Yearly Archives: 2010

Jim Marshall, Rinehart and Terrill ally, key player in Costello campaign

 Oklahoma is one of three
states where the Commissioner of Labor is elected. The position is among
the eight statewide non-federal positions voters will consider in the
November 2 election.

After the agency functioned as an extension of the state’s labor unions
for most of its history, in 1994 Brenda Reneau of Fort Gibson, a
Republican who had served as an executive with the “open shop”
Associated Builders and Contractors, was elected. She held the job for
three terms, the first woman (and only Republican) ever elected to the
post.

In the Democratic surge of 2006, Reneau lost the closest statewide election, to former state Rep. Lloyd Fields, who is seeking reelection this year.
 
In the 2010 campaign, businessman Mark Costello,
the Republican nominee, is leading in public opinion surveys. He has a
huge spending advantage over the incumbent. Reneau supported Oklahoma
City attorney Jason Reese in the GOP primary, and has remained silent since then.

In a recent interview, Reneau told CapitolBeatOK she had “cordial”
conversations with Costello earlier this year. However, she asked him
about “scuttlebutt” in Republican circles indicating that Jim Marshall, a
former aide, was in charge of the Costello campaign.

In reply, Reneau said Costello told her Marshall was “a good friend” but
was not playing a role in his campaign, save as a personal advisor.

Marshall left the Labor Department during Reneau’s tenure, and later
went to work for Oklahoma County Commissioner Brent Rinehart. Marshall
also is an ally of Randy Terrill, now a controversial Republican state
representative embroiled in a corruption investigation by the Oklahoma
County District Attorney. Terrill supported Fields in the 2006 campaign.

Reneau is concerned that Marshall’s return to the agency could
negatively effect morale and further erode what she calls “the important
work” there.

Separately from Reneau, CapitolBeatOK asked Costello last spring about
Marshall’s rumored involvement. Costello said Marshall had no daily role
in the campaign.

However, CapitolBeatOK has learned that one of the most respected and
experienced radio advertising brokers in the state was ousted from the
Costello campaign this summer – and that the message was delivered by
Jim Marshall, on Costello’s behalf.

Jon Nickens’ credentials in Oklahoma media advertising are unassailable.
His first client was the late, great Henry Bellmon, long-time U.S.
Senator and twice governor of the state.

Nickens worked for Don Nickles three times, and the same for J.C. Watts
and Frank Lucas. Frank Keating twice had the benefit of Nickens’
fact-driven but intuitive approach to radio “buys.” Other clients have
included Jim Inhofe and occasionally leading Democrats, including former
U.S. Rep. Glenn English, and the late Mike Synar.

Nickens told CapitolBeatOK, “My reputation in serving the client is the
most important thing to me. I get my clients radio interviews and ask
for the best placement of ads on each station. Since I send the stations
their money, unlike other networks, they respond to my request.”

For purposes of this report, however, Nickens’ best credential might be
his proven ability to make deft radio ad purchases for former Labor
Commissioner Reneau, who used him in her campaigns. Nickens was also
mastermind of radio strategies for the late 1990s drive promoting right
to work, which passed as a state constitutional amendment in 2001.

CapitolBeatOK has learned that in his conversations with Reneau and this
writer, Costello understated Marshall’s role in his campaign.

In interviews and a written description, Nickens described in some
detail his relations with Costello, and Marshall’s role as campaign
manager in all but name.

“In March of this year, I was contacted by Jim Marshall to put together a
buy for Mark Costello.” As Nickens explained, that’s  “the Jim
Marshall, of the Rinehart and Tim Pope group. As a matter of fact, Tim
Pope, before his death, convinced Mark to seek the post of Labor
Commissioner.”

Rinehart, the former county commissioner, and Pope, a former state
representative who opposed Reneau in the 2002 Republican primaries, were
both subjects of investigations for violation of state laws.

Costello, working with Marshall, engaged Nickens to arrange his radio
advertising purchases. At the campaign’s request, Nickens says he
“contracted a friend to produce the ad. Mr. Costello wanted a second
voice on the ad but did not want Jim Marshall’s voice. He was concerned
that the stigma of Marshall would be a hindrance to his campaign.”

