Yearly Archives: 2008

The day the school-choice debate changed

In the current session of the state Legislature, Sen. James Williamson, a Tulsa Republican, is sponsoring a proposal called the New Hope Scholarship Act. The measure provides a tax credit for taxpayers who contribute to organizations that provide private-school scholarships for low-income children attending failing (the technical term is "needs improvement") schools in the state’s two largest cities. The fiscal impact of the tax credit would be $5 million, with a practical doubling effect (to $10 million) for students who would benefit.

In a March 13 state Senate debate on the bill, Sen. Jeff Rabon, the "Little Dixie" Democrat, said he would oppose the bill because "it strikes me as giving up." Sen. Jay Paul Gumm, a Durant Democrat, said he could not support Williamson’s proposal because of the "sacred mission" of public schools to educate every child. Gumm asserted support for the bill would "send up the white flag to abandon many for the benefit of a few."

Sen. Kenneth Corn, a Poteau Democrat, said, "I am concerned like Senator Gumm … that while we allow some children to escape the problems of a failed school-if that is in fact what we want to call it-the children who have parents [who] are motivated, who want to see their child succeed, those children will get out. But what about those children who don’t have parents who want to get up and make sure they go to a better school?" Sen. Connie Johnson, one of only two urban Democrats to speak against the measure, asked, "Why is it that we want to take some of the kids out of the public schools and essentially leave the rest on the sinking ship?"
The latter observation compels offering a counter-from a Democrat. A former correspondent for The Economist, Charles Wheelan, author of Naked Economics, wrote in an essay for OCPA a few years back: "If students-especially the ‘best’ students-will flock from public schools like rats from a sinking ship, then what makes this system so worth protecting?" That’s Wheelan’s question, not mine.
Right after Johnson’s comments, Judy Eason-McIntyre rose. In this debate, things will never be the same, at least in Oklahoma. She told colleagues, "This is not a difficult decision for me to make. This does not mean that I’m anti-public education. No one, no one has been more of a supporter for public education than I have. I have been a supporter of public education all my life."
A veteran of 16 years on the Tulsa public schools’ board of education, McIntyre said she had worked to get someone to "do something about these same schools that have gone on for years and years and years and nobody cared. Now, my critics are telling me that I’m trying to destroy public education! No, I’m not trying to destroy public education, I’m trying to get us to do what we need to do that nobody in a position of power has even said anything about."
Sometimes the obvious is a powerful argument, so McIntyre stated the obvious: "I know politics brings about strange bedfellows, but I’m not ashamed to be in bed on this idea. Because somebody … is finally trying to help do something different. Are they going to get something out of the deal? Yeah, that’s what politics is all about. … So these people who are willing to give some money to get a tax credit, if it means educating a kid then I’m for it because I’m tired of waiting."
Then, she got stronger: "This is the time for me, despite an election year. I believe in this strongly enough that if I don’t come back I am still going to continue to fight for this because we are better than this." She explained, "In front of our title it says ‘state.’ Mine doesn’t say ‘North Tulsa’ or ‘Osage County’ Senator, it doesn’t say ‘African-American,’ it says ‘state Senator.’ So, while we are concerned about those things in our district, as we should be, we’re also concerned about every child in the state of Oklahoma."
McIntyre wrapped up by saying to "fellow Democrats" that if "you’re interested in children, if you believe that every child should be educated," then you should support the New Hope scholarships. Then, she sat down. It was one of those relatively rare moments in politics, when a speech really does make a difference.
Sen. Tom Adelson, another Tulsa Democrat who had already said he would back the bill, told colleagues who were assailing Williamson’s bill: "All this lofty and empty rhetoric on my [Democratic] side, I’m embarrassed, because if we’re going to criticize we better have something ourselves." The closing back and forth of the discussion included a comment by Sen. Johnnie Crutchfield, a choice foe, who told Eason-McIntyre she’d just delivered "probably the best speech I’ve ever heard you give."
Democratic state Senator Earl Garrison, describing himself as "an old man from the country," said he wasn’t sure he could "add anything to this," but begged colleagues to support the bill. "If you’ve got a better way to do this, let’s do it. Let’s just don’t keep on playing politics with kids’ lives."
Republican state Sen. Kathleen Wilcoxson, Williamson’s close ally on education issues, asked both sides of the aisle to remember the Senate is "the deliberative body." So, she deliberated: for 25 years, the Oklahoma Legislature has put $20 to $25 million a year into special programs aimed at educating poor kids in the state’s two big cities. (Do the math.) She argued that $5 million for an experimental scholarship program was not too much to ask.
Williamson closed the debate, and thanked Eason-McIntyre "for taking a courageous stand … that could very well get her beat in the next election. But her kids are more important to her than being in the state Senate. That is unbelievable for a politician to be so concerned … willing to risk the ire of the public educators over in Tulsa."
All over America, as Williamson pointed out, black Democrats are leading the fight on the school choice issue.
After remaining a study in restraint throughout the debate, Williamson got a bit emotional. He reflected on a New Testament story about Jesus, healing the man with a withered hand on the Sabbath Day, and then encountering criticism for the cure’s timing. As the Nazarene said, "The Sabbath was made for man, and not man for the Sabbath" (Mark 2:27, King James Version). Williamson argued, "Children weren’t made for the public schools; public schools were made for the children."
In every minute of debate, the inability of choice foes to argue real issues was manifest. The intellectual argument was over, even if the political debate will rage on and on.
The proposal passed, 30-18, as the dam broke. In the final roll call, one supporter was state Sen. Andrew Rice, a Democrat who represents the midtown Oklahoma City area where I live and work. Democrats Rice, Adelson, and Garrison were joined by Nancy Riley and Randy Bass, and by every Republican, in support of Eason-McIntyre’s position.
And all they are saying, is give choice a chance. The standard tactic, for decades, has been to accuse school-choice supporters of being closet racists, or haters of public education, or similar nonsense. In Oklahoma, school-choice opponents can no longer preempt argumentation and reasoning.
In Williamson, they faced the son of a public school teacher who was himself a public school teacher. In Eason-McIntyre, they faced a woman with 16 years tenure on a big city school board. In Adelson, they faced an unashamed liberal-who said he was ashamed of his party’s tactics in opposing choice. In Rice, they faced a man on a journey.
I’ve observed battles over school choice my entire life. I have always supported expanded options for children, parents, teachers, taxpayers, and donors. That’s my bias. Wisdom taught me, long ago, not to make confident declarations of inevitable victory for education reforms. In the near term, that’s probably still wise. 
 
