Yearly Archives: 2008

Sparks fly in run-off election

Saturday, 09 August 2008
Voters in Oklahoma Senate District 35 and House District 72 face a fast approaching run-off and while some former opponents have become friends; others are turning up the rhetorical heat targeting the Tuesday August, 26 contests.  Much quieter Special Municipal Elections for the City of Jenks and City of Owasso will also be held that day in Tulsa County.  Welcome summer politics in Oklahoma.

Cason Carter, the Republican candidate for Senate District 35 that led the primary election field with 45% of the vote recently added third place finisher, Jeff Applekamp, to his list of supporters.  They are not at all happy with fellow Republican Gary Stanislawski who opposes Carter in the hotly contested seat held by Senator Jim Williamson.

"I’m very pleased to endorse Cason Carter," said Applekamp.  "During a stressful campaign, you can find out a lot about a candidate’s personal integrity, and Cason passed every test with flying colors.  I witnessed Cason being truthful and forthright with voters and never heard of him or his campaign uttering an untrue or negative word."

"I believe that Gary Stanislawski intentionally tried to deceive the voters on multiple occasions.  The most egregious example was his blatant attempt during the waning hours of the campaign to insinuate that Senator Jim Inhofe was supporting him — something that could not be further from the truth.  The fact is Stanislawski’s use of a photo of him with Senator Inhofe prompted Senator Inhofe to issue a statement to deny he had endorsed him. Many voters, however, already had the image in their mind and are just now finding out that this was a hoax perpetuated by Stanislawski," Applekamp said.

Stanislawski campaign manger Josh McFarland answered, “The picture was taken at the State Republican Convention this year and Senator Inhofe said at that time we could use the photograph, but that he was not endorsing anyone in a primary election.  We were very clear in the mailing that both Billy Joe Daugherty and Senator Inhofe do not and were not endorsing the campaign, but as individuals they know and respect Gary Stanislawski.”

Applekamp also said, “It didn’t end with this.  He ran a radio ad calling me a “lifetime bureaucrat” but I’ve always worked in the private sector, never receiving a government paycheck.  It’s clear that Stanislawski plays fast and loose with the truth,” Applekamp added.

McFarlin said, “We have moved beyond the primary and wish Applekamp the best, but he worked as a lobbyist.  He campaigns on and brags about that experience working with government.  Ok, so Public Service Company of Oklahoma is a private company, but they sent him to the Legislature to become an insider or friend of the system as a paid lobbyist and we need elected officials that are not lobbyists or trial lawyers.”

Cason Carter said, "I am very happy to have the support and help of Jeff Applekamp.  I have known Jeff for quite some time, and he is an active part of the fabric of Tulsa and the Republican Party.  He ran a positive campaign and proven he is a man of character who understands the issues.  I am grateful to Jeff for his support and glad to add such a quality person to our campaign team.”

What was once a five-way District 72 primary battle for retiring Rep. Darrell Gilbert’s seat is now a contest between Democrats Seneca Scott and Christie Breedlove also to be decided August 26.

Scott, who captured 42 percent of the vote, said, "At the end of the day, folks don’t care which party wins, they just want policy issues fixed to help the people of the district.  Issues in District 72 include street repair, home ownership, and the reduction of crime.”

Scott is active in the Oklahoma Sustainability Network, a grass-roots initiative that works on energy conservation and local food production such as farmer’s markets.  He has been endorsed by John Slater and Wilbert Collins both prominent Democrats in the heavily Democrat registered district.

Breedlove works for a pipeline company and has been active as a campaign worker in other races for several election cycles.  She is a leader in an Oklahoma women’s Democrat group.  Breedlove, who had 29 percent of the votes, said she had expected all along to be headed into a runoff.

The winner in the District 72 runoff will face Lawrence Kirkpatrick, a frequent independent candidate who has never won a race.