Nickens “contracted Gary Owens to be the second voice. I paid, out of my
pocket, $100 for the talent. I told Mark that that was my donation to
the campaign. I am sure this was not listed in his campaign donations to
the authorities.”

Then, Nickens ran “another schedule for Mark and was asked to put
together a very complex schedule that would coincide with his speeches.
After hours of work, this was cancelled and I was out of time and effort
and long distance calls.
 
“In the meantime, Jim Marshall told me that Mark had been contacted by
an ad agency, Beals and Cunningham, to produce TV and Print Ads. I asked
Jim if I was being replaced and was told in no way would he let that
happen.”

But that was before things changed: “On July 8, Jim called and left a
message that I was to call him regarding an update. I was sure it was in
regards to the pending schedule that had been cancelled. Not! Jim
advised me that the agency had made a donation of $2,500 in return for
the radio account.”

Marshall was the one to deliver the farewell from the Costello campaign,
even though Marshall’s role was described by the candidate as “merely
advisory” and that of “a friend.”

Nickens told CapitolBeatOK that he had “never been released from a campaign.”

His conclusions are blunt, and not complimentary to the Republican: “In
my brief association with Mark Costello, I am convinced he asked for the
donation in return for the radio account.”

Pruitt gains endorsement from leader of fight against ‘ObamaCare’

 Kenneth Cuccinelli,
attorney general of the Commonwealth of Virginia, said his battle
against the federal health care legislation, widely termed “ObamaCare,”
is a battle for the meaning of federalism itself. He discussed the
controversial law during a visit to Oklahoma in support of former state
Sen. Scott Pruitt of Broken Arrow, the Republican nominee for attorney
general. 

The law passed earlier
this year violates constitutional provisions dividing power between
levels of government, he said. In discussions with reporters, he
contended the individual mandate forcing individuals to purchase health
insurance coverage or face penalties is unprecedented.

He said, “It is beyond
the power of Congress and the federal government to mandate this
activity. … Nothing like this law has even been done in the history of
the United States. It is unprecedented in its scope and impact on the
Constitution and relationship between the federal and state
governments. 

“Never before has the
government presumed the authority to tell Americans, force them, to buy a
product. The law was passed under the guise of the commerce powers.
It’s a twisting of the federal power for the government to regulate
inactivity as if it were activity.”

Cuccinelli made his
comments in a state Capitol press conference yesterday (Monday, October
25) where he also endorsed former state Sen. Scott Pruitt, the
Republican nominee to replace Attorney General Drew Edmondson. 

Cuccinelli contended, “This is not about health insurance but about
liberty. If the case is lost, it will be the end of federalism as we
have known it.” 

Pruitt told reporters he
would, if elected the state’s top legal officer, join the Virginia or
Florida cases now underway, or consider filing a new lawsuit on the
matter. Cuccinelli explained, “The entire bill is at stake. We’ve asked
the court to enjoin the entire bill. A ruling is expected in Virginia in
December.”

Defending the litigation,
the Virginian said the attorneys general of the American states are
“the last line of defense. It’s the AGs who legitimately exercise
authority versus the federal government. In the federalist structure
they are the best line of defense to push back against federal authority
that is excessive. In this case, Scott Pruitt is the most qualified
candidate. The protection of the rule of law is a fight to protect the
opportunity of all of us. Regulations always impair opportunity and
reduce liberty. This litigation is fighting against excessive impairment
and reduction of liberty.”

Cuccinelli said Pruitt
“will be the first line of defense for Oklahoma, and an ally for the
Constitution.” He also asserted, “The issue is bigger than health care.
If the feds have the power to require us to buy a product, where does it
end?”

Pruitt is facing Jim Priest, an Oklahoma City attorney, the Democratic party’s hopeful. In his comments, Pruitt reiterated his intention to establish a “federalism unit” in the state attorney general’s office. 

Concerning other possible
actions against federal encroachment, he pointed to recently announced
intentions for the Environmental Protection Agency to regulate dust
produced in farming processes. Pruitt stressed, “Although issues of
federalism are important, there are other matters that a crucial and
those will not be dismissed or ignored.”