But I’ll venture this modest bit of punditry: On March 13, 2008, the Oklahoma debate over school choice changed, forever. Defenders of the status quo will counterattack. They may even kill the Williamson-McIntyre bill (SB 2093) for this year, perhaps even by the time this essay is in print. We’ll see.
A gentle song from my youthful years keeps going through my head. Paraphrased, it goes like this: It’s been too long a-waiting. In the end, I know a change is gonna come. Oh, yes it will.


About the Author:
Patrick McGuigan (M.A. in history, Oklahoma State University) is an editor at The City Sentinel, a weekly newspaper in Oklahoma City. He is the author of two books and the editor of seven, including “Law, Economics & Civil Justice: A Reform Agenda” (1994) and “Crime & Punishment in Modern America” (1986). He is a regular contributor to Tulsa Today and a research fellow at OCPA.  A state-certified teacher, for two years he taught middle-school and high-school students at a public charter alternative school.

This editorial was first published April 4, 2008, Perspective Magazine (Oklahoma Council of Public Affairs).

Tulsa Entrepreneurial Spirit Award

Kicking off for only the second year, the Tulsa Entrepreneurial Spirit Award competition was opened on March 2, 2008.  Begun by Mayor Kathy Taylor and sponsored by SpiritBank to showcase the entrepreneurial fervor alive and well in the Tulsa area, last year’s winner, SeekingSitters, has gone on to nationwide fame by being named one of the “Best Women-Owned Companies” in the U.S. for 2008 by Working Mother Magazine.

