Yearly Archives: 2009

REVIEW: Food, Inc.

REVIEW: Food, Inc.
United States, 2009
Directed By: Robert Kenner
Written By: Robert Kenner
Starring: Eric Schlosser, Michael Pollan
Running Time: 94 minutes
Rated PG for some thematic material and disturbing images
(4 ½ out of 5 stars)

A personal note about myself: I spent a year and a half of my life as a full vegetarian. I don’t like talking about it, for a number of reasons, not the least of which is that every time I mentioned it, someone would immediately demand to know “Why!?”

Everyone had different reasons for asking: sometimes they were genuinely curious and wanted to get to know me better; sometimes they were eighth-generation beef-farming Republicans who felt the need to refute every opinion I had; sometimes they were crazy hippies eagerly hoping that I would join whatever flavor-of-the-month protest they were planning.
But regardless, it was a question I quickly tired of answering. I shouldn’t have to justify my personal choices to everyone I meet on the street.

But, since I know you’re all waiting for me to tell you why, I can tell you in three words (though I’m afraid they’ll seem terribly unoriginal): Fast Food Nation, the damning exposé of the food industry published by Eric Schlosser in 2001. Or, more accurately, a review of it.

In fact, I can still pinpoint the single sentence in the review that pushed me into veggie-dom: “The problem starts, to oversimplify a tad, when cattle are fed excrement, the corpses of dead cats and dogs, and animal blood.”

I was in high school at the time, and frankly, had never thought particularly hard about where my food was coming from before that moment (I had been far too busy establishing my identity, so that the adult world could crush it a few years later).

That sentence was enough to get me to give up meat — and give it up hard — for a long time.

I eventually “came around” for a number of reasons (I have a lean, muscular build that requires a lot of protein; I realized that being choosy about my food was essentially First-World elitism; I couldn’t reconcile rejection of certain types of food with my religious convictions; etc.; etc.), and in a sense, I consider the “veggie” chapter of my life to be closed.

But, in a much more accurate sense, the vegetarian identity has been subsumed and incorporated into (what I’d like to think of as) a more mature, developed me — and one that’s hopefully able to see a bit more nuance in the world.

I reacted to the aforementioned book review with disgust and revulsion; it wasn’t until my freshman year of college — after I had given up the diet — that I finally got around to reading Schlosser’s book in its entirety, and my reaction then was something different: anger, pathos.

These were problems, but not the kind that I could simply run away from; after all, the only reason to be aware of problems is so that we can work to effect change. Whether you like it or not, once Charlton Heston finishes shouting “Soylent Green is people!”, someone in the crowd has to respond with “Perhaps, but we all still need to eat.”

That is what, I hope, filmgoers will take home from Food, Inc., a new, similarly-themed documentary from Robert Kenner. Kenner interviews Schlosser extensively for the film, and his intention is a similar one: to throw back the iron curtain protecting the food industry from public scrutiny.

For anyone who doesn’t know, the factory farms and processing plants that produce most of our food are ugly, dirty, and dangerous places where both animals and people are routinely abused, and they’re all owned by an oligopoly of ruthless corporations who have the U.S. government nestled quite comfortably in their pocket.

Their stranglehold on the market has produced some of the cheapest food the world has ever seen — but it’s food with a “hidden” price tag that takes an enormous toll on our environment, our health, and our society.

Kenner’s documentary is an unblinking look at these realities, heavy on facts and broad in scope.

His pace can be dizzying at times as he jumps from the grocery store to the farm to the feedlot to the halls of Congress, but this ultimately proves necessary as his goal is to educate the American public — a public that has been trained by the fast food industry to demand everything quickly and cheaply — about realities that many of them would rather not know about. The film is a brisk 90 minutes, and in this time we see all of the following (and more):

The insides of a plant that produces “ammoniated meat product,” which is claimed to be a component of 75% of the hamburger patties on the market; Seed and chemical company Monsanto’s quest to sue their own customers into oblivion; The meat processing industry’s active and deliberate hiring of illegal immigrants, while the authorities turn a blind eye in exchange for a few token arrests; The insides of a modern chicken coop, where the air is nearly unbreathable and the prematurely fat chickens hobble around on nearly useless legs; Barbara Kowalcyk, activist and mother of a two-year-old child who died from eating a contaminated Jack in the Box hamburger.