County Election Board Secretary Patty Bryant said voters in Tulsa County who want to have absentee ballots mailed to them for the State Runoff Primary Election for Senate District 35 and House District 72 and Special Municipal Elections for the City of Jenks and City of Owasso to be held August 26, should apply now.  Although the County Election Board can accept applications for absentee ballots until 5 p.m. on Wednesday, August 20, Bryant urged voters who want to vote by absentee ballot to apply early.  Absentee ballot application forms are available at the County Election Board office located at 555 N. Denver.  A letter may be mailed or faxed requesting a ballot, or a form letter may be downloaded from the Tulsa County Election Board Webpage (http://www.tulsacounty.org/, click Departments/Divisions, click Election Board).

"At least two mail transactions must be made," Bryant said.  "The County Election Board must mail the ballots to the voter, and the voter must return the voted ballots by mail."   Ballots must be in the hands of the County Election Board by 7 p.m. on election day in order to be counted.

Bryant said that any registered voter may vote by absentee ballot in any election in which he or she is eligible to vote.  However, a voter must be registered and reside at an address within the geographical boundaries of the district to be eligible to vote.
Last Updated ( Saturday, 09 August 2008 )

Blank for my horses?

Beer For My Horses
United States, 2008

Directed By: Michael Salomon
Written By: Rodney Carrington & Toby Keith
Starring: Toby Keith, Rodney Carrington, Tom Skerritt, David Allan Coe, Willie Nelson, Ted Nugent
Running Time: 97 minutes
Rated PG-13 for some violence, sexual humor and dialogue, language, drug content and brief nudity
3 out of 5 stars

When the filmʼs publicist asked me if I would like a screening copy of Beer For My Horses to review, I said yes and immediately regretted it. A star vehicle for country singer/songwriter Toby Keith, I had seen the ads and knew that it was targeted quite specifically at a demographic that I was not a part of in any way, shape, or form: I donʼt listen to country music; I donʼt dream of driving a bigger truck than the truck I currently donʼt drive; I never watched Blue Collar TV because I never laughed when I did. Yet here I was, agreeing to deliver a critical opinion on a film that combined all three of those elements. This wasnʼt going to end well.

 
Films that 1) star musicians in the lead role and 2) are ostentatiously named after one of said musicianʼs hit songs/albums/stage names can go either way. On the positive end of things you have Princeʼs Purple Rain, a certifiable hit both cinematically and musically. The negative end of the scale, however, weighs a metaphorical ton with such career destroyers as Cool As Ice and Glitter, which Vanilla Ice and Mariah Carey (respectively) probably continue to have blood-curdling nightmares about. Fortunately, Beer For My Horses (named after a hit single by Toby Keith and Willie Nelson) falls into the former category. By the time the credits had rolled, the film had managed to win me over, and while I wasnʼt lying on the floor in some state of euphoric awe, I had thoroughly enjoyed its humor, quirks, and shockingly competent supporting cast. Consider me mildly charmed.

Toby Keith and Rodney Carrington star in the title roles, beer-swilling deputy Rack and his dopey sidekick Lonnie, who hold court in a small Oklahoman town. After foiling some fertilizer theft, they inadvertently anger a Mexican drug lord by imprisoning his caricature of a brother. The drug lord, understandably upset, kidnaps Rack’s love interest and demands an exchange, sending the two deputies on a cross-country rescue mission, complete with idealistic hookers and sideshow carnies.

While the story is painfully recycled, the script (by both Keith and Carrington) is surprisingly spry. It sparkles with down-home colloquialisms like "swelled bigger than an 8 legged dog tick" and features an incredibly diverse roster of eclectic characters. There’s the elderly department secretary (Tish Rayburn-Miller) who is both a manners nazi and a twilight sex fiend; Willie Nelson pops up as a moonshine-brewing carnival ringmaster in one of the film’s most surreal sidetrips (a midget named Merriweather lights himself on fire and a woman named Two Ton Tina gives Lonnie a bearhug. No, seriously); and Ted Nugent (in what is easily my favorite role) plays an uzi-toting mute named Skunk who was raised on a reservation, has his ‘badge’ tattooed over his heart, and shoots arrows into various posteriors (both man and donkey). And how do you explain the musical interlude at an interstate rest stop where Lonnie sings "You Make Me Want To Shout" while urinating, and a posse of gang bangers (who just happen to be lounging in the bathroom) spontaneously break into harmony? Beer For My Horses is chock full of such bizarre moments and asides, and while I’m tempted to suspect that Keith and Carrington were downing Nelson’s moonshine during most of the writing process, I’m more inclined to believe that this is a cult classic in the making. If Napoleon Dynamite was for the hipster set, Beer For My Horses if for the good-‘ole-boy one.