If you’re the owner or developer of a business which is less than five-years old and/or with equity capital of less than $1 million, then you ought to think about jumping into the competition.  With the first place prize a grant worth $25,000, which can be used in whatever way you wish, this is a great way to get exposure, grow your business and improve the economy in the City of Tulsa.  And the $5,000 for 2nd place or $2,500 for 3rd place are not shabby grants either.

You don’t have to be currently “successful” in your business today.  Struggling but viable businesses which have the potential for significant growth are also encouraged to participate.  What the judges are looking for are businesses that will contribute to the Tulsa economy through the creation of quality jobs and an increase the City of Tulsa tax base. 

So how do you get involved in the process?  First, obtain the application at http://www.tulsaspiritaward.com/.   Once that is submitted, begin preparing or updating your Business Plan Executive Summary which must be provided for judging by May 14, 2008.  On June 4, judging will be completed and the top 25 businesses will be notified.  Those competitors will then prepare a full business plan to be submitted by June 25, 2008, and develop a formal 7-minute presentation for review on July 9 and 10.

That July review will narrow the field down to 12 semi-finalists who will be assigned business coaches to help them refine their plans for submission on August 20 and a formal 5-minute pitch on September 3.  Seven finalists will be chosen to hone their plans and presentations for another 2-minute formal appearance before the judging panel on November 5.  The judges will then determine the winning plan and make the award at the Tulsa Air and Space Museum on November 18, 2008.  The top award will go to the team that shows it can execute its plan, has a realistic financial plan and projections, exhibits a strong marketing and public relations strategy, and identifies a viable market in which the product or service can grow and expand.

But perhaps the best part of this competition is the chance to develop your business plan with the help of the 30 professional coaches.  Particularly if you are an entrepreneur with a good idea, but are just not too sure how to grow, this program offers a view of other businesses and how they have developed.   Many resources are made available by several local companies and business leaders.  To start you out, you may want to attend the Business Plan and Entrepreneurial Resources meeting at the Central Park Community Center, 1028 E. 6th Street, on April 17, 2008, from 5:00pm – 7:00pm.  No fee or registration is required.  Go for it!


About the Author:
Karen is the owner of The KanDo™ Organization with her husband, W. David O’Brien, an Enrolled Agent tax accountant.  KanDo™ Virtual Administrative Services specializes in legal assistance, focusing on transcription and writing.  A third leg of the business is a mobile notary service.  Call 918-798-8908 for more information. 

Powerfully compelling film

4 Months, 3 Weeks, and 2 Days
Romania, 2007
Directed By: Cristian Mungiu
Written By: Cristian Mungiu
Starring: Anamaria Marinca, Laura Vasiliu, Vlad Ivanov, Alexandru Potocean
Running Time: 113 minutes
Not Rated
4.5 out of 5 stars

Raw and unflinching are the words that best describe 4 Months, 3 Weeks, and 2 Days, the title of which refers to how far along one of the characters is in her pregnancy when she undergoes an illegal abortion in late ‘80s Romania. I couldn’t take my eyes off of the screen except for one, brief moment (and then only because I couldn’t bear to watch). Director Cristian Mungiu pulls you into this world with an iron grip and refuses to let go. It is a work of extraordinary power and compassion and is important in the way so many films attempt to be and yet so few films really are.

Mungiu has stripped everything – the cinematography, the writing, the acting – of any sort of embellishment. There is no soundtrack. There are no fancy camera moves. The Romanian landscape is drained of color, an empty, inhospitable place. There is no beauty and little joy. The only laughter in the film, near the end, is hollow and forced, a paltry substitute for true humor. The walls of the college dorm the film begins in are whitewashed concrete, the floors dirty and devoid of carpet. Much like East Germany in The Lives of Others, Romania is a prison for the film’s characters; there are no walls or bars, but it nevertheless feels like a 10×10 windowless concrete cell.