It’s moments like the last one in particular that make the film seem, on its surface, a bit emotionally manipulative; but on the other hand, you can’t argue with facts.

Children die from food poisoning every year, and putting a human face on it is hardly an underhanded tactic.

At the same time, though, it’s hard to deny that Food, Inc. tends to aim for, if you’ll pardon the expression, the gut — attempting to disgust you first and make you think second.

It also comes across as a bit one-sided. Part of this is admittedly not its fault — as is acknowledged on-screen throughout, nearly all of the food companies being criticized declined to comment.

Part of the blame, however, rests squarely on Kenner’s shoulders. He’s determined to push organic farming, and in so doing, he glosses over some of the organic movement’s more glaring problems.

For instance: that the runoff from fields of organic crops is often as bad as the runoff from feedlots. Or that organic food is often trucked farther than conventionally farmed food, thus giving it an even bigger carbon footprint.

Or that there’s never been any evidence that organic food is any more nutritious. Or that if all the world’s farming operations were converted to organic methods, more than two billion people would starve, right off the bat.

But, as I’ve said, I’ve been pondering these questions for a long time, and there was definitely a time in my life when I thought the way Kenner does.

However, if we’re truly going to solve the world’s food problems, it will be a long, arduous process with no easy answer (much like it will be to solve the world’s energy and healthcare problems — for whatever that’s worth).

The “solution,” if I can use so crass a term, is undoubtedly going to be a myriad of small solutions, which we’ll have to enact, as a species, one step at a time.

Discovering and enacting solutions must begin with fact-finding and debate — and these are the very things that the food industry wants to silence.

This is where Food, Inc.’s importance lies. Kenner has said in interviews that he spent a large chunk of his production budget fighting legal actions by the food companies that wanted to silence him, and he even reports in the film that the state of Colorado is considering legislation that would make it a felony to publish a photo of a feedlot(!!!).

When this sort of might-makes-right censorship is being imposed, films like Food, Inc. (and books like Fast Food Nation) are both miracles and necessities.

After all, food is quite literally what the human body is made of; if people don’t have the right to know what materials they’re using to build their own bodies, then exactly what rights do they have?

In a sense, Food hasn’t earned the four-and-a-half star rating I’ve given it, but in this case, its sheer importance trumps whatever quibbles I might have with its form and content.

To a degree, it’s light on sustainable answers, but it ends with one nearly everyone can get behind: “If you say grace, ask for food that will be healthy for us and our environment.” Well, amen.

Luke Harrington is a film critic, editor for MovieZeal.com, freelance writer and English major extraordinaire who currently resides in Tulsa. Contact him at luke.t.harrington@gmail.com This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it .

Last Updated ( Wednesday, 12 August 2009 )

Economic health of Green County and sister regions

The heart of Green Country, Tulsa, boasts of being ranked the No.1 place to live by Relocate America.

This list of top 100 places to live is compiled on the basis of housing markets, local economy, and recreational and cultural activities that determine decisions of  house buyers as well as sellers.
For the region, this has become a great selling point.

It is important for Tulsans to comprehend the numerous factors behind such rankings as the performance of Tulsa’s local economy in recent times has exceeded general expectations of people.

In the past five to seven years, the local economy had done better than the state of Oklahoma and the nation as a whole.

A comparison can be made between Tulsa MSA (metropolitan statistical area) and similar size MSAs with comparable populations.

Across the country, Dayton (OH), Albany(NY), Fresno (CA), Albuquerque (NM) and Honolulu (HI) have comparable population numbers (between 837,000 and 917,000) as Tulsa.

Therefore, these regions may be considered as ‘sister regions’ as far as population goes.

These regions may vary as far as their labor force characteristics and work culture are concerned.  Nevertheless, as the classical economists like to phrase ‘with everything else being constant or equal,’ what follows is an interesting as well as insightful comparison of the economic health of these regions.

