Yearly Archives: 2008

Dirtbag Music launches social music network

The current music industry stalemate between content providers who control Digital Rights Management (DRM) and those who are call for an open file sharing universe has done little in terms of moving the music industry forward for the artists and fans caught in the middle.  Music used to be about the interaction and connection between artists and fans.
Dirtbag Music expects to change that convoluted tune. 

Represented by Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati, the same Silicon Valley law firm behind giants Google, YouTube and Apple, Dirtbag Music has launched a first-to-market social music network that provides the music industry with a radical new platform to aide musicians and fans.  Dirtbag Music provides free world wide video and voice calls for every user, a complete e-commerce engine to monetize online digital content and advance mobile applications that ensure artists and fans can stay connected.

The site’s peer-to-peer world-wide Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP) functionality utilizes an advanced multimedia instant messenger system, termed “Blab Box” creating real-time social interaction between users.
“Dirtbag Music provides everyone the ability to interact in real-time,” said CEO, John Alves, “bands and fans can now interact in real time through video sessions, personalized lessons, chats, concerts, interviews, rehearsals, tour bus updates and other reality based campaigns.  Having the ability to directly interact with your favorite artists or by attending a backstage meet and greet, in real-time, becomes a revolutionary new way of personalizing a user’s musical experience.
When fully implemented in late spring of 2008, the site will also provide individualized e-commerce platforms, like eBay, which allows each member to choose which products or features they want to monetize. For example, a band can choose to sell music tracks, merchandise, video chats, lessons, ringtones or whatever else the bands can invent and market.
“Real-time interaction is not something that can be duplicated or shared and therefore does not fall victim to the same DRM issues associated with downloading and sharing music tracks,” explains Mark Evans, Senior Vice President of Business Development, “it is a single one-off experience between the artist and the fan and one that radically changes how the music industry operates.”
That is just the tip of the iceberg for the new start-up.  Dirtbag Music’s proprietary mobile application enables real-time interaction right down to a users’ mobile cell phone.  
“Providing a single sign-on portal that is device independent and can be accessed through the user’s current home computer, laptop, cell phone or smart phone while providing direct access to your network of friends and artists is a core function of Dirtbag Music,” said Managing Director of Dirtbag Communications, Patrick Hauwert, “artists now have the ability to control, grow and monetize their fan base in ways never before possible.” With over 474 new proprietary features being rolled out in the next year, Dirtbag Music seeks to move the music industry forward by elevating interaction between artists and fans.
Dirtbag Music’s new platform is gaining industry support. With advisory board members as diverse as VH1 host and founding guitarist for Anthrax, Scott Ian, Hip-Hop artist DJ Skribble and Guns N’ Roses guitarist Ron Thal, Dirtbag Music is not just a social network site catering to one genre of music.
With support from music partners DW Drums, Basson Sound, ESP guitars, Schecter guitars, Dunlop, Boogie Street Guitars and Kahler music, the new start-up has even opened its platform to music manufacturers who will be demonstrating the company’s new technology during the National Association of Music Merchants’ (NAMM) annual convention starting January 17th in Anaheim, California.

To reach the site, click here www.dirtbagmusic.com – sign-up for free.

Dirtbag Music is a privately held company and a spin-off of The Dirtbag Clothing Company, an 11 year old lifestyle apparel company boasting over 400 artist endorsements and sponsorships from today’s top rock, pop and country artists. Dirtbag Music is headquartered in San Diego, California.

Leading lawyers say litigators need common sense public relations

After many years of watching the development of modern litigation and the law, I have become convinced that a wise public relations strategy is essential to the work of lawyers. Long ago, as a young observer of the law, I was not absolutely convinced of this. So, I’ve reflected inwardly of late that my new view might flow from age and a touch of cynicism. To test my hypothesis, I tracked down a few of the nation’s best-known lawyers, and several respected legal minds in Oklahoma.

Robert Henry, former state attorney general and now chief judge for the 10th U.S. circuit court of appeals, said, “Thurgood Marshall and Roscoe Dungee (an Oklahoma civil rights leader) certainly thought public relations was important to successful litigation.”