Anamaria Marinca and Laura Vasiliu give moving, understated performances as Otilia and Gabita, college roommates in Bucharest. Although Gabita is the one who is pregnant, the story really belongs to Otilia, and the camera follows her as she makes preparations for her roommate’s procedure. The film takes place in a single day, and Mungiu uses long, extended shots to bring you into an uncomfortable intimacy with the girls. You are not allowed to be some distant voyeur, contemplating their troubles from afar, but forced to become a close participant in their lives. You have to be with them rather than to simply watch. Suffice to say, this is not a film that engenders complacency.

In communist Romania, everyone is a part of the black market, and securing something as simple as a hotel room requires bribery. Economic restrictions make bartering a normal part of relationships. You can’t survive without a quick tongue and a shrewd sense of business. Otilia needs Kent cigarettes (Marlboros won’t cut it) in order to bribe the hotel clerk, but her dormmate won’t part with them because he needs to grease the wheels of other transaction himself. She also needs money from her boyfriend (he needs her to pick up flowers for his mother’s birthday party), and although the haggling is softened by the romantic nature of their relationship, it’s a negotiation nonetheless. And, in one of the film’s most painful moments, this bartering (that has become part of the fabric of Romanian life) has unforeseen and wrenching consequences when the girls realize that money alone isn’t enough to cover the abortion.

The film’s blistering power is owed almost entirely to the fact that it avoids politicizing one of the most hot-button issues in the world today (especially in America). I would not be willing to wager money on writer-director Mungiu’s pro-choice or pro-life leanings. He is simply observing (not passively, however) a situation many women find themselves in – alone, pregnant, and forced to make life-altering decisions within the inexperience of youth. The reasons for the abortion are not even given, although the difficulty of the choice and the ramifications of their actions are made apparent.

In the interest of full disclosure, let me tell you that I’m staunchly pro-life. I have an 18-month daughter who is so full of energy and life that it takes my breath away, and my wife is pregnant with our second child, a boy. I cannot fathom ever considering whether or not to terminate their lives. It would be easy for me to pass judgment on Otilia and Gabita, to call them murderers or child killers or selfish cowards. But I’m also blessed with a loving spouse, a roof over my head, and a steady source of income, three things that neither of these girls have. I’ve made some piss poor decisions in my life and there, but for the grace of God, go I. Do I think they made the right decision? No, of course I don’t, but it would be utter folly for me to judge them. Truly, it’s a testament to the film’s stunning force that I keep referring to Otilia and Gabita as real human beings

Are you a pro-choice advocate? Then you must see 4 Months, for it refuses to idealize abortion. Here it is in all of its bloody, messy, tragic horror, dumped unceremoniously on the floor of a dirty bathroom in a ragged heap. At one point I had to look away; what was on screen was just too horrible to keep watching. If you’re going to fight for a woman’s right to choose, you need to see what that choice looks like.

And if you’re a pro-life advocate, then you are equally obligated to see this film. Young, terrified women find themselves in this situation on a daily basis in our country. It’s easy and painless to sit back and judge from your golden pedestal, condemning the “baby killers” while you lounge in your pews. Here are real people in real trouble with real pain in their lives. It’s not so easy to condemn another when you’re forced to walk in their shoes.

After the film, I took my baby girl to play at a nearby park. As I watched her go down the slide and pick flowers to give to me and laugh as a dog licked her face, images from 4 Months, 3 Weeks, and 2 Days kept flashing before my eyes. How easy it would be for me to go about my life, thankful that I never had to make the kind of decision that Otilia and Gabita did, and write off the thousands of girls and women caught in their plight with a flick of my religious wrist.

I guess the question is, will I?

4 Months, 3 Weeks, and 2 Days is currently playing at the Circle Cinema


About the Author:
Evan Derrick loves movies, loves talking about movies, and even makes them from time to time. In the rare moment when movies aren’t consuming his grey matter, he enjoys eating grilled cheese sandwiches, playing with his baby daughter, and pretending to be the senior editor for MovieZeal.com.

