much from in the last twenty years or so, Richard Hoe.

Hoe wrote, “Good piece, David.  I’m proud of you; the article was terrific.  I know someone who invested $10 thousand.  She says she has gotten $4 thousand back, and could have gotten more, had she not reinvested, whatever the hell that means.  ASD could be the greatest thing since peas in a can, but without full disclosure, how can anyone know?   I suspect that perhaps very few people have actually received more than 100% on their ASD investments—the whole idea of Ponzi schemes is to keep everyone in a form of suspended animation, selling others and reinvesting while waiting for his or her own ship to come in; if this is a Ponzi, and I hope it is not, it’s among the most clever I’ve seen.”

We agree, there is much confusion, but ASD considerations continue – on or off Google, Tulsa Today will maintain and continue publication until that confusion is resolved in a court of law.  


Addendum
Bowdoin talks a lot about how great and honorable and successful he has been in business, but not about the following companies associated with his name and later dissolved by the Florida Secretary of State:

BOWDOIN, T.A.  GLOBAL SATELLITE DEVELOPER, INC.  P00000061994
BOWDOIN, T. ANDERDSON JR.  PERRY TECHNOLOGY CORPORATION.  580904
BOWDOIN, T. ANDERSON, JR  CHRISTIAN IMPACT, INC.  733341
BOWDOIN, T. ANDERSON, JR  ESI, INC. OF PERRY  F02821
BOWDOIN, T. ANDERSON, JR  ESI, INC. OF ORLANDO  F05574
BOWDOIN, T. ANDERSON, JR.  CHRISTIAN IMPACT, INC.  733341
BOWDOIN, T. ANDERSON, JR.  TUBE-LITE OF DAYTONA BEACH, INC.  G63848
BOWDOIN, T. ANDERSON, JR.  WATERFALL FANTASY, INC.  G63849
BOWDOIN, T. ANDY  CREATIVE RETAILING SERVICES, INC.  P98000021820
BOWDOIN, THOMAS A  GPS TECH, INC.  P04000052704
BOWDOIN, THOMAS A  EADNETWORK, INC.  P06000148969
BOWDOIN, THOMAS A  WORLD PAYMENT SYSTEMS, INC.  P06000148978
BOWDOIN, THOMAS A  GPS TECH, INC.  P04000052704
BOWDOIN, THOMAS A  GPS DEVELOPMENT AND MANUFACTURING, INC. P04000154373
BOWDOIN, THOMAS ANDERSON  MI-COM, INCORPORATED
BOWDOIN, THOMAS ANDERSON, JR.  TUBE-LITE INTERNATIONAL, INC.  G59445
BOWDOIN, THOMAS ANDERSON, JR.  CROSBY ENTERPRISES OF LAKELAND, INCORPORATED  G86108
BOWDOIN, THOMAS ANDERSON, JR.  KDJ ENTERPRISES, INCORPORATED  G86109
BOWDOIN, THOMAS ANDERSON, JR.  SOUTH POLK INVESTORS, INC.  G94144
BOWDOIN, THOMAS ANDERSON, JR.  RIDGE-TEC, INC.  G94146

The recent announcement of ASD’s business relationship with William Levine the owner of www.Greenbackstreet.com which at this report still operating a web site, creates other questions.  Levine also has a long history of companies that have been dissolved due to no annual report, a list of those companies follow:

