Yearly Archives: 2008

Fisher appointment criticized

The appointment of former Senator Ted Fisher to the Council of Bond Oversight "is an alarming development for anyone who believes in government accountability," Rep. Mike Reynolds said Friday.

"To put it mildly, Senator Fisher has an extremely weak record when it comes to ensuring tax dollars are not wasted or funneled to questionable business transactions," said Reynolds, R-Oklahoma City.

"Thanks to former Senator Fisher’s actions, Oklahoma taxpayers were fleeced out of millions of dollars through a tax credit scheme."

During his time in the state Senate, Fisher (D-Sapulpa) authored the Small Business Capital Formation Incentive Act and the Rural Venture Capital Formation Incentive Act. Supporters claimed the two programs,which provided tax credits on money invested in certain projects, would spur economic development.

In reality, the two programs were massive tax loopholes that drained state coffers without generating new jobs, Reynolds noted.Under Fisher’s legislation, there was no requirement for a person to seek pre-approval of an investment plan to obtain the tax credits, Reynolds said.

Ultimately, individuals had the ability to borrow money to obtain tax credits whose value actually exceeded the initial loan, allowing recipients to pay off the loan and make a profit solely on the paper transaction.

Apparently, some "investors" never spent a dime on any actual projects, yet they still reaped massive financial rewards.

When lawmakers finally closed the Fisher loopholes, it was unclear how much the tax credits would ultimately cost the state, but officials suggested several hundred million dollars in credits had already been issued, according to news reports at the time.


About the Author:
Mike McCarville has covered Oklahoma politics and government since he became State Capitol Correspondent for The Tulsa Tribune in 1966. Since, he has been a governor’s press secretary, investigative reporter, television station news executive, radio station program director and talk show host, and political consultant. In 1980, he founded The McCarville Report and it is the nation’s longest-running state political publication. In its online version, it has been called "The best political blog" by Dr. Keith Gaddie, pollster and pundit and "Oklahoma’s venerable McCarville Report" by The Arkansas Times.  McCarville, also a real estate investor and commentator for the National Rifle Association on NRANews.com and Sirius Satellite Radio, is a regular contributor to Tulsa Today.  

Return to the Hulk-ing base

The Incredible Hulk
United States, 2008

Directed By: Louis Letterier
Written By: Zak Penn
Starring: Edward Norton, Liv Tyler, William Hurt, Tim Roth, Tim Blake Nelson, Lou Ferrigno
Running Time: 114 minutes
Rated PG-13 for sequences of intense action violence, some frightening sci-fi images, and brief suggestive content.
4 out of 5 stars

“It’s a monster! Run for your lives!”

Apart from being a quote from Frankenstein, those are also the words uttered by Marvel and company following the 2003 release of Ang Lee’s Hulk. Perhaps an obvious pairing on paper, the Asian auteur of angst took significant liberties with the property and rendered a film that was well written, superbly acted, ambitious, and…absolutely no fun. And in the comic book genre, ‘no fun’ is just another way of saying ‘franchise killer’. “Hulk Poodles!” became the bitter rallying cry of spurned fanboys the globe over.

So Avi Arad and the boys at Marvel (not content to let one of their most recognizable properties be remembered primarily for Nick Nolte shooting lightning bolts out of his eyes) turned to a director guaranteed never to make anything in his career that even remotely resembles Brokeback Mountain – Louis Letterier, the French action junkie responsible for the Transporter franchise and Unleashed. With a lot more SMASH and a lot less pathos, The Incredible Hulk is as obvious an apology for Hulk as The Last Crusade was for The Temple of Doom, which both helps and hurts it.

Ditching the standard origin-story that most comic book franchises kick off with (if nothing else, Ang Lee can be thanked for getting that out of the way), the film thrusts us straight into the action. Bruce Banner (Edward Norton replacing Eric Bana) is hiding out in the slums of South America, working at a soda bottling plant while he desperately searches for a cure to his condition. The U.S. military, however, has a hankering for that condition and the legions of super soldiers they could create with it. Headed by General Thaddeus Ross (William Hurt of Vantage Point) and special ops guru Emil Blonsky (Tim Roth, Youth Without Youth), it isn’t long before they’ve tracked Banner down and are chasing him over sheet metal rooftops and through congested alleys and streets.