The heart of the film, however, lies with Toby Keith, who manages an effortless aura of self-deprecation. Although it’s obvious he would like to spin this off into more meaty leading man roles, he conspicuously lacks the pretension that most star musicians would bring to such a role. Lesser films would have the roadside bombshell flutter her lashes all "come-hither" like at the strapping hero; here he just gets the finger. Keith isn’t taking himself too seriously, and that decision earns the film untold dividends.

Sadly, the directorial skill behind Beer For My Horses does not match the cleverness of the script. It is barely cinematic, having been shot in wides and mediums (probably due in part to time and fiscal restrictions); the sound design is uninspired (the gunshots during the final shootout likely came from a royalty free sound effects library); and the little green screen work that exists in the film is woefully amateur. And although Keith effortlessly exudes his unpretentious charisma the majority of the film, whenever director Michael Salomon asks him to get serious, he ends up grimacing like a child who just realized that the Halloween candy he’d been saving for 6 months went bad. Since both director and star’s previous experience is almost exclusively limited to music videos (excepting a single dramatic turn by Keith in ’06s Broken Bridges), that might explain the mediocre quality of the dramatic elements, but it doesn’t bode well for either of their respective future careers.
But does any of that really matter? To the film’s target demographic, probably not. Beer For My Horses fetishizes big trucks with gaudy airbrush jobs, features a soundtrack of country hits that I couldn’t identify if my life depended on it, and mixes romance and corn dogs without a trace of irony. I don’t understand any of those things, but I can appreciate that others do. If you can fill in the following blank ("______________________ and beer for my horses") without missing a beat, then purchase yourself a ticket posthaste.


About the author:

Evan Derrick loves movies, loves talking about movies, and even makes them from time to time. In the rare moment when movies aren’t consuming his grey matter, he enjoys eating grilled cheese sandwiches, playing with his baby daughter, and pretending to be the senior editor for MovieZeal.com. Use the Tulsa Today search feature to read previous reviews by this author.

Issue light comedy

Swing Vote
(United States, 2008)
Directed By: Joshua Michael Stern
Written By: Joshua Michael Stern, Jason Richman
Starring: Kevin Costner, Madeline Carroll, Paula Patton, Kelsey Grammer, Dennis Hopper, Nathan Lane, Stanley Tucci, George Lopez
Running Time: 119 min.
Rated PG-13 for language
3.5 out of 5 stars{mosimage}

Swing Vote is the cinematic equivalent of a servile politician. He has nothing new to bring to the table, nothing to say that really inspires the American people, and hardly any real platform to speak of—but he just really wants your vote, will do anything to get it, and heck, he’s just a darn nice guy. What more could you want? Well, substance, maybe, but if so, you’re clearly looking in the wrong country. Swing Vote is undeniably a fun piece of fluff, but those looking for real, meaningful discussion should remain cloistered at the local art house.

The (painfully high-concept) plot of Swing Vote unfolds almost exactly as you might imagine it was pitched to the studio execs: Kevin Costner plays Earnest “Bud” Johnson, a divorced blue collar slob who lives in trailer with his precocious daughter Molly (Madeline Carroll) in the backwater town of Texico, New Mexico.

Molly has been assigned to write an essay for school on her experience of going to vote with her father, who, as you might imagine, isn’t interested in the upcoming presidential election at all. No problem—Molly forges his signature and registers him; then, when he fails to show up at the polls, she sneaks in and votes for him. But the computers fail at a moment that could only happen in Hollywood—and Bud’s fraudulent vote is not counted.