Cuccinelli repeated
estimates that implementation of “ObamaCare” in Oklahoma could cost $500
million to implement over seven years. Based on his own office’s
experience, he supported Pruitt’s estimate that costs for involvement in
such litigation would be low: “It is not a trial, there are no
witnesses and there will be no need to take depositions. The issues
involved are not Republican or Democrat.”

Responding to a question
from CapitolBeatOK, Cuccinelli noted Attorney General Edmondson had
“joined our brief on greenhouse gases.” He quipped he had worked with
Edmondson in “a group that has my favorite acronym – NAAG (National
Association of Attorneys General).”

Pruitt, responding to a
question from CapitolBeatOK, said legislative experience is at least as
significant as other kinds of experience as a preparation for the
attorney general’s job. He said, “How do you put a dollar value on
legislative experience? Of course it is important. Having an attorney
general who has actually participated in the process of making laws is
crucial.”

Cuccinelli also
encouraged support for State Question 756 on next week’s general
election ballot in the Sooner State: “You have two governments
contending. The statute on the ballot in eight days is important, as it
represents the dignity of the sovereign, the state of Oklahoma in this
case.”

The ballot question
would enact a state constitutional “opt out” provision allowing the
state to step aside from the new federal law and its mandates.

Some of the legal
analysis presented in the press briefing focused on the lack of a
severability clause in the federal legislation, meaning that if anyone
provision in law is found invalid, the entire bill could collapse.
Cuccinelli explained: “The supporters have called the individual mandate
‘the linchpin’ of the legislation. This bill never went to a
committee.”

Virginia was the first
state to challenge the federal law. The lawsuit is pending before Judge
Henry Hudson, a federal district judge in the Commonwealth. Oklahoma
could, if next week’s measure prevails, be the next state to challenge
the bill. 

In a statement circulated
after the press conference, Cuccinelli declared “Now more than ever we
need attorneys general across this nation, who understand it is the
responsibility of AGs to protect citizens against the overreach of
Washington D.C. policies that have put a choke hold on our economic
vitality and fundamental liberties.”
 
Pruitt said, “The practical reality is state Medicaid services costs
Oklahomans more than $1 billion annually in taxes,” and “ObamaCare”
would add millions more in costs. 

Pruitt noted that last week Boeing, which employs hundreds in the state,
announced it would cut benefits and increase out-of-pocket expenses for
workers due to the new law’s costs. Concerning the recent moves to
expand federal power into areas traditionally left to markets or to the
states, he concluded, “I assure you from Altus to Woodward to Claremore
it is the number one concern of the Oklahomans I meet as I cross the
state.”

The Democratic primary election: What happened?

NOTE: Last week,
SoonerPoll sent this critical analysis of its own polling to
CapitolBeatOK. Without editorial revision or commentary, it appears
below. To access the tables and other aspects of the analysis, visit
here (http://soonerpoll.com/the-democratic-primary-election/).

Prior to the July 27th
primary election, SoonerPoll was one of several pollsters in the state
who had Lt. Governor Jari Askins losing to Attorney General Drew
Edmondson in the Democratic Primary Race for Governor.

Since the election,
researchers at SoonerPoll have been examining voter turnout and
conducting extensive polling in order find out why pre-election polls
conducted by our house and others were so drastically different from
election results.

“We have waited until now
to address the issue because we wanted to have hard evidence as to what
happened in the election,” Bill Shapard, CEO of SoonerPoll, said. “It
would be of no use to us or the public at large if we had tried to
explain this phenomenon without empirical data from the state election
board and our own follow up polling.”

Voter Turnout

Voter turnout often plays
a significant role in an election and in this election it was one of
many factors that helped decide the outcome.

When developing a voter
turnout model in the state of Oklahoma two counties, Tulsa and Oklahoma,
carry more weight than rest because of their population size.

Prior to the election,
Tulsa County was considered to be Edmondson’s base.  Edmondson won Tulsa
County with 61.8 percent of the vote on Election Day, however Tulsa
county had the fourth lowest turnout in the state.

“Since we live in a state
so dominated by two large cities, a drastically low turnout in either
city would result in a broken turnout model,” Shapard said.

Voter turnout in this
season’s primary elections was low for Democrats across the nation.  In
fact,  a CBS special report found that the Democratic turnout in
Oklahoma was the lowest on record.  Conversely, Republican turnout is
very high nationwide and Republican turnout in Oklahoma set a record
high.