LEVINE, WILLIAM A.  INTERNATIONAL BEEFALO MARKETING, INC.  545977
LEVINE, WILLIAM A.  NATIONAL BEEFALO INDUSTRIES, INC.  574393
LEVINE, WILLIAM A.  TLC PLANT CO., INC.  621394
LEVINE, WILLIAM A.  NBI SEMEN, INC.  621395
LEVINE, WILLIAM A.  NBI MEAT, INC.  621396
LEVINE, WILLIAM A.  TCH INDUSTRIES, INC.  621397
LEVINE, WILLIAM A.  NATIONAL BEEFALO MARKETING, INC.  627808
LEVINE, WILLIAM A  GENESIS ENERGY, INC.  629666
LEVINE, WILLIAM A  NATIONAL BEEFALO MANAGEMENT, INC.  629667
LEVINE, WILLIAM A.  REPRODUCTIVE RESEARCH & TECHNOLOGY, INC.  635711
LEVINE, WILLIAM A.  TLC TRANSIT, INC.  659039
LEVINE, WILLIAM A  OLD BRIDGE CELLARS INC.  F94000004025
LEVINE, WILLIAM A.  ABBYMARK INDUSTRIES, INC.  G23933
LEVINE, WILLIAM A.  ANIMAL GENETICS & EMBRYONICS, INC.  G30806
LEVINE, WILLIAM A.  THE FURNITURE STORE, INC.  G50139
LEVINE, WILLIAM A.  FIRST COAST GROUP, INC.  H23631
LEVINE, WILLIAM A.  AMERICAN HOME DECORATING CENTER, INC.  H34391
LEVINE, WILLIAM A.  NATURE’S PLAN, INC.  H41845
LEVINE, WILLIAM A.  MLM DISTRIBUTORS, INC.  H60451
LEVINE, WILLIAM A.  PRIORITY PLANNER, INC.  J62235
LEVINE, WILLIAM A.  NETWORK PLANNING, INC.  K02359
LEVINE, WILLIAM A  ABBYMARK, LLC  L05000111199
LEVINE, WILLIAM A.  WATERBED WAREHOUSE OUTLET, INC.  M67299
LEVINE, WILLIAM A.  THE OASIS GROUP, INC.  M69932
LEVINE, WILLIAM A.  HEALTH & WEALTH 50/50, INC.  M69934
LEVINE, WILLIAM A.  RESEARCH DEVELOPMENT GROUP, INC.  M69935
LEVINE, WILLIAM A  MORTGAGE PLANNING, INC.  P04000017481
LEVINE, WILLIAM A  SNOWHOSTER, INC.  P04000099732
LEVINE, WILLIAM A.  PILOT PETROLEUM CORPORATION  P04070
LEVINE, WILLIAM A  GATENET, INC.  P05000161020
LEVINE, WILLIAM A  KLIKFIRE, INC.  P05000161029
LEVINE, WILLIAM A  GREENBACKSTREET, INC.  P07000124669
LEVINE, WILLIAM A  SUCCESS THRU KNOWLEDGE, INC  P08000051635
LEVINE, WILLIAM A.  ANGLO PETROLEUM CORPORATION  P11257
LEVINE, WILLIAM A.  IDEA SERVCOM INCORPORATED  P29702
LEVINE, WILLIAM A.  SECO SOUTH, INC.  P30352
LEVINE, WILLIAM A  PINNACLE COMMUNICATIONS INTERNATIONAL, INC.  P95000094532
LEVINE, WILLIAM A.  INTERNATIONAL BEEFALO MARKETING, INC.  545977
LEVINE, WILLIAM A.  NATIONAL BEEFALO INDUSTRIES, INC.  574393
LEVINE, WILLIAM A  TLC PLANT CO., INC.  621394
LEVINE, WILLIAM A  NBI SEMEN, INC.  621395
LEVINE, WILLIAM A  TCH INDUSTRIES, INC.  621397
LEVINE, WILLIAM A  GENESIS ENERGY, INC.  629666
LEVINE, WILLIAM A  NATIONAL BEEFALO MANAGEMENT, INC.  629667
LEVINE, WILLIAM A  TLC TRANSIT, INC.  659039
LEVINE, WILLIAM A.  ABBYMARK INDUSTRIES, INC.  G23933
LEVINE, WILLIAM A.  NETWORK PLANNING, INC.  K02359
LEVINE, WILLIAM A  MORTGAGE PLANNING, INC.  P04000017481
LEVINE, WILLIAM A  SUCCESS THRU KNOWLEDGE, INC  P08000051635
LEVINE, WILLIAM A  LEVINE HOLDINGS, INC.  P93000069025
LEVINE, WILLIAM A  PINNACLE COMMUNICATIONS INTERNATIONAL, INC.  P95000094532
LEVINE, WM. A  LEVINE HOLDINGS, INC.  P93000069025
LEVINE, WM A  COMMUNICATIONS CONCEPTS MANAGEMENT, INC.  P96000102045
LEVINE, WILLIAM  INTERACTIVE COMPUTER SOLUTIONS, INC.  P95000029581
LEVINE, WILLIAM  INTERNATIONAL COMMUNICATIONS SYSTEMS, INC.  L22873

TU Songstress on the road to fame

Natalie Tidwell is in the middle of a songwriting session in Nashville when the group adjourns for a moment. The opportunity for a breath of fresh air is appreciated. She has a few minutes before the session begins again. Just enough time to answer a few questions. Tidwell speaks, recalling moments in retrospect sweet enough to illustrate one of the sultry, country tunes she writes.