Carter G. Phillips, managing partner with Sidley & Austin in the nation’s capital, commented, “The reality is that there is some press or media angle in virtually all of my argued cases and in a good many others, and it is important to make sure the client appreciates the spotlight that a Supreme Court case can create.”

Another deft comment came from Jamie Gorelick, “I have long believed that public communications needs to be a part of most, though not all, representations. I  represent public figures and major companies who have many constituencies. Communicating on the merits of their positions, consistent with the rules and constraints of litigation, is crucial to their ability to function in their jobs and for their institutions — and it has important ramifications for the litigation itself.” Gorelick, who worked in the Clinton administration and later on the 9/11 Commission, is a partner at Wilmer Hale in D.C..

To connect with my philosophical moorings, I called former Attorney General Edwin Meese III. If anything, he was even more direct than the litigators, saying, “I’ve often said that in strategic litigation the court of public opinion is almost as important as the court of law. It’s critical to align your litigation strategy and your public relations strategy to assure success.” Now at the Heritage Foundation, Meese is an icon to fellow conservatives.

Perhaps the most pragmatic comment on the issue came from William “Chip” Mellor, a libertarian-leaning thinker and public interest lawyer, who told me, “From our start in 1991, the Institute for Justice has incorporated a media strategy into our litigation program. If a case involves an issue of public interest or significance, it’s incumbent upon the lawyers in the case to explicitly decide what their media strategy will be. This is essential not only for their clients, but also because such cases provide uniquely effective platforms for educating the public about the principles at stake,” he said. Mellor had one caveat. Not every case must be aggressively placed in the media, but “a decision on media strategy should be made at the outset, not late in the case or by default when media inquiries come in.”

Richard Grellner, who works for Plains Indian tribes, put it this way, “On a scale of one to ten, public relations is a ten in most significant litigation. It’s very important to remember the court of public opinion in the process. It can and has been determinative in a high number of cases.”

Fellow Oklahoman, Bruce W. Day, a busy litigator in securities cases, reflected, “Public relations has probably been important for lawyers for decades. It is absolutely essential today because of the ubiquitous nature of the media outlets and their vast distribution. In the business of representing business, it’s not just whether you’re legally right or wrong; it’s that without a litigation communication strategy you run the risk of losing more in the court of public opinion than you gain, or lose, in court.”

Two law schools deans, an Oklahoman and a Californian, also responded to my inquiries. 

Andrew Coats, the University of Oklahoma law dean, told me,  “The duty to represent, and the right of everyone to good counsel, is paramount. In civil litigation, without question lawyers must and should think about the impact of what they do. A case should be tried in the courtroom, not in the media, but a lawyer should have a plan.” He commented further, “The media, and the need for good public relations, is simply a fact of life in the law, and we must deal with it in a professional manner.”

John C. Eastman, at the Chapman University School of Law in Orange, California, put it this way: “A well-developed public relations strategy is a critically important competent of public interest litigation, and most public interest lawyers know that. … Less obvious, but equally important, is for lawyers involved in general civil litigation to keep an eye on P.R. Strategy. Even with something as basic as the development of evidence, the utilization of facts that advance an appealing narrative lies at the heart of effective advocacy, and this is true even if the only ‘public’ reached by the P.R. strategy is a particular jury rather than the larger community.”

Theodore B. Olson, former Solicitor General of the U.S., captured many sentiments expressed by colleagues in the law: “Important litigation and other legal decisions are invariably made in a real-world environment, in which perceptions and public opinion are important intangible factors.” Now a combatant in the high-powered world of  D.C. law at the Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher firm, Olson said, “Decision-makers form their background impressions based on a wide variety of sources, and are seldom immune from forming impressions based on whether those sources perceive a cause as just, unfair, unreasonable, overreaching, and so forth.” Olson specifically pointed to newspaper stories and editorials, and to television “buzz,” as impacting every lawyer’s work.