Free campaign training offered

Tuesday, 08 April 2008
American Majority, a national non-partisan, candidate training organization, will hold a training seminar Friday, April 11 in Tulsa for Oklahomans interested in learning more about how to organize and a execute a successful campaign plan.

The free seminar, held at the Courtyard Marriott at 3340 S 79th St E (west of Memorial and south of E 31st St South and I-44), will teach candidates how to develop a victorious operational plan, fund a successful campaign and organize grassroots support.  The American Majority forum also will feature campaign and public policy experts from across Oklahoma and the nation.

“We are excited to work with Oklahomans interested in learning how to plan and implement a successful campaign,” American Majority spokesman Seth Brown said.  

“We are dedicated to providing the necessary education and resources to help fellow Oklahomans committed to advancing free-market ideals, personal freedom and liberty across our state,” Brown said.

What:  Candidate Training Seminar, with continental breakfast and lunch provided

When:  Friday, April 11; Registration begins at 8:30 a.m. and the seminar ends at 5:15 p.m.

Where:  Courtyard by Marriott, 3340 S 79th St East in Tulsa
                  (West of Memorial and south of E 31st St South and I-44)

Upon completion of the training seminar, participants will receive continuing education materials, the lectures, communications curriculum and suggestions to help them utilize think-tank resources.

To RSVP or learn more information about the training seminar, call Seth Brown at (405) 639-8896 or e-mail him at seth@americanmajority.org.

American Majority Inc. is a non-profit and non-partisan organization formed to lead the battle in training, educating, and equipping the next generation of liberty-minded candidates, activists and community leaders.   Log on to the web site by clicking here  http://www.americanmajority.org/  to learn more.

Last Updated ( Tuesday, 08 April 2008 )

Tulsa selected for dropout summit

Friday, 04 April 2008
The national America’s Promise Alliance founded by Colin and Alma Powell has chosen Tulsa as a location for a dropout prevention leadership summit. The Alliance has pledged $10,000 in funding for the summit to be held within the next two years.

"Tulsa’s drop-out rates are unacceptable and it is time we addressed the issue head-on," Mayor Kathy Taylor said. "This summit is another way to help better serve these kids."

America’s Promise Alliance ranks Tulsa as having the 12th highest graduation disparity in the country between urban and suburban school districts. The America’s Promise summit will bring together city and community leaders to aggressively address the issue of dropout prevention and recovery. At the summit, leaders will map out an action plan directed at reducing the dropout rate.

Mayor Taylor has emphasized education as a top priority. In May 2007, she hosted a Call to Action summit with Union Public Schools Superintendent Cathy Burden focusing on preschool education, community schools and workforce readiness. Those in attendance included higher education administrators, area school superintendents, members of the Oklahoma Boards of Regents and school board members, as well as leaders in workforce development and alternative education.

In January 2007, Mayor Taylor began her Mentoring to the Max program following the September 2006 Building a Safer Tulsa Summit to Address Gang Violence. Through a donation from Bank of America, free after-school programs have been established at 18 elementary schools in the Tulsa and Union districts. These schools include Addams, Alcott, Bryant, Celia Clinton, Cooper, Eugene Field, Hawthorne, Kendall-Whittier, Mark Twain, Marshall, McClure, McKinley, Boevers, Briarglen, Clark, Grove, McAuliffe, and Rosa Parks.

Mayor Taylor also participated with Tulsa Regents for Higher Education and Tulsa Community College in development of the Tulsa Achieves program. This program provides funding for Tulsa County high-school graduates who meet certain requirements to attend Tulsa Community College tuition-free for two years. This has increased enrollment significantly at TCC beginning with the current 2007-2008 school year.

Since 1997, the America’s Promise Alliance has grown to become the nation’s largest multi-sector alliance focused on the well-being of young people. Today the Alliance encompasses more than 105 partner organizations representing the business community, nonprofits, communities and policymakers.

Last Updated ( Friday, 04 April 2008 )