Comments from her center around a love of music, a dream held and captured. When Tidwell, a graduate of the University of Tulsa, (TU), arrived on campus as a young freshman from Oklahoma City, the notes were there, in her mind. All she needed was a little inspiration and an audience.
The fact that she’d find her audience in the form of professional truck drivers seems a gentle reminder that more than the economy is dependent upon the transportation industry–that drivers are, in fact, strong and influential enough to lift even an aspiring singer to the place she most wants to be, on the radio.  

It’s a dream realized thanks to them and one of the largest temperature-controlled transportation companies in the United States, the Frozen Food Express Industries, Inc, (FFE), headquartered in Dallas, TX.

“We entered into an arrangement with Natalie in May for her to serve as the voice of FFE and to assist with various media and communication projects. She is such a genuine and talented professional. Her understanding and appreciation of the trucking industry has enabled her to connect with drivers in a way that is different from any other recruiting campaign," Sherry F. Bass, FFE Vice President of Fleet Development, said.

With a calendar of events that is quickly filling up, Tidwell is preparing for her next live appearance. “We are looking forward to the opportunity to introduce her publicly as the FFE spokesperson at the 2008 Great American Trucking Show (GATS) in Dallas, Aug. 21-23," Bass said.

At the show, Tidwell will be cross promoting her current album, titled, Sign of Things to Come, which features a number of songs she wrote, such as "Sun Kissed." She plans to utilize the album and her music talents to build notoriety for FFE and the transportation industry.

"When you think about it, professional truck drivers have a lot of windshield time. That translates into radio time. Drivers are very discerning of talent and initial promotions by Natalie have been well received by them," Bass said.

"Driver reach is amazing when you consider that one out of every 13 people working in the private sector in the United States is employed in a trucking-related job. Nearly 50,000 people attended GATS last year and attendance this year is expected to be higher. This show is an important milestone for Tidwell and FFE recruiting projects."
Helping to promote Tidwell and FFE is Tennessee based ACS Advertising Account Executive and Marketing Professional, Tia Dorris. "One of the biggest challenges for advertising agencies is to find a symbol or person to strengthen the branding position of a company. Natalie Tidwell is a perfect person for this purpose. She is talented, attractive and has a real love for interacting with people."

Her participation with the Dallas based transportation giant is expected to grow. “It’s an exciting partnership for me. We already have some podcasts, print and commercial work planned," Tidwell said.

There are a number of other perks included in the package for Tidwell, such as sponsorship of her website located at www.natalietidwell.com, where songs may be purchased and downloaded.

"Utilizing a different website from our own is a new approach in marketing, but the goal is to make FFE more visible to volumes of internet traffic that may not normally visit our site," Bass said. Along with website sponsorship, Tidwell has been engaged by the company to perform at special events.
The marketing associated with her new role is geared toward two objectives: helping the company fill open positions with quality drivers and to warm up internal relations in a more personal and original way.

Immediately following GATS, FFE has plans for Tidwell to perform during National Truck Driver Appreciation Week, Aug. 24-30. "This is when America takes time to honor drivers for their hard work and commitment in tackling one of our economy’s most demanding and important jobs," Bass said. "What better way to thank our drivers than to commission someone like Natalie to serve as a public symbol of their hard work and dedication.”

Although jobless claims are high and many transportation companies are less than stable, FFE takes pride in strong positioning and being able to offer a number of opportunities, available for viewing online at www.ffeinc.com.

Lori Furnell, ACS Advertising Director of Client Services, has been measuring the campaign against the backdrop of current economic conditions. "This year has been extremely challenging for companies in the trucking industry. Fuel costs have increased and the demand for freight has decreased in some areas. FFE has always been on the cutting edge of marketing innovations and using Natalie as a spokesperson allows them to put a face and a personality out-front so that drivers, employees and customers have someone to relate to in uncertain, often tough, economic winds."

For Tidwell, who majored in marketing and graduated in 2000 from the University of Tulsa with a Bachelor of Science in Business Administration, it’s the chance to grab the brass ring, and further her already amazing career.