When it becomes clear just how close this presidential race is—it’s come down to New Mexico, and, in fact, Bud’s own Curry County, which is exactly tied—it’s decided that Bud will be allowed to recast his ballot. And when words gets out about the situation, Texico becomes a media circus, as reporters, lobbyists and politicians all mob Bud, trying to find out what makes him tick—and how to get his vote.

From there, the film hits exactly every beat you expect it to, but somehow it manages to be a lot of fun—a fact that owes primarily to the excellent cast they’ve assembled here. It’s beyond me why so many A-list (or at least high-B-list) actors signed on for such bland, broad material, but Kevin Costner and his co-producer Jim Wilson managed to cast the roles almost perfectly: Kelsey Grammer as the good-natured but dimwitted Republican incumbent, Dennis Hopper as the weasely but well-meaning Democratic hopeful, Stanley Tucci (The Devil Wears Prada, The Hoax) and Nathan Lane as their respective campaign managers. The only real misstep here is a rather bland Paula Patton as a local news anchor, but fortunately, George Lopez shows up as her manager, brightening things up a bit.

The cast manages to sell the gags, which have a surprising amount of depth (even a slapstick scene where a drunken Bud walks into a “Vote Today!” sign had me laughing for an embarrassingly long time). Grammer and Tucci’s comic timing are impeccable as always, and Lane owns his character well, but the real surprise here is child actress Carroll, who literally carries the entire film, both in terms of plot and in terms of charisma. As the foil to Costner’s (very well-done) man-child, Carroll’s girl-adult becomes the hero of the film (though key scenes prove that she’s just as fallible as her dad), and she displays an acting ability that’s beyond her years. Here’s hoping she’ll make producers forget about Freddie Highmore.

Even while Swing Vote manages to entertain, however, it still manages to disappoint. It feels like a rehash of a rehash of Capra (specifically, Ivan Reitman’s Dave, right down to the talking head cameos)—an unsure attempt to recapture the Italian auteur’s effortlessly naïve and idealistic take on Americana. I guess it shouldn’t be a surprise that Swing Vote wants to avoid offending, even as it uses “hot-button” (read: irresolvable) issues like abortion and gay marriage as plot points—but in acknowledging them at all, all it succeeds in doing is highlighting its own lack of teeth. There are moments of bite—a delightfully offensive anti-abortion campaign ad that features exploding children—but for the most part, this is a film that’s content to trot out the same old Democrat/Republican gags we’ve been hearing since before Watergate.

Therein lies the real issue: at some level, Swing Vote wants to be a message movie, and it eventually (after the laughs are over) mounts its soapbox to remind Americans that Every Vote Counts!—but it’s plagued by a conundrum that even it doesn’t know how to get around. Bud has only two choices: the Democrat or the Republican, and they’ve both been shown to be not all that different. Swing Vote wants us to believe that deep down, all of us—even our generic, weasely politicians—are the same Americans, but that it somehow still matters who is in the Oval Office. If you’re doubting that this is the same sort of issue-avoiding drivel you get from CNN every election year, pay attention to the climactic debate: as soon as the actual debate begins, we cut to the next scene. I guess you could say that this story is not really about politics; it’s about Bud reclaiming his life—but any way you look at it, Swing Vote is a movie that wants people to feel, not think.

All that said, it’s still not a bad film, and would make for a great family outing—call it a primer on the electoral process. It’s rated PG-13 “for language,” but if the MPAA knew what they were doing, they would have bumped it down to a PG. The language comes almost exclusively from Bud—it’s absolutely necessary for showing the kind of character he is—and Molly is the one who calls him out on it repeatedly (“Stop using ‘Jesus’ as a cuss word—he’s a billion people’s savior, you know!”). With or without the kids, though, Swing Vote is an enjoyable flick with an impeccable sense of humor. Just lower your expectations, check your brain at the door, and let the cast work its magic.