Some might wish it were otherwise, and perhaps none of this is rocket science, but it has made me look a little differently at the law and its development. Among other things, I’m thinking that to assure competence among graduates, the nation’s law schools might need to incorporate public relations training into curricula.

About the Author:
Patrick B. McGuigan is the author of two books and the editor of seven, including “Law, Economics & Civil Justice: A Reform Agenda” (1994) and “Crime & Punishment in Modern America” (1986). He is an editor at The City Sentinel (an Oklahoma City weekly) and a regular contributor to Tulsa Today.

Additional comments from interviews for this essay follow:


“It’s a very interesting question. Thurgood Marshall and Roscoe Dungee (civil rights leader) certainly thought public relations was important to successful litigation.”
— Judge Robert H. Henry, chief judge, 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, former attorney general of Oklahoma


“The Supreme Court piece of litigation is probably somewhat unique. The truth is that in trying to persuade the Court that a case is important it helps if the press identifies the case as newsworthy. It generally is a subtle message and needs to be handled delicately, but a well placed editorial can be very important in that process. Once the Court takes a case, then the press will naturally show up. For most cases, the media in general are not interested. But there is a specialized media in most areas of law that will be very focused and it is important to coordinate with the client in dealing with that media. But in general there is little downside p.r. risk because the press coverage will be narrow. In some cases, it is reasonable to expect that National Public Radio, and the broader media will be interested and then it can be very important what message is delivered.
“My experience in this sphere has gone about 180 degrees. When I was at the U.S. Department of Justice and handling cases at the Court, the absolute rule was no communication with the press. I thought that would carry over to private practice, but the reality is that there is some press or media angle in virtually all of my argued cases and in a good many others and it is important to make sure the client appreciates the spotlight that a Supreme Court case can create.”
— Carter G. Phillips, Managing Partner, Sidley & Austin, Washington, D.C.


“I have long believed that public communications needs to be a part of most, though not all, representations. I represent public figures and major companies who have many constituencies. Communicating on the merits of their positions, consistent with the rules and constraints of litigation, is crucial to their ability to function in their jobs and for their institutions — and it has important ramifications for the litigation itself.”

— Jamie Gorelock, partner, Wilmer Hale, Washington, D.C.


“Important litigation and other legal decisions are invariably made in a real-world environment, in which perceptions and public opinion are important intangible factors.  Decision-makers form their background impressions based on a wide variety of sources, and are seldom immune from forming impressions based on whether those sources (newspapers including op-ed, television, "buzz", etc.) perceive a cause as just, unfair, unreasonable, overreaching, etc. It is important for the advocate to evaluate all of the influences that might affect, even subliminally, the decision-maker to see his client’s cause in the most favorable light.

“Focusing on public relations also has the secondary effect of causing the advocate to think about what the message(s) is and should be, and how best to formulate the arguments so that they will be the most persuasive.”
— Theodore B. Olson, partner, Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher, Washington, D.C.


“I’ve often said that in strategic litigation the court of public opinion is almost as important as the court of law. It’s critical to align your litigation strategy and your public relations strategy to assure success.”
— Edwin Meese III, former attorney general of the United States, Ronald Reagan Distinguished Fellow, Chairman of the Center for Legal Studies The Heritage Foundation, Washington, D.C. 


“A well-developed public relations strategy is a critically important component of public interest litigation, and most public interest lawyers know that, even if they do not always perfectly implement it. Less obvious, but equally important, is for lawyers involved in general civil litigation to keep an eye on public relations strategy. Even with something as basic as the development of evidence, the utilization of facts that advance an appealing narrative lies at the heart of effective advocacy, and this is true even if the only ‘public’ reached by the PR strategy is a particular jury rather than the larger community.”
–Dr. John C. Eastman, dean and Donald P. Kennedy Chair in Law Chapman University School of Law, Orange, California