Turnout was especially
low in Tulsa County, where only 19.9 percent of registered Democrats
voted in the election. Tulsa County had the fourth lowest turnout in the
state, well below the average county turnout of 26.4 percent.

Edmondson won Tulsa
County by a better than 3 to 2 margin, receiving 61.7 percent of the
vote in the primary. If that margin had held, Edmondson would have won
the election if voter turnout in Tulsa County had been 5.67 points
better, or 25.6 percent, just under the statewide average.

Similarly, Muskogee,
Wagoner and Washington counties were all counties considered to be part
of Edmondson’s base that had below average turnout.

“Had Edmondson been able
to ensure just an average turnout in his base counties, the election
would have gone his way,” Shapard said.

Getting out the vote

State election board data
shows counties that were considered to be Edmondson’s base had below
average turnout in the primary, while Counties considered to be Askins
base had an above average turnout.

In order to measure how
“Get Out the Vote” campaigns effected the primary, SoonerPoll
commissioned and conducted a poll of 450 registered Democrats who voted
in the July 27th primary and 401 registered Democrats who were likely to
vote in the July 27th primary but did not vote.

Of all those who voted in
the primary, 58 percent said they received no contact from the
Edmondson campaign while only 50 percent said they received no contact
from the Askins campaign

When asked about whether
they received mail from one of the candidates 36 percent said they had
received mail from Askins, compared to only 30 percent from
Edmondson. The same was true when voters were asked about recorded
calls, 25 percent said they had received a call from the Askins
campaign, while only 20 percent received a call from the Edmondson
campaign.

When the probability of
voter turnout is analyzed through a binary logistic regression model,
associations between the Askins campaign contact tactics of mail pieces,
live phone calls and literature and voting was identified.

Neither contacts by the
Edmondson campaign or historic controls for voter participation — age,
income, education — were statistically significant.

“The three contacting
methods identified in the regression model were more effective in
mobilizing voter turnout than any other contacting methods used by
either Askins or Edmondson,“ Ryan Nelson, Senior Research Analyst at
SoonerPoll, said.

The Oklahoma Gazette
reported immediately after the July primary on the Askins’ “Get Out the
Vote” [GOTV] strategy. The strategy was based in part on selective
targeting and mobilization of voters in areas where Askins or her
legislative allies were deemed politically-strong, and also on an
aggressive ground game that used personal contacting, mail, phones, and
literature to mobilize select voters.

“Around the margins, it
was the Askins ground game and GOTV effort that drove the shape of the
electorate in a low-turnout primary,” Dr. Keith Gaddie, Vice-President
of SoonerPoll, observed.

President Obama

The poll conducted by
SoonerPoll following the primary election asked respondents a variety of
other questions, including whether they approve of President Barack
Obama.

In the current political
environment, the president and his policies have become the focus of
political debate from the national to the local level. The president’s
approval rating, while never strong among voters in Oklahoma,
nonetheless has consequences for Democratic voter participation in
November.

The poll results reveal
that those with strong opinions for or against the president were more
likely to vote than those with weaker or no opinions.

Primary voters who
strongly support Obama were more likely to prefer Askins over Edmondson
with few undecided, while voters who strongly oppose Obama were evenly
split with about a third in favor of Askins, about a third in favor of
Edmondson and about a third undecided.

“Obama had a polarizing
effect on the Democrat electorate, those undecided Democratic Primary
voters who oppose Obama had difficulty picking a candidate because
neither candidate represented the anti-Obama candidate,” Shapard
said.  “For obvious political reasons, neither Askins nor Edmondson
wanted to distance themselves from their party in Washington or Obama.”

When the Obama approval ratings are compared to how Democrats intend to vote in November a similar trend is revealed.

Those who strongly
approve of Obama are more likely to say they will vote for Askins,
inversely, Democrats that do not approve of Obama are more likely to
either support Mary Fallin or be undecided.

“Right now, polling shows
that Mary Fallin is receiving a large number of crossover votes from
Democrats who are unsatisfied with Obama and have nowhere else to turn,”
Shapard said.