This initial chase is an impressive cinematic feat, combining the best elements of Bourne and Bond. When little Brucey finally gets an inevitable case of the pissed-offs, Letterier chooses to mask the transformation in shadow, never giving us a clear look at the Hulk. Even though nearly every human being on the planet knows exactly what Mr. Green-and-Angry looks like, because Letterier treats his initial appearance more like Jaws and less like Godzilla, he stokes the audience’s anticipation for the Big Reveal (which doesn’t arrive until halfway through the film). It’s a subtle choice but an extremely effective one, garnering surprising mileage out the titular metamorphosis.

While Letterier crafts action set pieces that rank with the best of Spider-Man and Batman, directing actors is not his strong suit. Although the cast is top shelf, each and every one turns in an average performance (with the exception of Tim Blake Nelson, mucking it up as a Nobel-hungry scientist). William Hurt seems mildly grumpy most of the time, and Tim Roth, who is responsible for one of the nastiest on-screen villains of all time (Archibald Cunningham in Rob Roy), appears to be more constipated than ruthless.

Most disappointing of all, however, is the almost-chemistry between Norton and Liv Tyler, who plays Banner’s longtime love Elizabeth Ross. The Hulk has always been ripe for Shakespearean tragedy (you can see now why Ang Lee would have appealed), a tale of two lovers ripped apart by forces beyond their control, but Letterier and his Marvel handlers run screaming from anything that might remind viewers too much of the previous incarnation. In an attempt to distance themselves from the 2003 debacle, they’ve over-swung the pendulum in the opposite direction, and moments of genuine romantic tragedy are played for yucks. Both the script and actors are up to the task, but the just-barely-almost-there romantic spark never ignites between the two leads, a missed opportunity that other franchises have capitalized on.

Regardless of its missteps, The Incredible Hulk is a genuinely entertaining piece of comic book goodness. From the fanboy service (Lou Ferrigno’s cameo, the musical score that references the original TV series, and Hulk’s classic line of subtle dialogue, “HULK SMASH”) to the city crushing confrontation between the Hulk and his psoriasis-challenged nemesis Abomination, Marvel and co have effectively rebooted a series that seemed destined to sulk in the corners of Blockbuster’s bargain bin. It’s not a reinvention of the wheel (one painful lesson was enough), but it is smashing fun.


About the Author:
Evan Derrick loves movies, loves talking about movies, and even makes them from time to time. In the rare moment when movies aren’t consuming his grey matter, he enjoys eating grilled cheese sandwiches, playing with his baby daughter, and pretending to be the senior editor for MovieZeal.com. Use the Tulsa Today search feature to read previous reviews by this author.

McMahan resigns after conviction

Analysis:  Oklahoma Auditor and Inspector Jeff McMahan resigned today in disgrace after his conviction Saturday on federal crimes. 
"It is with sadness and regret that I resign my position as Oklahoma State Auditor and Inspector, effective immediately," read the one-sentence letter of resignation submitted to Governor Henry.  A federal grand jury in Muskogee convicted McMahan and his wife, Lori, of one count of conspiracy and two counts of accepting bribes.
The McMahans were convicted of illegally accepting excessive campaign money, jewelry and trips from southeastern Oklahoma businessman Steve Phipps. In return, the state auditor, with his wife’s help, provided favors for Phipps’ abstract companies.  Their actions could serve as textbook examples of political corruption.

Following Saturday’s verdict, jury foreman Michael Miracle delivered the most interesting comment on the case, telling reporters that after hearing nine days of testimony and arguments, he considered the state auditor "a small fish in a big pond with a lot of whales.”