Here’s a look at the annual percentage change in total employment and personal income between 2001 and 2007 for these regions.

Tulsa MSA experienced a 41 percent increase in personal income and a 7 percent increase in total employment as against 34 percent and 9 percent in case of the whole nation.  Tulsa MSA also outperformed all its sister regions and stood strong in comparison to the state’s numbers.

Another benchmark comparison is between the GDP# growth rates.  Tulsa’s annual GDP growth rates have constantly been higher than that of the US since the middle of 2003.

More surprisingly, Oklahoma City’s growth rates experienced a steep fall between 2004 and 2005 exactly at the time when Tulsa experienced a steep rise. Here again, we see that Tulsa outperforms all its sister regions.

Local unemployment rates have consistently been the lowest in Tulsa among the neighboring areas- Lawton and Oklahoma City.  Even when unemployment was shooting up nationally during 2007 and 2008, Tulsa maintained its lowest unemployment rates in almost five years.

All of these above are economic factors that contribute to the attractiveness of a region.  Besides, Tulsa is home to the performing arts center, ballet and arenas that host a multitude of shows that attract tourists from nearby regions.

It is all these factors combined with the overall quality of life that contributes to Tulsa being the No.1 place to relocate.

This also points to the fact our local region has not been as adversely impacted by the current economic times.

This year our economy has seen the worst financial times since the Great Depression of the 1930s.  Government is floating stimulus money to all states.  There are two categories of the federal Government spending:

1. Social spending that includes spending on

– Education
– Housing and Urban Development
– Health
– Crime Fighting
– Job Training
– Arts
– Food and Farming

2. Infrastructure spending that includes spending on

– Transportation
– Water
– Energy
– Military
– Veteran Spending
– Government
– Outdoors
– Emergency Shelters

The largest portion of the federal stimulus money is expected to go towards education and transportation ($113.6 billion).  The second largest portion will be spent on housing and urban development, health and energy ($55.0 billion).

The state of Oklahoma will receive about $2.35 billion in Government stimulus money.  About 62 percent of this money will be spent on education and transportation while 19 percent will be spent in the health care and energy sectors.

A lot is going on in the energy sector and it is encouraging to see money being invested into higher education for training aspiring technicians and engineers in this sector.

Recently, the Oklahoma Department of Commerce was awarded $400,000 from the U.S. Department of Energy to develop a wind technician safety curriculum to be designed and implemented with the Oklahoma Department of Career and Technology Education and the Oklahoma Regents for Higher Education.

The Department of Energy report says "Oklahoma has the potential to become the second-largest wind energy producer, providing almost 10 percent of the nation’s electricity needs by 2030."

The Department of Commerce expects the state’s emerging wind industry to create 7,000 jobs over the next five years and up to 18,000 jobs within 10 years, with a significant portion of them occurring in Oklahoma’s advanced manufacturing sector.

This size of direct spending in the region will not only create direct jobs but also a substantial number of indirect jobs, and increased household earnings.

Every dollar spent has a ripple effect on the economy not just within the impacted region but also on the neighboring regions.

When new jobs are created a region’s attractiveness increases manifold and subsequently new businesses start looking at it as a place of destination.

Business interactions, as we know, transverse regional and economic boundaries.

It remains to be seen how Green Country will benefit from this spending and also whether or not the spending areas have been targeted precisely.

Only time will tell.

An economic impact analysis of this spending could be performed, but at the moment it is beyond the scope of this article.

Nevertheless, it is a topic of future research and this series of articles may address it in subsequent issues.

About the author
The author welcomes comments and suggestions on the article as well as requests for topics for future articles.  The author may be contacted at ananta.kirikera@gmail.com.

Learn more about Ananta by reading her biography.

Last Updated ( Wednesday, 12 August 2009 )

Jazz Hall of Fame presents Janet Rutland

Janet Rutland will bring her one-woman show Mercer & More to the Depot Sun, Aug. 9 at 5p.m. as part of the Oklahoma Jazz Hall of Fame, Wild Women of Oklahoma Jazz Concert Series.