About the author:

A graduate of the University of Nebraska, Luke Harrington currently resides in Tulsa and works in the aerospace industry–but, at any given moment, would probably rather be reviewing movies.  In his spare time, he’s off playing blues piano and pretending to be Assistant Editor for MovieZeal.com.

The British at Brideshead

Brideshead Revisited
United Kingdom, 2008
Directed By: Julian Jarrold
Written By: Jeremy Brock and Andrew Davies, from the book by Evelyn Waugh
Starring: Matthew Goode, Ben Whishaw, Hayley Atwell, Emma Thompson
Running Time: 134 min.
Rated PG-13 for some sexual content
3.5 out of 5 stars
I was a little wary stepping into a screening of Brideshead Revisited. These British-movies-based-on-British-novels (Pride and Prejudice et. al.) tend to be, in my experience, mere “fan service”—little more than visual imaginings of the novel, intended primarily (or even exclusively) for fans of the novel (sort of like a more-literate take on our recent spate of comic book films stateside)—and I had barely even heard of Evelyn Waugh’s classic tome Brideshead Revisited. (I’m really not sure how that happened, as I possess a bachelor’s degree in English—perhaps because my literature professors always tended toward either extremely old British fiction, or extremely recent American fiction written by “diverse” authors, neither of which describes Brideshead at all. Regardless, it appears that I’m a Philistine. Consider this my formal apology to the literacy police.) Walking out, I felt roughly the same way.

The question, of course, is whether my personal experience should count as an asset or a liability in reviewing the film, and I guess the choice on that matter is up to you. On the one hand, I brought a clean slate to the film and was (theoretically) able to judge it on its own merit, without any of the bias that would have come from reading the original novel (or, for that matter, viewing the 1980s BBC serial); on the other, I’m pretty much the last person fans of the novel will want to hear from, as I can tell you next to nothing about how closely the film hews to the text or whether it does it any sort of justice. Even with that out of the way, though, I still have very little to say about this film. Is it good? Sure. Is it great? Well…no.
I found Brideshead moderately engaging throughout, with scenes and story arcs that gripped me for a while—but as often as not, I found my mind wandering—counting ceiling tiles and such. When it finished, I felt somewhat satisfied, but the next day I had all but forgotten everything that had transpired onscreen. Summarily, you could say that Brideshead is a fairly average film—neither spectacular nor terrible, and should please fans of the book who aren’t expecting an exhaustive transliteration.
Having given myself a crash course in the novel (I love you, Wikipedia!), I think I can safely say that the movie plays up the novel’s homoerotic themes, and plays down its Catholic ones. This should surprise no one; this is the difference between the 1940s and the 2000s. The story concerns Charles Ryder, a working-class young man who attends Oxford in the 1930s, is romanced by an aristocratic student named Sebastian Flyte (Ben Whishaw), and becomes involved with his family, later on beginning an affair with his sister Julia (Hayley Atwell, Cassandra’s Dream). All the while he feels God pulling him away from his atheism and toward the Catholic faith—but, of course, we only glimpse that here.

It shouldn’t be a big surprise that the movie emphasizes the sex at the expense of the religion; there are very real limitations to the respective media of book and film. Books are made of words, and thus emphasize thought—philosophy, introspection; movies, on the other hand, are made of photographs, and by nature emphasize physicality and action. One character’s romance with God can be fascinating to read about, but is impossible to capture on film. Meanwhile, romantic moments on the human level—tender kisses, brushes of the cheek, longing glances—are intensified in power when recorded by a camera (this is true of many of the moments between Charles and Sebastian, and later between Charles and Julia).
That being said, Brideshead Revisited still does a decent job of communicating Charles’ stumbling progress toward theism. If you’ve been wondering why I gave the film a three-and-a-half-star rating despite my lack of enthusiasm, here’s the only reason: the cinematography. Under the camera of cinematographer Jess Hall (Hot Fuzz, Son of Rambow), every sequence in the film says more than what is on the surface. The icons that overrun Brideshead (the Catholic Flyte family’s estate) are equal parts menacing and inviting, and certain moments, like Julia’s dying father making the sign of the cross, are astonishing in their resonance. And try as I might, I can’t get the last sequence (which, for the sake of the “SPOILER ALERT!” crowd, I’ll avoid describing here) out of my head.
All that said, the choice is ultimately yours on this one. I wouldn’t know, but I’m going to hazard a guess that it’s far worse that BBC’s adaptation in terms of plot, character, and dialogue, but far better than it in terms of lighting, cinematography, and atmosphere (for some reason, Auntie Beeb seems unable to hire gaffers and cinematographers). If nothing else, it made me want to read the book—and in many ways, that’s the highest praise you can give a literary adaptation.