Gaddie agrees, and sees
this as a hurdle for all Democratic competitors this November. “The
challenge for Democrats on the ballot, including Ms. Askins, is to
figure out how to invigorate and mobilize these Democrats, who need to
turnout and support her at an 85 percent clip to prevail in November,”
Gaddie said.

Impact on the general election

When the respondents who
voted in the primary election were asked who they plan to vote for in
the general election, 57 percent said Askins and 24 percent said Fallin
while 20 percent remained undecided. Of those who did not vote, 46
percent said Askins and 28 percent said Fallin while 26 percent remained
undecided.

A deeper look into
secondary polling data indicates that Democrats who stayed home in the
primary election were ‘disenfranchised’ with the party.  Non-voters were
slightly more likely to be conservative, disapprove of Obama, and not
have a preference in the primary.

“The large number of
undecideds and Fallin supporters among those who did not vote, indicates
that many Democrats may have sat out of the primary election because
they anticipated voting Republican in November regardless of who the
candidate was,” Shapard said.

In the 2008 election,
49.3 percent of Democrats, 43.8 percent of Republicans, and 6.7 percent
of Independents turned out to vote. Using that turn out model and the
rule of thumb that 90 percent of Republicans will vote for the
Republican candidate and Democrats and Republicans will split the
Independent vote, Republicans need as little as 15 percent of Democratic
votes to win the election.

Historically, statewide
Republican candidates have needed a much larger percent of the
Democratic vote to win. That amount has slowly decreased overtime as
Republicans have increased in registration while Democratic turnout has
dropped.

With 24 percent of
Democratic voters and 28 percent Democratic non-voters in favor of the
Republican nominee, the 15 point threshold is a daunting figure. The
most recent SoonerPoll conducted earlier this month shows 31.2 percent
of Democrats are now in favor Fallin, raising the hurdle even higher for
the Askins campaign.

“Right now the election
is Fallin’s to lose,” Shapard said. “She has a 17.3 percent crossover
advantage and has the support of both Republicans and Democrats who do
not approve of the president,” Shapard said.

The Fallin campaign has
been able to capitalize on the low approval of Obama among
Democrats. Conservative political groups unaffiliated with Fallin’s
campaign have been running commercials which link Askins to Obama. so
far the commercials have been effective and will probably continue to be
until Askins makes an effort to distance herself from the president.

“If Askins has any hope
of making up ground in this race she is going to have to focus within
her own party,” Shapard said. “Democrats like Joe Manchin from West
Virginia have been able to overcome similar situations by giving
Democrats who don’t approve of Obama a Democratic candidate to run to.”

Gaddie says that the Askins campaign needs a game-changer in order to stay competitive in this election.

“The initial debate has
telegraphed a plan to challenge Republican characterizations of the
Lieutenant Governor that tie her to unpopular national Democratic
politicians and policies,” Gaddie said. “They were able to run stealthy
in the primary in order to break the turnout model. There is no such
privilege in a high-salience general election with an energized
conservative electorate. They have to move, aggressively and in the
open, if they want to overcome the ambivalence of a significant and
important portion of the Democratic electorate.”

Following the
election SoonerPoll commissioned and conducted a poll of 450 registered
Democrats who voted in the July 27th Primary and 401 registered
Democrats who were likely to vote in the July 27th primary but did not. 
The scientific study used live interviewers by telephone from, 2010 and
has a margin of error of ± 4.62 percent among those who voted and ±
4.89 percent among those who did not vote.

Atheist In The Woods

An atheist was walking through the woods.

"What majestic trees!  What powerful rivers!  What beautiful animals," he said to himself.

As he was walking alongside the river, he heard a rustling in the bushes behind him.

He turned to look.  He saw a 7-foot grizzly bear begin to charge towards him.

He ran as fast as he could up the path.  He looked over his shoulder and saw that the bear was closing in on him.

He looked over his shoulder again and the bear was even closer.

He tripped and fell on the ground.

He rolled over to pick himself up, but he saw that the bear was right on top of him, reaching for him with his left paw and raising his right paw to strike him.

At that instant moment, the Atheist cried out, "Oh my God!"

Time stopped.
The bear froze.
The forest was silent.

As a bright light shone upon the man, a voice came out of the sky.  "You deny my existence for all these years, teach others I don’t exist and even credit creation to cosmic accident.  Do you expect me to help you out of this predicament?  Am I to count you as a believer?"