Rutland’s show features Johnny Mercer standards such as “Come Rain or Come Shine,” “That Old Black Magic,” “Something’s Gotta Give,” and others.

Those performing with Rutland include Spencer Sutton on piano, Tony Yohe, on drums, Rutland’s sons Nathan Eicher, on bass, and Isaac Eicher on mandolin, as well as special guest performers, pianist Rick Fortner and vocalist Larry Cochran.

Come early as there will be a pre-show set at 4:30p.m.

The Jazz Depot is located at 111 E. First Street (Upper Level), with parking available on 1st Street and the GC Lot.

There is free parking in the GC Lot, which is across from the Jazz Hall.

Tickets for this event are $15 adults, $10 seniors, jazz hall members and college students, and $5 for students over 12. Tickets can be purchased at the door.

To make reservations, contact the Jazz Hall at 918-281-8609.

Not just an urban legend

A Tulsa Today Special Review

“You may want to call up the babysitter and tell her you will be a little late getting home tonight.”

Singer/Songwriter and Guitarist Keith Urban shouts into the microphone, “Cause we aren’t going anywhere!”  A bold statement, but one that he easily lived up to.

The Escape Together Tour rolled into Tulsa on Friday night and entertained a full capacity crowd at the BOK center.
The night was kicked off by multi-platinum artist Sugarland, an Atlanta based duo that burst onto the scene a few years back and has been lighting up stages and Billboard charts ever since.

Lead Singer Jennifer Nettles has an amazing voice. With a deep southern draw and jaw dropping range, her voice was made for country music.

Her vocals shined with song such as: “Baby Girl,” “Everyday America,” and “Something More,” which were all huge hit singles.

She has a way with complex notes that she makes sound easy.  Very smooth and polished.

Stand out number of the night for Sugarland had to be “Who Says You Can’t Go Home,” a song written by Jon Bon Jovi and Richie Sambora of Bon Jovi.

Nettles sang duet with Bon Jovi on the CMT Crossroads, Bon Jovi/Sugarland episode.  What made this song such a hit on this night was that someone did their homework and went out and got some great video footage from around Tulsa and incorporated it into the song backdrop.

The Golden Driller, Drillers Stadium, Cain’s, Blue Doom district, as well as many other notable Tulsa landmarks were all on display and were met with very enthusiastic screams and shouts.

It was a very high energy, new country show that had the audience primed and ready for the main event.

Nettles and Guitarist Kristian Bush are full of life and work very well together on stage.  It’s easy to see why this relatively new group has fast become a huge draw and fan favorite.

After a brief intermission, the stage was transformed. Shrouded with a black curtain, the lights went out and the crowd readied themselves for the man they had come to see.

Lighting behind the curtain began to shine and shapes of band members were visible through the curtain–images that met with an eruption from the throngs of people in attendance.

Guitar chords struck, drum beats hit, bass lines plucked and off we went. Curtain drops and the frenzy begins.

Urban appeared on the stage with blistering guitar licks and walked straight down the runway to a microphone that has risen from under the stage.

From the first word of the opener “I’d Hit the Ground Runnin’” it was a night of singing along.

The crowd, which for obvious reasons, was mostly female based.  They were easily wrapped around Urban’s finger from the word go.

Although, I must admit, I am a Keith Urban fan because of his amazing guitar work and stellar songwriting–both of which have earned him much praise and awards in the music industry.

From last night’s performance, it’s easy to see that Urban is right at home onstage and behind a guitar.  He delivers on all levels.

He was all smiles and laughs most of the night and he took the time to greet the BOK from top to bottom.

He spoke directly to those in the 3 deck, lower bowl and floor.  He even joked with the people in the suites, “Thank you for having us to play before thee.”

KU’s stage was set up in a way that allowed him to move from side to side, while he sang to the crowd.  Mic’s were set up everywhere, allowing him to entertain everyone.

The sides of the stage were adorned with ramps that led down onto the floor which he and his band made much use of–they all came into the audience to mingle and to showcase their playing.