"Granted, he’s an elected official and he should be held to a higher standard, but there’s a lot of other people that were involved,” Miracle said. "I just don’t think Mr. McMahan was one of the ringleaders.”

If a state elected official is not “one of the ringleaders,” then how corrupt is Oklahoma government?  How high – or low – does it go?  And when do the “whales” go to jails?

Tulsa Today was the first Oklahoma news organization to cover this scandal.  With respect to the The Oklahoman and, to a far lesser degree, The Tulsa World – the two largest daily newspapers in the state – we beat you guys like a drum, despite your staff of hundreds, revenues in the millions and national news affiliations.

After 13 hours of deliberations over two days, jurors in the McMahan case found the couple guilty on a conspiracy count and two counts of violating the Travel Act to promote bribery. The Travel Act counts involve trips the McMahans took at Phipps’ expense in 2003 and 2004.

Jurors acquitted the couple on five counts of mail fraud.

Congratulations to federal investigators and prosecutors, without whom Oklahomans would have no prayer of honest government as long as Oklahoma Democrats are protected by Attorney General Drew Edmondson.  (Lori McMahan admitted several misdeeds in court, but said they were either state crimes or state Ethics Commission violations.  Prosecutors said that seemed like a convenient excuse, since the statute of limitations for many of her admitted crimes has expired.)

Supported and illegally funded by the slimy likes of Gene Stipe, who served in the Legislature for 50 years, and his long-time partner, Steve Phipps, the Oklahoma Democratic Party makes more Republican victories as individual Oklahomans observe first-hand the corruption of Democratic powerbrokers who are promoted, protected and repeatedly proven evil throughout the state.

For years, Stipe operated as Little Dixie’s Robin Hood – stealing from taxpayers to fund further election of corrupt stooges and personal friends.  He spread the money around.  His admitted activities prove that any party that retains absolute control of the political process for over 100 years inevitably devolves into vile betrayal.

Governor Brad Henry, by law, will appoint a successor, but Henry (as well as U.S. Congressman Dan Boren) also received huge amounts of money from the same network of straw donors as Jeff McMahan.  Don’t expect nonpartisan decisions from that group; but if there is any justice in the world, the man cheated in two elections for the post, Republican Gary Jones, should be appointed.  Jones connected the dots six years ago on McMahan.  Tulsa Today contributer Mike McCarville mused on his McCarville Report Online, “How much better a watchdog of public funds could we find than a guy with that kind of nose for corruption?”

Tulsa Today first started paying close attention as the final numbers became public on McMahan’s first race.  In a story published June 30, 2006, Jones offered a detailed recap of McMahan’s final report of his 2002 campaign reporting. Jones said the report showed McMahan had total monetary receipts of $364,464.16 (line 10 form C1R) and had expenditures made of $289,880.02 (line 17 forms C1R).  Based upon those numbers, Jones said the fund balance should be $74,584.14 on line 25 of the report. Jones noted that the actual figure on McMahan’s report is $2,573.59 – a difference of over $70,000.  The $2,573.59 figure was carried forward and reported as the starting balance on McMahan’s 2006 campaign.

“I believe how a candidate manages their finances in a campaign and how they report them is very important. Jeff McMahan should immediately correct his math and acknowledge his poor bookkeeping to the Oklahoma Ethics Commission,” Jones said. (To read that posting, click here.)

In the next campaign for the same office by the same individuals – McMahan and Jones – things got a little strange in Tecumseh, McMahan’s hometown, when Gary Jones’ campaign trailer was stolen.  It was not a small theft and Jones announced a reward – and in January 2008, we discovered it was McMahan’s brother, Jason, who with a friend committed the crime. (To read that posting, click here.)

Steve Phipps first hit our investigative radar in a story on April 2, 2006, as we found links to a strange beneficiary of Oklahoma tax dollars by the name of the “Rural Development Foundation” that received some $2.5 million  for “pondering” development of a water system that would compete with the City of Tulsa’s water.  Tulsa Mayor Kathy Taylor facilitated the transfer of funds while serving as Governor Henry’s Secretary of Commerce. (To read that posting, click here.)