The atheist looked directly into the light, and said, "It would be hypocritical of me to suddenly ask you to treat me as a Christian now, but perhaps you could make the BEAR a Christian?"

"Very well," said the voice.

The light went out.  The sounds of the forest resumed.  And the bear dropped his right paw, brought both paws together, bowed his head and spoke saying, "’Lord bless this food, which I am about to receive from Thy bounty through Christ our Lord, Amen." 

Regional 2010 Campaign Review

Editor’s Note: As early voting gets underway now through November 1, Crain explores growing voter significance of the Southern Midwest that consists of Oklahoma, Arkansas, Texas, and Louisiana.

Teaching children to be polite is viewed as critical, but they must be able to defend themselves as well.  As elementary as it may seem, it is a lot like the resounding messages in the 2010 campaign:  Speak up.  Vote.  Defend.

The cold realization in politics is that no candidate gets it done alone. Dr. Michael Logan, Professor of History at Oklahoma State University, says special interests messages take a long time to reach the general population.  Once they do, they are hard to combat.  

Attack ads are on the rise and many politicians and voters are not equipped to process or repeal them.  One just recently attacked Arkansas Senator Blanche Lincoln for voting 83% of the time with the President.

There is an idea that once we elect a representative, we can trust them to make decisions.  That is not a universally held notion, Dr. Logan said.  A secondary view is that a candidate represents the voter’s interest exclusively.

The problem with the second notion is that it does not allow a candidate independent thoughts. Instead, they must be a microphone for a particular district.  What is missing are the moderates.

Logan continued, “I would only challenge a candidate’s voting record on specific votes, absences or missed votes.  That’s the kind of thing you want to criticize.  Were they there to do the job and did they get results?”
 
Interestingly enough, a study of personality types found that as a group both politicians and serial killers scored the highest in areas such as superficial charm, exaggerated sense of self worth, glibness, lying, lack of remorse, and manipulation of others.

It takes a certain personality type to survive in some of these campaigns and against some of these candidates.  According to Dr. Logan, even those who have the best of intentions, often cannot fulfill their promises once elected.

2010 election results will have significant influence over who holds power in Washington next year and who will sit in the Oval office after 2012.  The Washington Post reports a total of 37 senate seats, 435 house of representative seats, and 37 governor seats open in this election.

Senate races in the lower Midwest, an area consisting of Texas, Oklahoma, Arkansas, and Louisiana have historically received less attention than the I-70 corridor.

Of 16 elections in the lower region, only five were won by Democrats in the last election cycle. (Comparing Presidential, Gubernatorial and Senate races)  Of the four states, Republicans won all of the Texas, Louisiana and Oklahoma elections, with the exception that Democrats won one race in both Oklahoma and Louisiana.

Election Highlights In Arkansas
Of the four state region, Arkansas is the most Democratic. (comparing presidential, gubernatorial, and senate races). As a result, there’s potential for substantial pressure from political groups who are not part of that Democratic minority. 

During the 2010 election debates last week at the University of Central Arkansas, Pat O’Brien, the Pulaski County Circuit Clerk and Democratic nominee for Secretary of State, said that he felt he had been queried more than any other candidate who has run for that office. He is currently running against Republican Mark Martin.

While Democrats in the state have come under intense scrutiny by the Republican Party for alleged misuse of state vehicles and funds, O’Brien has been one of the few to avoid formal charges. He plans to restrict state vehicle usage in the Secretary of State’s office if elected. “This plan is consistent with my previous record on open and accountable government,” he said. “We want to save taxpayer dollars by ensuring there is no abuse of vehicles.”

Although he continues to provide impressive service to tax payers, he remains vulnerable as a result of his party affiliations.

“There are rules about state and elected employees. The idea of doing political work on the job is not acceptable if you are a state or elected official. Outside of the regular 8-5, however, you can be who you want to be,” Dr. Logan said. “There are two notions that politicians play with. One is that I am not paid to represent the Department’s views on my private time and a second is that I don’t have to leave my identity behind at the office.”

He continued, “Politicians frequently display an official title to the benefit of their party leaders. As long as they are not on the job, there is nothing wrong with it. People may try to imply something is wrong, but it is not against the law to support another politician on your own time.”