“There are a couple of aspects to your question. In criminal cases, we teach our students that it’s important that you NOT refuse to take a case just because you know it will be unpopular, that some times your client will be viewed unfavorably in the media and by the public. Everybody thinks about it, but the duty to represent, and the right of everyone to good counsel, is paramount. In civil litigation, without question lawyers must and should think about the impact of what they do. A case should be tried in the courtroom, not in the media, but a lawyer should have a plan on how to limit unfavorable coverage or  publicity as much as he or she can, and on the positive side to assure that at least part of both sides is heard. The media, and the need for good public relations, is simply a fact of life in the law, and we must deal with it in a professional manner.”
— Andrew Coats, Director of the Law Center, Dean of the College of Law
Professor of Law, Fenelon Boesche Chair of Law, University of Oklahoma


“From our start in 1991, the Institute for Justice has incorporated a media strategy into our litigation program. If a case involves an issue of public interest or significance, it’s incumbent upon the lawyers in the case to explicitly decide what their media strategy will be. This is essential not only for their clients, but also because such cases provide  uniquely effective platforms for educating the public about the principles at stake. That does not mean every case must be aggressively placed in the media. But rather that a decision on media strategy should be made at the outset, not late in the case or by default when media inquiries come in.”
–William “Chip” Mellor, President & General Counsel, Institute for Justice, Washington, D.C.

“On a scale of one to ten, public relations is a ten in most important litigation. It’s very important to remember the court of public opinion in the process. It can and has been determinative in a high number of cases.”
–Richard Grellner, lead attorney for Plains Indian tribal governments, including the Caddo, Apache and Cheyenne-Arapaho


“Public relations has probably been important for lawyers for decades. It is absolutely essential today because of the ubiquitous nature of the media outlets and their vast distribution. In the business of representing business, it’s not just whether you’re legally right or wrong; it’s that without a litigation communication strategy you run the risk of losing more in the court of public opinion than you gain, or lose, in court.”
— Bruce W. Day, Day, Edwards, Propester & Christensen, Oklahoma City

Coin challenge: Find the good

Founders of the “Character Coin” began a challenge this week aimed at Tulsa area businesses with a simple goal, “increase positive dialogue in Tulsa and surrounding communities.”
Character Coin was created last year based on the question “What if we all focused on the positive instead of the negative?”  Character Coin is the first program designed for corporate, community, and educational settings with the sole purpose of rewarding and acknowledging positive character.  The goal of the program is to actively focus on the positives in others.  In addition, the program fits hand in hand with the ongoing community character program already in place in communities and school systems throughout Oklahoma.

Character Coin allows businesses to accomplish three things:

1.) To create and be actively involved in a positive dialogue within the community.

2.) Positively influence corporate culture.

3.) Build a positive brand identity for the business.

The Character Coin initiative founded by Melanie Hasty-Grant and Ken Grant of Owasso launched in October of 2007 and in the three months following has spread like wildfire.

“In our first sixty days of operation our website, there were visits from over 20 states. We even had a coin end up in China,” Melanie Hasty-Grant said.  “The greatest part of sponsoring Character Coin is reading the stories submitted to www.charactercoin.com.”

“The purpose of this challenge is to continue the dialogue created by the numerous volunteers involved in the ice storm clean up,” Hasty-Grant said.  “We saw so many extraordinary acts of kindness and we want to keep that momentum going.”

Human heat proposed to warm offices

A plan to utilize the body heat of commuters in Sweden’s Central Railway Station is being advanced and appears to offer money saving environmentally friendly opportunity.
A private firm that owns and operates railway stations and other buildings attached to the Swedish railway network, Jernhusen AB believes the system can provide about 15 percent of the heat needed for a 13-story building currently under construction next to the Central Station.  Over 250,000 people pass through the station every day.

"It just came up at a coffee meeting last summer. Somebody suggested: why not do something with all this heat in the station?" project leader Karl Sundholm said.

Sundholm said the idea is to have large ventilators in the station suck in the warm air and use it to heat up water, which will then be shipped through pipes to the new office building.

The system will cost about $47,000 to install, he said.

"All that’s needed is a few pumps and some pipes," he said, adding the station is already equipped with most of the required ventilator systems.

Bates wrong about Tulsa County

Monday, 07 January 2008
In an oped piece in the Urban Tulsa Weekly of November 28th, Michael D. Bates made a statement which, for someone who presents himself as an expert on local government, was extremely misinformed and inaccurate.