Today, House Speaker Chris Benge said McMahan did the right things by stepping down.  "I am pleased Mr. McMahan did the honorable thing for the people of Oklahoma and decided to step down today,” said Benge, R-Tulsa. “The House will now not have to have an expensive and redundant impeachment process that would have cost the taxpayers money."

Yes, it is indeed a wonderful thing to see the enemies of good government float face-down and out with the spring rain – but again, when are the rest of the whales going to jails?


About the Author:
{mosimage}David Arnett began his career in professional journalism in 1985 and has published Tulsa Today since 1996 – before Al Gore invented the Internet.  He has won two national awards as a First Amendment Publisher.  Arnett is a Constitutional Republican, Public Information Specialist and Conservative Media Critic. This analysis may be reproduced without charge with proper attribution and links back to the original source.  Arnett is available for interview by recognized media.

Kisha Makerney: A soldier you should know

Specialist Kisha Makerney is an inspiration and a surprise.  An unassuming woman with an amazing story of personal triumph against personal tragedy, Kisha’s life defines honor and courage.
Specialist Makerney was raised in the small southern town of Ft. Towson, Oklahoma to a large family full of life and laughter.  As a child, Kisha wanted to be in the Army and at age 17, the dream became a reality.
“My dad asked me what I wanted to do when I grew up. I told him I wanted to join the Army!  It was all I lived and breathed while I was growing up.”
“I was working at Sonic and I saw a recruiter so I told him I wanted to join.  Originally, my goal was to join the Army National Guard, go to college on the National Guard Tuition Assistance Program and become an officer.  I then planned to join the [Active Duty] Army.”

 

Over the past few years, Kisha’s plans have changed slightly.  She still plans to finish college and go full-time Army.  Only now, she plans to lead from the front.  “Now I want a career in the regular Army as a Non-Commissioned Officer (NCO).”

“No One Is More Professional Than I” – The NCO Creed

This isn’t Kisha’s first time to Iraq.  She was here from February 2004 to March 2005 with the 120th Engineers out of Oklahoma.

Now she finds herself back in Baghdad.  This time she is serving as an instructor for the Iraqi Correctional Officer Academy.  She trains Iraqi citizens to become correctional officers in order to, one day, assume control of the detainee operations from the Americans.

“I help train the NCO course.  We teach them basic leadership principles and effective styles of leadership.  We train them to the same standard American soldiers are trained to.”  She continues, “They learn about human rights, effective communication skills and how to make sound decisions.  We teach them to lead the other Iraqi Correctional Officers.”  She adds, “I’m also a Combatives Instructor (the Army standard for hand-to-hand combat).”

Kisha notes the conditions here in Iraq have changed significantly since she was last here. “Last time [I was here] you never knew what was going to happen.  Compared to [what it was like] then, things are much better.” She adds, “I wish people back home knew that.”

Kisha is serving here at Camp Cropper with her younger brother, Tommy.  She also has a cousin, Keith, serving in southern Iraq at Camp Bucca.  A huge smile spreads across her face as she talks about her family, and rightly so.  They’ve all been through a lot together.

“I Love them and miss them.” She confides, “They believed in me and gave me tough love when I needed it. They helped make me who I am.”

I asked Kisha’s brother, Tommy, about his sister.  “She’s brave and she’s tough.” he said.  “She volunteered for this mission… I don’t think I could do the things she does.”

Things Changed Back Home …

Kisha returned from her first deployment and resumed the pursuit of her goals.  However, June 24th 2005 at 5:00 PM, things changed…

“I was going about 60 miles-per-hour on my motorcycle when the front tire blew out.”