In graduate school at TU, Tidwell received a second offer to sing with Country Tonite. “I had already done it in the past in Branson and they gave me the opportunity to do it again in Pigeon Forge, TN.  I couldn’t turn down the opportunity. It gave me the facet to sing, perform and make a great living as well," Tidwell said.
Standing now, in the heart of Nashville, writing and working among some of the most talented songwriters, she continues to encourage the pursuit of higher learning and graciously describes the time she spent at TU as a wonderful, warm and inviting experience.

"The thing I liked most is that I never felt like I had to get their attention. They have a great student professor ratio and I found the academic experience rewarding,” she said.
Past professors are mentioned fondly. "I knew all of my instructors so well. It made a tremendous difference in the quality of my education,” she said.
TU is also where she met her husband, Tim Martin, a professional football player. "After college, he signed with the New England Patriots, transferred to the Miami Dolphins, and later spent some time with NFL Europe in Barcelona," Tidwell said. "He suffered a few injuries that put him out a bit, but he returned and played in arena football leagues out of Dallas, New Orleans and a few other areas before retiring. If there’s been one constant motivation for me, it’s been Tim."

The couple shares a tender, traditional tale of love and endurance. She was on the pom-pom squad and he was an athlete. She remembers their story fondly. "We met after a game one night. At the time, he had a broken foot," she said. "He liked me so much that he didn’t mind walking me all the way back to my dorm, broken foot and all. I thought it was sweet and that’s how it all started."

Tidwell and her husband return to TU for homecoming each year. Great supporters of the athletic department, they love "being among friends."  
It was not a rushed affair, by any means, when it comes to the two of them. Tidwell was 19 when she met Martin and the couple did not wed until she reached the age of 27.

"That was mainly due to our traveling," she said. "He really wanted me to go after my dream."

What is life, if there is not a dream or the courage to grab it—and Tidwell has always been brave and talented enough. Evidenced by her long list of accomplishments, she’s the type of person who can take the horse by the bit and run it.
 
In school, she was named a top 10 freshman, a top 10 senior, was a nominee for homecoming queen and landed in the top tier of her class in academics. She was also the captain of the dance team, a member of the Delta, Delta, Delta sorority, and sang the national anthem during athletic events.

"TU gave me the opportunity to shine. My advertising professor, Mr. Hinkle and my Marketing professor, Dr. James Cagley, were always there to help. That meant a lot to me," she said. “What other school offers that much faculty attention? That was one of the main reasons I loved TU. It was just a remarkable experience and I think most of the student body would agree when I say it is one of the best schools to attend."

As she learned the finer points of managing and marketing a career in and outside of college, Tidwell competed and performed in various talent competitions, including Star Search. Among other awards, she’s also been named the Next American Superstar on the Dave Nemo Show, in a competition co-sponsored by XM radio.

She may have blossomed in business at TU, but music was always her first priority. It’s a calling she heard at the age of five, onstage with Barbara Mandrell. She was at a concert with her parents, when Mandrell noticed her and invited the little girl onstage to perform.

"I just went up there and started singing my heart out to the song, Sleeping Single in a Double Bed. My parents knew right then and there that I was going to do that the rest of my life," she said. So, it seems.

Tidwell, as she gears up for another round of songwriting, has much to look forward to. "I’m excited about the upcoming events I have with FFE. I love one on one time with fans and having the opportunity to meet with them," she said. "Serving as the voice of FFE is turning into quite an experience. It is really wonderful. My fan base is continually growing with the nicest people you could hope to meet."

She continues, "Gaining exposure is great, but I’m doing this to help drivers and because I love to sing. I am glad the music touches the fans in a personal way. That is important to me."

The thought wraps up with a story of a new fan. "A lot of drivers contact me through the website. One particular FFE driver, who just recently sent an email, truly inspired something in me," she said.

The email, as she states, described how the driver appreciates her efforts to send a positive message about the trucking industry into the main stream public. "There is such a misconception about truck drivers. What they do is hard work. So many go above and beyond the call of duty and it‘s all in a days work for them," she said.

Russell Stubbs, Senior Vice President and Chief Operating Officer of FFE, describes trucking as a tough business, complete with its share of driver shortages and issues.
Tidwell, who grew up in Oklahoma and currently resides in Nashville, plans to utilize every opportunity she has through FFE in the next year to help enlighten the public about the transportation industry, not only through personal engagements, but in her music as well. Her husband, Tim, who works as an engineer for a construction company, is standing by her every step of the way.