Michael is a smart man but if he is going to be a computer programmer turned journalist, he might do some basic research.  For example, in the November 28th article he makes the following statement that isn’t true.  He said, “The County Commission’s primary role in Oklahoma is to provide limited municipal-type services to unincorporated areas.  That role should shrink as more and more of the county’s territory is annexed into cities and towns.”  As most readers will know, the unincorporated area is the area not falling within the city limits of the incorporated cities and towns of Tulsa, Broken Arrow, Owasso, Jenks, Glenpool, Sperry, Collinsville, Skiatook, Bixby, and Sand Springs. The incorporated area includes all of these towns and cities.

Michael needs to check the Oklahoma Statutes, Title 19.  When he does so he will find that the county commissioners are responsible for county functions throughout the county. In fact, the county commissioners are known as the “chief administrators in county government”. The county commission districts include all areas in the county, including the incorporated cities and towns.

The county commission is responsible for all the county buildings, including the courthouse.  So, they are the judicial system’s landlords.  Nearly all of the county buildings are in the incorporated areas.  The county commission is responsible for setting personnel and human resource policies. At nearly every weekly county commissioner meetings we approve hiring, terminations, training and other personnel matters of employees throughout the county.   When someone has a major complaint against the county assessor’s office, treasurer’s office, county clerk’s office, court clerk’s office or the Sheriff or any other county activity, the suit (by statute) is filed against the county commission.  So, we have the pleasure of being involved in litigation regardless of where it occurs in the county.

The commissioners are responsible, by Oklahoma statute, for developing and overseeing the $60 million county budget. As a practice, in Tulsa County we do this in concert with the other county elected officials as a “budget board”. The board must be headed up by the county commission chairman. Obviously, the budget board affects the incorporated areas. Only the county commission can sell, buy or renovate county land or buildings.  The county commission has the power to audit any county office, even that of an elected official.  We have excellent county officers so this is not likely to occur.  (The state audits all of county government each year.)  As you know, these elected officials are Sheriff Stanley Glanz, County Treasurer Dennis Semler, County Assessor Ken Yazel, County Clerk Earlene Wilson, and County Court Clerk Sally Howe Smith.  The county commission is required to provide court room, jail, and offices for the sheriff, treasurer, district clerk, court clerk, county clerk, district attorney, juvenile bureau, court services, judge of the district court and other county functions.  All of these elected officials submit monthly reports to the county commission as dictated by statute.

While most of the road, bridge and highway work is done in the unincorporated areas, the county does a lot of street widening, snow plowing and asphalt overlays within incorporated cities.  Recent heavy duty street projects, for example, include the Broadway Bridge in Collinsville, South Tulsa projects including a number of miles on 91st Street, Mingo and Sheridan.  In Sand Springs a lot of residential streets are being done now by the county.  Ask the town and city mayors and city managers and staff if they don’t depend on the county.

The county commission chairman sits on the Tulsa Metropolitan Area Planning Commission, the body that has a lot of responsibility regarding zoning and land use throughout the county.  The county commissioners also hear and vote on appeals made by those who disagree with planning commission decisions.

Image
Michael D. Bates
The following division directors report to the county commissioners:  County Engineer (roads, bridges, and inspections), Human Resources, Social Services (Family Homeless Shelter and pharmacy), Court Services (inmate parolee and community services supervision), Building Operations, Parks, MIS, Budget Director and Purchasing.   And, we interface with City-County Health and the Juvenile Bureau on multiple issues.  We take state laws dealing with competitive bidding very seriously. Hundreds of bid packages are opened every year in county commission meetings and many of these deal with the incorporated towns and cities. (Michael was critical about the county commissioners not putting out bond underwriting for bid but there have been no bond issues by the county in the eleven months Commissioner John Smaligo and I have been in office. I’m told that the RFP process was used previously.)