"Brideshead Revisited" currently playing at the Circle Cinema. Please call 592-FILM for showtimes and tickets.


About the author:

A graduate of the University of Nebraska, Luke Harrington currently resides in Tulsa and works in the aerospace industry–but, at any given moment, would probably rather be reviewing movies.  In his spare time, he’s off playing blues piano and pretending to be Assistant Editor for MovieZeal.com.

‘With Loving Care’ – Marc Nuttle’s ‘Moment of Truth’

While full of details that will lead to prayerful concern about the future of the world’s greatest nation, Marc Nuttle’s “Moment of Truth” (Front Line: 241 pages with references and index, $21.99) also overflows with assurance that individuals can make a difference, and that America’s best days might still lie ahead.

Reading about the economic and political signs of our times can be a despair-inducing experience. Yet this new book from Oklahoma’s most respected national political consultant and analyst brims with hope and radiates a rational confidence needed in challenging times.

In a clear manner, Nuttle catalogues how cultural trends are changing our way of life. He states in no uncertain terms what many are saying in homes, churches, and boardrooms across America. In these days, "many people feel a measure of uncertainty about our nation’s future."

No other recent author has delivered such a readable, focused and graceful overview of American problems, and with such an unrivaled, measured and purposeful methodology. Nuttle’s writing compares favorably to great rhetorical calls to arms from the past, including Ronald Reagan’s prescient 1964 speech for Barry Goldwater, and William Simon’s “A Time for Truth.”

Nuttle outlines stressful influences in state and nation, and the impact of world developments on individuals, communities and the American psyche. Whatever one’s personal political preferences, there is comfort in Nuttle’s analytical description of the crisis of confidence many citizens feel. He argues that our nation is at the culmination of a normal political and cultural progression, a “forty year cycle” from despair (the 1960s) to confidence (the 1980s). And no we have reached the prelude to – whatever comes next. His point is that we can choose what comes next.

This year’s election, he says, "will determine what this nation will be and who we will become as a people from this year forward." We hear that every election, but this year it’s all there: from bitter cultural and moral divisions and crushing burdens of regulatory law and taxes, to the shock of technological change and the horrid intrusiveness of government and media in daily living. Leavening the depressing details is Nuttle’s determination that, with thought and care, we can do better as individuals and as a nation.
Nuttle calls for personal introspection and communal deliberation about how our government has lost sight of the people’s best interests, explains what we need to do to get back on track, provides a framework for clarifying each reader’s personal “grid” for policy and politics, and outlines the need for a new assessment of national priorities. 
As the book’s jacket make clear, Nuttle is unrelenting in assailing the addiction of government to spending, and the tendency of power to corrupt and undermine American greatness. Yet he outlines how to retain government as an asset, not a ruler, to forge the necessary balance between liberty and law, and to discern the limits of good intentions.

Nuttle relates a few endearing stories about his friend Milton Friedman, the Nobel Prize-winning economist, who wrote "Nothing is inevitable about the course of history; however it may appear in retrospect. Because we live in a largely free society, we tend to forget how limited is the span of time and the part of the globe for which there has ever been anything like political freedom; the typical state of mankind is tyranny, servitude, and misery."

As Nuttle points out, Friedman went right to the heart of the great issues of our day. Freedom is a rare and precious jewel in human history, a treasure "to be protected at all costs and handed down to the next generation with loving care."