At that speed there wasn’t much she could do.  She fought to maintain control but the motorcycle swerved and veered.  In a split-second she found herself hurled between two road signs.  The reinforced motorcycle jacket she wore absorbed the impact as her shoulder collided into the sign.  Her left leg struck the same sign and was instantly severed below the knee.  Her momentum continued her airborne travel off the road and down into a ditch as the motorcycle was hurtled further forward into heavily wooded foliage.  When everything slowed to a stop, Kisha found herself bruised and battered with a severed leg.  She was down in a ditch, completely obscured from the road.  No one would see her.  No one would hear her.  It was just her, her will to live, and the Hand of God.

Kisha found her inner strength and “Low-Crawled” out of the ditch and back towards the road.  Along the way she found her cell phone and paused to try and make a call – it was broken.  She continued to crawl to the roadside where she applied immediate first aid and treated herself for shock.  In the midst of this traumatic moment, she managed to wave down a passing car.

Fort Towson is a small town and word travels quickly.  Instantly, word had spread, and her family was notified.  Within minutes, they were by Kisha’s side at the accident scene waiting for ambulance to arrive.

The ambulance took Kisha to a nearby hospital where she was then Air evac’d to Dallas.  She went through extensive surgery, however, her leg could not be saved.

When she awoke from surgery, she found she was not alone.  Her family, close friends and comrades from the 120th Combat Engineers had dropped everything and made the 5-hour drive to the Dallas hospital to be by her side.

I Can Do All Things…

After the accident, Kisha was faced with a difficult road to recovery.  Additional surgeries, physical therapy coupled with the pain and emotional trauma associated with the loss of her leg.  She would have to adapt and, in time, learn how to walk again.  To add to her daunting task, Kisha added another obstacle—she wanted to remain in the Army.  She refused to let this event prevent her from achieving her dream.

“Physically, it was very hard but everybody was great!  They all believed in me.  Nobody ever doubted me.”  She explains, “I had to perform my job and meet Army Standards.”  She adds, “My battle buddies from the 120th Engineers were the best and my battle buddies from the 45th ROC are awesome!”

“If I could tell anybody anything, I want people to know that if they really believe, they can do anything they want to.”

She confides, “It’s all about God.  I would not be here without Him.  Without Him I would have given up back when I was laying in the hospital bed.”  She beams with enlightenment. “It really is all about Him.”

As we concluded our interview I found myself wrapped in amazement and wonder at her incredible testimony.  Surely if there was ever a living example of what “inspiration” means, Kisha is it.  Her life is a testimony to the passage of scripture found in Philippians 4:13 which says: “I can do all things through Christ who strengthens me.”

Yes, Kisha.  You Can.

 


About the Author:
SFC Erik Wolf reports from Camp Cropper, Iraq for Tulsa Today and on this story also served as photographer.

Father’s Day memory

Sunday, 15 June 2008
After 40 years working in the Post Office, my father, the world’s sweetest, kindest and most unassuming man, retired and moved to Florida with my mother and my grandmother.  They bought an apartment at Century Village in West Palm Beach.  It was Red Buttons’ favorite place.  That’s what it said on the billboard.  If it was good enough for Red it was good enough for them.  And, off they went.

Even though he had a comfortable pension from the Post Office, my dad took a job down there working at the jai-lai fronton.  His job was to write in the winning numbers and what they payed after each game.  He’d write them in chalk on a big blackboard up on the second floor.

It wasn’t much of a “skill” job, he would say, laughing.  But, it got him out of the house at night.  And, my dad was always happiest being part of a group of people.  An affable, easy-going man, everyone always enjoyed his company.

Diana and I came down on a visit one time.  And, after checking in with mom and grandma we went over to jai-lai to surprise Dad.  When I went to buy admission tickets the guy at the counter seemed to recognize me.

“You’re George Goldberg’s boy, aren’t you?”

“Yeah.  Gary.”

“The writer?”

“I guess.”

“I’m Lenny.”

We shook hands and as I reached into my pocket for my wallet Lenny put a hand up to stop me.

“George’s son can’t pay.”

I tried to explain that it was OK.  I didn’t mind paying.  And, I didn’t want him to get in any trouble.