As a couple who has traveled extensively, they understand the hardships truckers face. Those experiences help her connect on a deeper level with an ever-growing fan base.
"Truckers spend so much time away from their families, on the road, day in and day out to keep America going. If it were not for them, all of our lives would be different," she said. "Their continuing efforts mean so much to our daily activities. I am honored and so thankful to be in a position to help, in whatever small way possible, to lighten their load."

It’s a feeling she extends further in her song, Here you are.
“You were like a circle on the map…A destination I was told to drive to…We were touched by an angel’s wings…I know it’s true, cause baby here you are. Here you are.”


About the Author:
Tracy Crain is a creative writer with Affiliated Computer Services in Maumelle, AR and works as the media and public relations specialist for FFE. She has been a freelance writer for eight and a half years for a variety of newspapers and holds degrees in Journalism from Arkansas and completed post graduate work from the University of Memphis. To contact Tracy, please email tlcrain10@aol.com. 

Swanson: trial lawyers fund Democrats

The head of the Oklahoma Republican Senatorial Committee, Randy Swanson, said today that trial lawyers "are almost singularly funding key Democrat campaigns."

And, he charged, some of them are trying to do that while hiding their occupations.

Swanson said Senator Nancy Riley of Tulsa and candidates Robert Murphy of Stillwater and Diane Drum of Norman have received over 70% of their financial support from lawyers outside of their districts.

“Without the largesse of big-time lawyers who have a vested interest in seeing Republicans defeated at the polls, candidates like Nancy Riley, Robert Murphy and Diane Drum would barely have enough campaign money to buy that high-priced gasoline for which Riley is so grateful,” said Swanson, executive director of the GOP committee.

“The very lawyers who have financed Brad Henry’s campaigns, resulting in his consistent vetoes of lawsuit reform legislation, are now funding Democrat Senate candidates across the state and Democrat campaign committees.

“In the case of Nancy Riley, their investment is already paying dividends, due to the fact that she has flip-flopped numerous times on the important tort reform legislation we need to keep our business climate and medical services thriving,” Swanson said. “She was for it before she was against it.”
An analysis of Ethics reports over the past three reporting periods (4th quarter 2007, 1st & 2nd quarters 2008) indicate the following startling statistics, he said:

Senator Nancy Riley of Tulsa has raised $125,065 in individual, reportable (over $50) contributions. Of that figure, $85,425 has been raised from trial lawyers. Add the $5,400 her campaign has raised from lobbyists and Democrat legislators, such special interests account for 72.6% of Riley’s financial support.

Candidate Robert Murphy of Stillwater, the former judge, only recently announced his candidacy, and has filed one Ethics report. In that report, Murphy reports raising $51,600 from individuals, of which $35,900 – 69.6% — has come from lawyers, most from outside of Stillwater or Payne County.

Candidate Diane Drum of Norman has raised $74,485 from individuals of which $56,115 has come from lawyers, most of whom live outside Norman and Cleveland County, accounting for 75.3% of her financial receipts.

"In a tactic indicative of haphazard campaign reporting or intentional misrepresentation, many lawyers list their occupations on these reports as Self Employed, Consultant, or some other innocuous title," Swanson’s news release said. "However, a simple online search of their names belies their true occupations, and exposes the magnitude of the support from this special interest group enjoyed by Democrats."

“This is just the tip of the iceberg,” Swanson said. “A vast majority of the lawyers who have contributed to these and other Democrat Senate candidates have not yet given the legal maximum amount, so there are hundreds of thousands of dollars still on the table for their cause.

“With almost three of every four dollars in Democrat campaigns coming from the Democrat Party’s most affluent and reliable special interest group, the Trial Bar is making its last, bold stand to maintain its stranglehold on the Capitol, and the State Senate is their final beachhead. They won’t go down without a fight. Oklahoma voters need to be aware of who controls the Democrats in the Senate, and to whom they are beholden."
 


About the Author:
Mike McCarville has covered Oklahoma politics and government since he became State Capitol Correspondent for The Tulsa Tribune in 1966. Since, he has been a governor’s press secretary, investigative reporter, television station news executive, radio station program director and talk show host, and political consultant. In 1980, he founded The McCarville Report and it is the nation’s longest-running state political publication. In its online version, it has been called "The best political blog" by Dr. Keith Gaddie, pollster and pundit and "Oklahoma’s venerable McCarville Report" by The Arkansas Times.  McCarville, also a real estate investor and commentator for the National Rifle Association on NRANews.com and Sirius Satellite Radio, is a regular contributor to Tulsa Today.