An experienced veteran of political warfare and international diplomacy, Nuttle has effectively dealt with the national news media for decades. While candidly documenting examples of liberal bias, Nuttle repeatedly demonstrates that many reporters are, like those they cover, seeking truth.

In one memorable exchange, a previously friendly journalist describes Nuttle as a liar. Naturally, this shreds their relationship. Yet Nuttle refused to close the door on reconciliation. Their eventual return to respect and friendship is not only a triumph for Nuttle, it is a fresh and contemporary revelation of the eternal power of forgiveness. Those active in politics and policy disputes will find endless sagacity in these pages.

Nuttle’s call for deep thought and discussion about our immediate political decisions are compelling as we prepare to vote in an election that could affect us and our children in ways we have only suspected, or feared, in the past. Nuttle is centered in the sunny tradition of Ronald Reagan. He is filled with happiness and hope, giving a plan of action to prevent circumvention of our freedoms, to counter increased abuses of power by privileged officials, and to bridge gaps that have polarized us as a society in areas such as religion, politics, and even the meaning of truth itself. 
 
Few Americans and even fewer Oklahomans have counseled political leaders in every corner of the world, and fewer still have distilled their experiences into as many golden nuggets of wisdom as Nuttle. His account of one experience in Asia gives the reader great food for thought in understanding the broad tides of history.

In conversation with a Chinese official, Nuttle is asked how he would define freedom. Citing the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution and an elaborating on the rule of law, Nuttle felt as if he had defended his country properly. However, the Chinese secretary replies with "That’s nice … but one of our definitions is ‘the right not to starve to death.’" The Chinese official also asked Nuttle how he thought democracy was doing, but as he tried to give a sophisticated answer, the fellow interrupted him and said "Marc, it’s a trick question. The correct answer is: It’s too soon to tell!"

Fair enough, but this encounter between a country with more than six thousand years of history to one with little more than two hundred lends perspective. Nuttle was defiant and admirable in defending the history of the world’s greatest experiment in self-government that has served the people. He is right that our democratic Republican is living proof that freedom works, and a model for future governments. Yet, we live in a world of contrary values.

Lest we forget, China is still very much under Communist political control. Even as it emerges with its own stunning economic growth and prepares to host the Olympics, China continues to threaten brave little Taiwan, and to punish internal dissenters with jail and even death for exercising basic and cherished freedoms such as free speech.
Nuttle explores the consequences of political choices made in the past that have led us toward a more European-style, socialist economy. He lays out a plan of action for recovery of liberty through reasoned defense of American traditions. Nuttle’s insight into growing trends toward those European models comes from his up front and personal experiences abroad. While he credits America’s city, county and state governments for having the "best of intentions," he points out that they are adopting policies that will ultimately lead to higher taxes and a reduction in cherished constitutional rights. Federal officials, he writes, are "allowing the nation to slip toward the European model of a centrally controlled economy at a frightening pace."

In the end, this book is interactive. Early on, Nuttle provides a series of questions that might help individual readers determine their own political and cultural philosophy. Late in the work, he outlines areas of policy concern, and describes 12 steps that help a reader fashion his or her own “moral imperative” for direct involvement in restoring national greatness. Via the worldwide web, Nuttle draws the reader into what will no doubt be continuing and broadening dialogue about personal purpose and national goals, providing a code inside the cover jacket that allows access to his web site.

Nuttle’s devotion to faith, family and a better America shine through in his descriptions of the type of leaders our country needs.

For those who have lost faith in government, those who feel the world has outgrown their vote, and for those who simply need a "how to" on how to get involved for positive change, this is a must read. (Click here for the Amazon listing.)

About the author: Pat McGuigan is an editor at The City Sentinel, a weekly newspaper in Oklahoma City. He is a regular contributor to Tulsa Today since 2002 and once served as our Capital Editor – a position we hope McGuigan will fill again some day soon. This essay first appeared in Perspective magazine, the monthly publication of the Oklahoma Council of Public Affairs.  pmcguigan@cox.net