That position is always going to be somewhat subjective, Dr. Logan said. It’s like being a judge. They should never be elected. As soon as you insert a judge into a campaign, you open the door to all kinds of shenanigans. In Oklahoma, it is unseemly in many cases because you have what should be nonpartisan representatives engaged in partisan activity.

When it comes to the Senate races, Arkansas has four candidates: Blanche Lincoln, (D), John Boozman (R), John Gray (G), and Trevor Drown (I).  All support transparency in political ads and cutting the budget. Only one in the four support Obamacare. The rest are for individual plans, such as getting rid of insurance companies or implementing a state mandated program.

“In 2010, will the five of the 16 elections drop to three or two Democrats and would that then be the bottom for Democrats and will they then start to come back to power? That is what we can’t say.  When you have a 16-5 divide between Republican and Democrat elections, well that looks like we are close to the bottom, if we are not there right now,” Dr. Logan said.  “Historians are terrible at looking at the future. I would just say that is part of the long standing development that is coming to a peek.”

Highlights of the Oklahoma Senate Race
In Oklahoma, if past numbers are any indication of future progress, Dr. Tom Coburn, a 62 year old physician and Republican, is certainly the favorite for the Oklahoma senate seat. His fundraising is also much more substantial than Democratic and Independent opponents.

“Coburn is a great example of how difficult it is to be a politician,” Dr. Logan said. “It’s an intellectual exercise for me to watch him try to accomplish something.  He’s beating his head against the wall, but he speaks effectively to his constituents.”

Coburn is a social and fiscal conservative.  He opposes deficit spending, gay marriage, and “pork barrel projects.”  He is pro-life, supports term limits, gun rights, and the death penalty.

Jim Rogers, a retired teacher, from Mid-West City is the Democratic nominee, who won with 66 percent of the vote.  Ronald Dwyer, an activist and Stephen Wallace, a businessman, both of Tulsa, are running as independent candidates and will be on the general election ballot.  This will be Coburn’s second and, by his choice, final term if elected.

Highlights of the Louisiana Senate Race
The race between David Vitter (R ) and Charles Melancon (D) for the Louisiana senate seat is going to be one of the most closely watched in the country according to sources in Louisiana.

Vitter, with a little more than $5 million, has more than double the amount of campaign funding than Melancon, with just over $2 million.
 
Vitter’s campaign is one that opposes wasteful government spending, implements a jobs plan, provides no pay raises for Congress, supports the right to bear arms and the Tea Party.

Melancon, a three time blue dog Democrat, was elected in 2004 and then re-elected two more times.  One of his leading platform initiatives is that he would like to bring honor back to Louisiana – whatever that means. 

Although he describes himself as a conservative, Vitter, a Harvard and Oxford-educated Rhodes Scholar, is said to be more reserved than Melancon, who has a wife named Peachy.  William Mcshan is the Reform Party candidate out of Louisiana, promising honest and accountable alternatives to establishment politicians such as Vitter.  Randall Todd Hayes, a libertarian, is working to make sure debates are open to more than just two candidates.

Hayes says half the states in which U.S. Senate or Gubernatorial debates are being held this year, at least one minor party or independent candidate has been included in at least one such debate.  He is running to make sure public forums are expanded to include more candidates so that voters can make better choices.

Highlights of Texas 2010 Elections
Although Rick Perry and Bill White are squaring off in the Governor’s race, there are no senate seats up for election in Texas.

Overall, of the 37 Senate races across the United States, 28 were previously won by Republicans and 9 by Democrats.  Of the four states reviewed, Arkansas and Oklahoma are the most similar to each other, with a Republican majority in the Presidential and a Democratic majority in the Gubernatorial race. Louisiana and Texas are similar in that they both share a Republican majority in previous Presidential and Gubernatorial elections.


About the Writer:

Tracy Crain is a print reporter and regular contributor to Tulsa Today. Throughout her career, she has served as a features writer, a web producer and a creative copywriter. An award winning journalist, her work has appeared in publications nationally, has aired on television stations across the country, and has been regularly featured on Sirius Satellite Radio. She has a Master‘s Degree in Journalism and advanced training in Psychology and Research from Memphis State.