Only the county commission can contract with a government body of a city.  Only the county commission can issue bonds on behalf of the county.  The county commission is responsible for seeing that state laws regarding county inventory laws are followed.  Most county parks are located within the incorporated cities.  These include LaFortune Park, O’Brien Park, South Lakes and Chandler.  The county commission, through its MIS director and staff, is responsible for the county-wide computer system.  The county commission is responsible for approving all county bills and claims.

While only required by statute to meet monthly, the Tulsa county commission meets weekly and will do so in 2008, when I am chairman.  Prior to each Board of County Commission meeting, we get many pages of material to go over in order to approve or disapprove by vote in the Monday morning meeting.  Most of these deal with issues that are county wide.

So as you can see, Michael was very wrong about the county commission’s job responsibilities being limited to the unincorporated areas.  Obviously the board’s responsibilities are county wide, including the cities and towns.  As population grows, the need for all county commission activities will grow, not shrink, because they are not limited to the unincorporated areas as Michael incorrectly stated.

I have no vested interest in the activities of the county Board of County Commissioners growing.  I’ll expect to be retired four years from now.  However, I couldn’t let Mr. Bates’ incorrect statement about the role of the Board of County Commissioners go unchallenged.  I’m disappointed that he doesn’t do his homework before improperly informing those members of the public who read the Urban Tulsa Weekly.

In addition, in Tulsa County, the fairgrounds are owned by the county.  The three county commissioners sit on the board of Expo Square.  They have the majority responsibility for the five member board in overseeing the running of that enterprise – an enterprise which has a $125 million positive impact on the metro area.  The board, often simply called the “fair board” operates as a trust set up in 1983 as the Tulsa County Public Facilities Authority.  These responsibilities won’t “shrink” either but due to the recently built new facilities and more buildings in progress, the Expo Square activities will grow and oversight will be more important, not less.

One more thing — In his November 28 oped Michael says that I refer all inquiries about Vision 2025 accounts to John Piercey.  That is a false statement and Michael would have no way of knowing what I do with inquiries from people other than himself and possibly a couple of other people.  I do refer inquiries about Vision 2025 bonds to John Piercey because John Piercey represents the company that did the underwriting of the Vision 2025 bonds long before Commission Smaligo and I were elected.  I refer Vision 2025 account information to the county fiscal officer, Jim Smith.  I could look up the balances myself in the information provided to the county commissioners in monthly reports but I want the inquirer to get the latest information from Jim.  In the incident Mr. Bates referred to, ironically he called me asking for me to call John Piercey for him to get the information he wanted.  I was just following Michael’s request. I was in Oklahoma City at the time on county business.

Also in the oped of November 28th, Michael made some other accusations about me which simply aren’t true.  Anyone who knows me knows that I accept constructive criticism in a positive manner.  It isn’t Michael‘s constructive criticism that bothers us.  It’s his wild generalizations and assertions not based on facts that are troubling.

Michael says we don’t take a skeptical look at county government and challenge ways of doing things.  He is not in the meetings or in the offices of division heads or the fairground staff when we have done exactly that.  But we don’t agree with him on some points, and some time in the past someone in county government made him mad, so he uses the barrels of ink at the Urban Tulsa to make assertions that aren’t true.  In some cases, his facts just aren’t right, as the reader can see from his misinformation about the statutory and constitutional role of the county commission.

Tulsa Today Edit Note:
Never elected or formally educated in government or journalism, Michael D. Bates continues a career promoting fabricated negatives on Tulsa.  Primary among his victims are those who supported Vision 2025, a public development effort approved by voters in 2003.  Bates led the failed opposition to that effort and has been demonizing Tulsa people and institutions ever since.  His favorite targets include Tulsa County because the constituencies are too large for his small group of activists to impact.  While never proving charges against elected public officials, Bates has himself been guilty of failing to disclose his own interests in two published instances Tulsa Today has found to date including political payola and professional self-interest.  As marginal media loves polarizing figures; Bates has found his niche with his blog, an entertainment rag, and the radical radio station that promoted and defended disgraced former host Michael DelGiorno.

Last Updated ( Wednesday, 09 January 2008 )