Lenny looked at me like English might not be my first language.  “George’s son can’t pay,” he repeated, then punched out two tickets and waved us in.

“Thanks.”

We walked a few feet and then Lenny called out after us, “Your father’s a great guy.”

I turned back to Lenny, “You don’t have to tell me.”

Diana and I made our way upstairs, weaving carefully through a noisy, colorfully clad crowd of people.  When we came around the corner we saw my dad.  He was up on a stool, his back to us, chalk in one hand, cigarette in another.  He had already been diagnosed with the lung cancer that would eventually kill him.  And, as far as we all knew he had given up smoking about six months ago.

He was kibitzing with a couple of guys.  And, even from the back I could tell he was smiling.  He hopped down from the stool and when he saw us he broke into a big grin.

As he came towards us he must have suddenly realized he was still holding the cigarette, because he cupped it in his big hand and put it behind his back.  He looked like a kid caught smoking in the high school bathroom.

We hugged and kissed.  A special hug for Diana who he adored.  We stood there for a few seconds as the smoke began to billow up now from his elbow.

“Pop,” I said, trying to locate him through the haze of smoke.  He looked down at the cigarette in his hand as if surprised to find it there.  Smiled, sheepishly, “Two a night, that’s all.”

I went off to get some coffee for us as Dad and Diana went to find a place to sit.

At the snack bar I ordered coffee from an overweight, older woman, Estelle.  As I reached for my wallet.  Estelle put her hand out to stop me. “George’s son can’t pay.”

I explained that I didn’t mind.  I didn’t want her to get in any trouble.  She fixed me with a stern look.

“George’s son can’t pay.”

Back at the apartment later that night Dad and I were seated together in the screened-in porch area, known, not surprisingly, in that part of the world, as the Florida room.  My father was worried about money.  His and mine.

“I’m making too much money now, he told me.”

“How do you figure that, Pop?”

He explained that with the cost of living allowance that was built into his pension, he kept getting an increase every year.  And, he didn’t think he deserved it.

“How much is it up to now?”

“Thirteen hundred dollars a month.”

“Just enjoy it.”

“I can’t.  I’m worried about young families starting out.  How are they going to buy homes?  Get what they need.  If old guys like me are taking so much out of the system.”

I tried to explain that I didn’t think his thirteen hundred a month was causing the Federal Reserve to tighten interest rates.  But, I could see it was really bothering him.

“Who takes care of your money?” he then asked.  “Because, there’s a guy lives across the courtyard from me,” he explained, “Arthur.  Very wealthy man.  Knows a lot about business.  I think you should talk to him.”

My father had paid $14,000 for his apartment.  I assumed Arthur, who lived in an identical unit, had paid about the same.  The year before, when Family Ties sold into syndication, I was handed a check slightly larger than the Gross National Product of Ecuador.  But, my father could never quite grasp what had happened.  And for him, Arthur, who had been in plumbing supplies, and probably maxed out at 45 thousand, was a “very wealthy man.”

“He knows a lot about business.  Talk to him.  I’m worried about you.”

Arthur couldn’t have been sweeter or more thoughtful.  He served coffee and cookies and gave me a brief overview of his investment philosophy.  Put it in the bank.  Take the interest. Sleep good at night.  Series E Bonds.  Christmas club.  Stuff you can count on.  I thanked him for his time.  And, went back downstairs.  My dad was there.

“You saw Arthur?”

“I did.  Smart guy.  And, very nice.”

My father looked over towards Arthur’s apartment.  Spoke quietly, “Very wealthy man.”

“I know, Dad.”

“I feel better.”

“Me, too.”

About the Author:
Gary David Goldberg is the founder of UBU Productions which produced nine television series including “Family Ties” and “Brooklyn Bridge.” He is the author of the upcoming book, Sit, Ubu, Sit: How I went from Brooklyn to Hollywood with the same woman, the same dog, and a lot less hair (Harmony 2008). Visit him online at www.GaryDavidGoldberg.com/.

Last Updated ( Sunday, 15 June 2008 )