At one point, Urban came down the ramp and began walking around the floor playing guitar. When he reached an area back by the sound booth, he stood on an island stage at the back of the room and shouted’ “Who has the good seats now!”

While he sat there and played “Making Memories of Us” and other songs, he slowly made his way back to the main stage for more upbeat songs, such as: “Who Wouldn’t Want to Be Me,” “Better Half” and “You Look Good In My Shirt,” the latter of which he again left the stage and showed up in the middle of the crowd in the lower bowl, where the crowd was singing along with the chorus of “Shirt.”

Keith has a fun time onstage and interacts with the audience in a way that draws them in and makes them a part of his show.

He’s the same way with his band members, too.  He gave each of them a chance to showcase their talents and singing abilities.

After playing a long list of hit songs that were met with great reaction, Urban stopped the show to tell us that “Since he was in Oklahoma, he had worked out a tune that we may like.”

That being said, he brought Sugarland back to the stage to help him out with a spot on the cover of “You’re The Reason God Made Oklahoma.”  (See bottom of article to hear last night’s performance.)

As the show started to close, the humble and obviously grounded Urban took the time to say to those in attendance, “We [Sugarland also] know how hard it is during these hard economic times, and it means so much to us that you still come out to see us. Thank You from the bottom of our hearts.”

Two encores followed, “Tonight I Wanna Cry” and “Better Life” both of which had a “we don’t want to go” kind of feel.

“Better Life” was stretched out with a long guitar solo and much playing to the crowd as well as a shower of neon colored confetti shot on either side of the stage.

The night was well worth the price of a ticket and then some.  Combined, the two acts played for nearly three hours.  It was a great way to spend a Friday night.

About the writer:
Ernie Osborn is a California transplant that has been around the music business much of his life. He has been in bands and currently plays guitar/sings when called upon to do so.

Photo credits: Ernie Osborn

Hear last night’s performance of "You’re the Reason God Made Oklahoma," at this address: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jwcNaYYKRHM

Last Updated ( Monday, 10 August 2009 )

Officials seek resolution on cross-border trucking

WASHINGTON – The Alliance to Keep U.S. Jobs is endorsing a letter sent to President Obama by a bipartisan group of former U.S. Cabinet members and U.S. Ambassadors to Mexico that urged him to resolve the cross-border trucking dispute.

Alliance Executive Director Steve Mulder said: "Every day this issue goes unresolved, more and more good paying American jobs are put in jeopardy.

The administration has talked about finding solutions but now it’s time to put their words into action. We hope the President will take advantage of his upcoming meetings in Mexico and urge a swift resolution." The letter sent to Obama, co-signed by former U.S. Trade Representative Carla Hills, former Ambassadors to Mexico James Jones, Jeffrey Davidow and Tony Garza,and former Commerce Secretaries Norman Mineta and Carlos Gutierrez, said that "without prompt resolution of this 14-year-old dispute our nation will needlessly suffer.
U.S. companies, farmers and workers will continue to be hit by Mexico’s $2.4 billion of retaliatory tariffs on manufactured and agriculture goods – the last thing the United States needs as our unemployment rate approaches 10%."

The Alliance to Keep U.S. Jobs, which represents more than 150 U.S. companies and associations, said it was "concerned about the adverse impact to the U.S. economy stemming from a failure to resolve the longstanding trucking dispute."

To illustrate its case, the alliance examined how one participant, Appleton Papers, of Appleton, Wis., was affected. Appleton Paper is the biggest supplier of carbonless paper to Mexico.

Kent Willetts, vice president of marketing and strategy for Appleton Papers said the 10 percent tariffs on U.S. carbonless paper sold into Mexico has put Appleton at a significant competitive disadvantage because carbonless products from Asia and Europe are not subject to such a duty, the news release stated.

"Given the state of the U.S. economy, these tariffs come at the worst possible time for our company and thousands of our employees," Willetts said. "Appleton is a 100 percent employee-owned company that has a very dedicated, hardworking workforce. Together, we are doing everything we can to remain competitive in these challenging economic times. But these tariffs are causing us to reduce work hours, and wages and jobs for our employees. Over the long term the impact of the tariffs will erode the value of our company stock in which most of our employees have invested for their retirement."

—

The membership includes these associations: American Apparel & Footwear Association, American Association of Exporters & Importers, American Chamber of Commerce of Mexico, American Chemistry Council, American Cotton Shippers Association, American Farm Bureau Federation, American Feed Industry Association, American Frozen Food Institute, American Home Appliance Manufacturers Association, American Institute for International Steel;

American Meat Institute, American Nursery & Landscape Association, American Peanut Council, American Peanut Product Manufacturers, American Peanuts Shellers Association, American Seed Trade Association, American Soybean Association, American Trucking Associations, Apricot Producers of California, Association of Equipment Manufacturers;

California Cherry Export Association, California Agriculture Issues Forum, California Farm Bureau Federation, California Fig Advisory Board, California Grape and Tree Fruit League, California League of Food Processors, California Pear Advisory Board, California Strawberry Commission, California Table Grape Commission, California Tomato Growers Association;

Consumer Electronics Association, Corn Refiners Association, Distilled Spirits Council, Emergency Committee for American Trade, Fashion Accessories Shippers Association, Fertilizer Institute, Georgia Fruit and Vegetable Growers Association, Grocery Manufacturers Association, Grower-Shipper Association of Central California, Grower-Shipper Association of Santa Barbara and San Luis Obispo Counties;

International Dairy Foods Association, National Association of Manufacturers, National Association of Wheat Growers, National Barley Grower’s Association, National Cattlemen’s Beef Association, National Chicken Council, National Christmas Tree Association, National Corn Growers Association, National Council of Farmer Cooperatives…

National Electrical Manufacturers Association; National Foreign Trade Council, National Grain and Feed Association, National Grange, National Milk Producers Federation, National Oilseed Processors Association, National Pork Producers Council, National Potato Council, National Renderers Association, National Sorghum Producers; National Turkey Federation, Nisei Farmers League, North American Equipment Dealers Association, North American Millers’ Association, North American Export Grain Association, Northwest Horticultural Council, Ohio Alliance for International Trade, Oregon Association of Nurseries, Personal Care Products Council, Pet Food Institute;

Popcorn Institute, Produce Marketing Association, Retail Industry Leaders Association, Texas Vegetable Association, United Egg Association, United Egg Producers, United States-Mexico Chamber of Commerce, United States Association of Importers of Textiles and Apparel, United States Council for International Business, United States Dry Bean Council, U.S. Apple Association; U.S. Chamber of Commerce, U.S. Grains Council, U.S. Meat Export Federation, U.S. Premium Beef, U.S. Rice Federation, U.S. Rice Producers Association,

U.S. Wheat Associates, USA Poultry & Egg Export Council, USA Rice Federation, Ventura County Agricultural Association; Washington State Council for International Trade, Western Growers Association, Western United Dairymen, Wine Institute.

Company membership includes: Altria, ALTICOR, Appleton Paper, Archer Daniels Midland, Blue Diamond Growers, Bunge, Business Roundtable, Campbell Soup Co., Cargill Inc., Caterpillar, Chiquita Brands, Commodity Markets Council, ConAgra Foods, Continental Express, Cornerstone Government Affairs, CropLife America, DHL Express USA, Fierce, Isakowitz and Blalock, Free Trade Alliance, General Electric, General Mills, Glanbia Foods, Herbalife International of America, Hershey, Hormel Foods, Jefferson Waterman International, Jochum Shore & Trossevin, JR Simplot Co., Kraft Foods, Louis Dreyfus Commodities, Magination

Consulting International, Manatt Phillips, Mars, Mary Kay, McAllister & Quinn, National Beef Packing Co., Ocean Spray Cranberries, P&G, Panasonic Corporation of North America, PepsiCo, Plastic Express, Schering-Plough, Seaboard Foods, Smithfield Foods, STR, TBM Carriers, TechAmerica, Truss World, Tyson Foods, U.S. Dairy Export Council, Unilever, Viagen, Wal-Mart Stores, and Wm. Wrigley Jr. Co.